Why are cooked foods unacceptable? I'm looking for links to an actual study on the matter. Thanks for any info you may be able to provide
Looking for hard science: Feeding
- J-P
- Former Staff Member
- Posts: 5626
- Joined: Tue Oct 13, 2009 12:21 am
- Gender: Male
- Location (country): Japan
- Location: Sasebo, Nagasaki, Japan
Looking for hard science: Feeding
Raw vs cooked foods.
Why are cooked foods unacceptable? I'm looking for links to an actual study on the matter. Thanks for any info you may be able to provide
Why are cooked foods unacceptable? I'm looking for links to an actual study on the matter. Thanks for any info you may be able to provide
if you follow me, you avoid stepping in the crap that I just did...
https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCZR55G ... pqlgec1A2Q
https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCZR55G ... pqlgec1A2Q
-
SammyDee
- Mbu Puffer
- Posts: 1073
- Joined: Thu Sep 10, 2009 1:50 am
- Gender: Male
- My Puffers: 55g (2) GSP, (2) Maroon Clownfish, (1) blue damsel, And some soft corals and 1 Nem
45g FW community
20g snail and shrimp breeding tank for puffers - Location (country): USA USA USA USA
- Location: Detroit, Michigan
Re: Looking for hard science: Feeding
Its a fact that any foods once cooked lose a ton of nutrition(even for us). IF you watch "The Gerson Therapy" It talks about foods and how they are best raw. They even did xrays showing the energy/aura around it and it was way bright when raw. Some ppl dont believe in auras n stuff but its a fact proven thing that can be photographed, it proves all living things have a energy around them radiating from the inside out. THEY did a carrot for example. Using a fancy camera they photograpghed it the blanced it of and took another pic. The pic of the raw carrot showed a ton more nutritional valu than after when it was cooked it was reduced like 75% of its nutrition. To me it makes perfect sense. If you cook chicken in water you have Chicken Stock( chx flavored water) so basically any foods cooked become soft loose there ability to hold the good stuff and leach it out. Thats why all the hype is RAW ORGANIC FOODS right now. Although they knew all about this way back then. RAw foods are best. Look at the japanese. You hardly see FAt ones. Americans eat crap GMO foods all week long. The good stuff is natural uncooked foods with no pesticides.
"DREAM AS IF YOU'LL LIVE FOREVER, LIVE AS IF YOU'L DIE TODAY' -JAMES DEAN
- J-P
- Former Staff Member
- Posts: 5626
- Joined: Tue Oct 13, 2009 12:21 am
- Gender: Male
- Location (country): Japan
- Location: Sasebo, Nagasaki, Japan
Re: Looking for hard science: Feeding
I agree that raw foods are more nutritional for you. I thought it had to do more with "denatured protein" and the fish's ability to digest it. I searched and searched and found nothing to say that cooked foods are in anyway harmful to fish.
As far as the Japanese go... ohhh yea they have an obesity problem also. It may not be as pronounced but it is there. You know how we have an ideal weight for height and age? The Japanese recently increased the women's ideal height / weight ratio so there would be less "depression" among women. But, I digress.....
As far as the Japanese go... ohhh yea they have an obesity problem also. It may not be as pronounced but it is there. You know how we have an ideal weight for height and age? The Japanese recently increased the women's ideal height / weight ratio so there would be less "depression" among women. But, I digress.....
if you follow me, you avoid stepping in the crap that I just did...
https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCZR55G ... pqlgec1A2Q
https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCZR55G ... pqlgec1A2Q
-
SammyDee
- Mbu Puffer
- Posts: 1073
- Joined: Thu Sep 10, 2009 1:50 am
- Gender: Male
- My Puffers: 55g (2) GSP, (2) Maroon Clownfish, (1) blue damsel, And some soft corals and 1 Nem
45g FW community
20g snail and shrimp breeding tank for puffers - Location (country): USA USA USA USA
- Location: Detroit, Michigan
Re: Looking for hard science: Feeding
I don't necessarily think if its cooked it will harm you fish BUT, they'll get less needed nutrition. And it can absolutely be possibly harmful if you try to (example)feed clams from a can. Cuz they're cooked(no nutrition), Plus they sit in Salt,Water, Oil, preservatives etc. THat why raw is best. NO food IMO is good enough anymore but when its the GMO foods that are cheaper than the Natural stuff, Somethings definitely wrong.
"DREAM AS IF YOU'LL LIVE FOREVER, LIVE AS IF YOU'L DIE TODAY' -JAMES DEAN
- J-P
- Former Staff Member
- Posts: 5626
- Joined: Tue Oct 13, 2009 12:21 am
- Gender: Male
- Location (country): Japan
- Location: Sasebo, Nagasaki, Japan
Re: Looking for hard science: Feeding
The reason for the qestion was I know someone feeding that "fake crab" meat to their fish.. it is mostly pollack, and already cooked. I mentioned raw foos and they said "provide solid evidence". Opinions don't matter... they are looking for real data.
AFAIK the protein structure breaks down twice when cooking. Same with digestion and then some. If the fish can't digest cooked foods properly then there should have been a study of that made by someone somewhere.
AFAIK the protein structure breaks down twice when cooking. Same with digestion and then some. If the fish can't digest cooked foods properly then there should have been a study of that made by someone somewhere.
if you follow me, you avoid stepping in the crap that I just did...
https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCZR55G ... pqlgec1A2Q
https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCZR55G ... pqlgec1A2Q
-
SammyDee
- Mbu Puffer
- Posts: 1073
- Joined: Thu Sep 10, 2009 1:50 am
- Gender: Male
- My Puffers: 55g (2) GSP, (2) Maroon Clownfish, (1) blue damsel, And some soft corals and 1 Nem
45g FW community
20g snail and shrimp breeding tank for puffers - Location (country): USA USA USA USA
- Location: Detroit, Michigan
Re: Looking for hard science: Feeding
Oh yea there prolly is a study....Just tell him its common sense.....LOL
Yea the fake crab stuff is garbage. It has tons of artificial flavors and colors added. Why must he feed crab? why not market
shrimp, clams, mussels, etc. Its not anymore expensive than Bad Fish SCraps labeled as crab with all kind of other crap in it. Tell him the ingredients should Say : "CRAB Meat" and Not "xanthum gum and yellow #1" or whatever. lol 
You are right thou about proteins being broke down. LIke for instance humans Digestive track is not mad for meat as a dogs is. We take twice as long to digest meat than most animals....
Yea the fake crab stuff is garbage. It has tons of artificial flavors and colors added. Why must he feed crab? why not market
You are right thou about proteins being broke down. LIke for instance humans Digestive track is not mad for meat as a dogs is. We take twice as long to digest meat than most animals....
"DREAM AS IF YOU'LL LIVE FOREVER, LIVE AS IF YOU'L DIE TODAY' -JAMES DEAN
- Pufferpunk
- Queen Admin
- Posts: 32988
- Joined: Tue May 31, 2005 11:06 am
- Gender: Female
- My Puffers: Puffers I have kept:
T lineatus
T miurus
A modestus
T biocellatus
C valentini
C coranata
C papuan
C lorteti
DPs
suvattii
burrfish
T niphobles - Location (country): USA, Greenville, SC
- Location: Greenville, SC
- Contact:
Re: Looking for hard science: Feeding
Cooking denatures (chemically changes) the protein structures and can make it very difficult to digest. Fish can't cook their food (that whole fire/heat under water thing..) and shouldn't be given cooked foods. Sometimes tiny amounts are OK but for a staple it's not good. Think about humans, we evolved to eat cooked food, imagine what would happen if you ate a belly full of raw beef...your body wouldn't be used to it and, even though it wouldn't kill you, you wouldn't feel too well for a few days. A few good examples of denaturing protein is cooking eggs & pickling meats. Egg whites (mainly consisting of the protein albumin) start off as clear and as heat is applied the protein structure changes making the "whites" opaque. Pickling meats has the same result, you expose the proteins to acids (vinegar) and the protein structure changes visibly (turns whitish).
As per Dadof4
As per Dadof4
You are getting sleepy... you only hear the sound of my voice... you must do water changes... water changes... water changes... water changes...
"The solution to pollution is dilution!"
"The solution to pollution is dilution!"
-
RTR
- Mentor
- Posts: 6155
- Joined: Tue May 31, 2005 4:39 pm
- Gender: Male
- Location (country): East Coast, USA
Re: Looking for hard science: Feeding
The human GI track is that of an omnivore, not that of a herbivore. So-called "evidence" to the contrary is false. There are three vertebrate formats for the GI tract (which may or may not have subdivisions within the three main types). Those main types are carnivore, omnivore, and herbivore. The first is principally a meat eater, the middle one (where we fit) eats both plants and meat, while the last is primarily a plant eater. We evolved as omnivores, period. To say that our gut is is not suited to consuming animal protein is false, period. To say that we are pure carnivores is as false as saying that we are pure herbivores. Humans, homo sapiens sapiens, are in the mixed diet group, consuming both animal and vegetable materials.
We have no data on when in our speciation we learned to control fire (thus allowing for cooking both/either animal or plant material, or both together, but it is generally assumed to be fairly late. Cooking does allow for easier or better access to certain materials, but does incur some degradation of other materials within a given food. So it is a two-edged sword, neither positive or negative in and of itself, without careful specification of the components being discussed.
The fact that "auras" can be photographed has no implication in any supposed interpretation of their meaning or significance without scientifically peer-reviewed hard data to back it up, which so far as I can tell, is quite rare and extremely limited in scope.
Dietary preferences and prejudices are cultural in nature, and as such are widely subject to fads and mistaken inferences.
HTH
We have no data on when in our speciation we learned to control fire (thus allowing for cooking both/either animal or plant material, or both together, but it is generally assumed to be fairly late. Cooking does allow for easier or better access to certain materials, but does incur some degradation of other materials within a given food. So it is a two-edged sword, neither positive or negative in and of itself, without careful specification of the components being discussed.
The fact that "auras" can be photographed has no implication in any supposed interpretation of their meaning or significance without scientifically peer-reviewed hard data to back it up, which so far as I can tell, is quite rare and extremely limited in scope.
Dietary preferences and prejudices are cultural in nature, and as such are widely subject to fads and mistaken inferences.
HTH
Where's the fish? - Neptune
-
SammyDee
- Mbu Puffer
- Posts: 1073
- Joined: Thu Sep 10, 2009 1:50 am
- Gender: Male
- My Puffers: 55g (2) GSP, (2) Maroon Clownfish, (1) blue damsel, And some soft corals and 1 Nem
45g FW community
20g snail and shrimp breeding tank for puffers - Location (country): USA USA USA USA
- Location: Detroit, Michigan
Re: Looking for hard science: Feeding
The gerson therapy
"DREAM AS IF YOU'LL LIVE FOREVER, LIVE AS IF YOU'L DIE TODAY' -JAMES DEAN
-
Nick
- Former Staff Member
- Posts: 3231
- Joined: Sun Oct 22, 2006 8:47 pm
- My Puffers: Mine:
GSPs - Shakespeare and Jillybean
F8 - Velvet
My fiance:
DP - Emma Goldman
Narrow Lined Puffer - Ulrike - Location (country): Northeastern USA
- Location: Middletown, CT
- Contact:
Re: Looking for hard science: Feeding
As usual, RTR is pretty much right on. I can provide a bit more elaboration on the whole cooking thing, as I love the practice myself, so I do my reading on human diets, evolution, and technology such as cooking. As he says, it's really quite difficult to pin down when we began cooking. Earliest estimates are a bit over 1.5 million years ago, around when H. erectus emerged. Of course actual cooking equipment is not found until much later.
H. erectus had MUCH smaller jaws and half again larger brains than their most immediate recognized ancestor, H. habilis, and eating a raw diet is a LOT of work. Our closest modern cousins such as chimps spend a lot of time eating, and the calorie needs of a human sized ancestor with large brains (brains use MUCH more calories than muscle per unit weight) would require a lot of chewing with a jaw small enough to make it quite a labor - it would take 12 pounds of plants (involving the entire rest of the day chewing), and at least six hours a day of chewing even using high calorie fatty meats.
However, learning to use tools to split bones and suck marrow, as well as crack skulls and eat animal brains could also do the job, so this change in physiology is not proof, especially since evidence of controlled fire is rare during this period. We do know raw diets in modern humans often lead to malnutrition because of insufficient chewing and calorie intake, but this only means they make very good weight loss diets, and a partially raw diet is good for getting the widest variety of vitamins and micro-nutrients. Also, I very much enjoy salads.
Other estimates place cooking at only hundreds of thousands of years ago (some even less), but even if it did not develop until then, cooking was used not only by our ancestors but by our extinct cousins, Neanderthals, so it was clearly a valuable adaption. Studies in snakes (very good for digestion studies for many reasons) have shown faster and more calorie-efficient digestion of cooked foods, even though snakes are not adapted at all. There are also some modern meats served raw; sushi aside, there is steak tartare, first served at turn of the 20th century, and gored gored, a national dish of Ethiopia composed of small, seasoned cubes of lean beef. Prepared correctly, both are safe and delicious.
To tie this back in with something that matters, I would say it's not big deal if your puffer gets SOME cooked food. Might make for a fatter puffer due to easy digestion. But a diet of ONLY cooked foods will likely deprive your fish of certain nutrients it needs, as it's not adapted to this, so keep it to treats.
H. erectus had MUCH smaller jaws and half again larger brains than their most immediate recognized ancestor, H. habilis, and eating a raw diet is a LOT of work. Our closest modern cousins such as chimps spend a lot of time eating, and the calorie needs of a human sized ancestor with large brains (brains use MUCH more calories than muscle per unit weight) would require a lot of chewing with a jaw small enough to make it quite a labor - it would take 12 pounds of plants (involving the entire rest of the day chewing), and at least six hours a day of chewing even using high calorie fatty meats.
However, learning to use tools to split bones and suck marrow, as well as crack skulls and eat animal brains could also do the job, so this change in physiology is not proof, especially since evidence of controlled fire is rare during this period. We do know raw diets in modern humans often lead to malnutrition because of insufficient chewing and calorie intake, but this only means they make very good weight loss diets, and a partially raw diet is good for getting the widest variety of vitamins and micro-nutrients. Also, I very much enjoy salads.
Other estimates place cooking at only hundreds of thousands of years ago (some even less), but even if it did not develop until then, cooking was used not only by our ancestors but by our extinct cousins, Neanderthals, so it was clearly a valuable adaption. Studies in snakes (very good for digestion studies for many reasons) have shown faster and more calorie-efficient digestion of cooked foods, even though snakes are not adapted at all. There are also some modern meats served raw; sushi aside, there is steak tartare, first served at turn of the 20th century, and gored gored, a national dish of Ethiopia composed of small, seasoned cubes of lean beef. Prepared correctly, both are safe and delicious.
To tie this back in with something that matters, I would say it's not big deal if your puffer gets SOME cooked food. Might make for a fatter puffer due to easy digestion. But a diet of ONLY cooked foods will likely deprive your fish of certain nutrients it needs, as it's not adapted to this, so keep it to treats.
No matter how magnificent your successes or devastating your failures, the worlds' approximately 5 billion impoverished people could not possibly care less.
- J-P
- Former Staff Member
- Posts: 5626
- Joined: Tue Oct 13, 2009 12:21 am
- Gender: Male
- Location (country): Japan
- Location: Sasebo, Nagasaki, Japan
Re: Looking for hard science: Feeding
Thank you everyone!
No links to a study by someone somewhere with actual data as it pertains to fish?
No links to a study by someone somewhere with actual data as it pertains to fish?
if you follow me, you avoid stepping in the crap that I just did...
https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCZR55G ... pqlgec1A2Q
https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCZR55G ... pqlgec1A2Q
-
Nick
- Former Staff Member
- Posts: 3231
- Joined: Sun Oct 22, 2006 8:47 pm
- My Puffers: Mine:
GSPs - Shakespeare and Jillybean
F8 - Velvet
My fiance:
DP - Emma Goldman
Narrow Lined Puffer - Ulrike - Location (country): Northeastern USA
- Location: Middletown, CT
- Contact:
Re: Looking for hard science: Feeding
There is just about no hard data as it pertains to fish, only speculations and best-guesses. My puffers have gotten cooked Alaskan king crab leg meat now and again, to no ill effect, but eat primarily raw foods.
No matter how magnificent your successes or devastating your failures, the worlds' approximately 5 billion impoverished people could not possibly care less.
Re: Looking for hard science: Feeding
I think you need to look into this stuff more. The vast majority of our crops are genetically modified. Depending on your definition they are ALL genetically modified by humans. This does not inherently make them better or worse for us. Why not do some research on foods like corn and soybeans. They're found everywhere and both are heavily modified.SammyDee wrote:NO food IMO is good enough anymore but when its the GMO foods that are cheaper than the Natural stuff, Somethings definitely wrong.
It is absurd to talk of one animal being higher than another. We consider those, when the cerebral structure/intellectual faculties most developed, as highest. A bee doubtless would when the instincts were.
Charles Darwin
Charles Darwin