Page 1 of 1

Help me chose the right puffer for me.

Posted: Mon Jun 21, 2010 3:58 pm
by HGI
Greetings,

1st post here so I'll introduce myself here rather than making a separate thread.

I'm Jason, born and raised on Vancouver Island and I am now 27. I currently have 7 piranhas(1 was a rescued fish) in a 170g filted with a single fx5 filled top to bottom and sides(took the prefilter foam out) with ceramic rings. Having Piranhas I'm able to say I know how messy fish can be and how important it is to keep the tank clean for their health, so I am well prepared for a puffer.

Image


A few month ago I scored a 90g for free, as well as a 30g for free. The 90g is going to be resealed once I'm finished moving into the new house I bought (YaY I get a fish room!!) and I planned on using the 30g as a sump (as I also scored a 600gph overflow box and a return pump for free).

My whole life I always wanted Piranhas(done) and a porcupine puffer but after realizing it'd cost all my arms and legs for enough live rock for one fish I decided it might be better to stick with fresh water, witch is ok cause I really enjoy planted tanks. Next I looked up a bunch of photos and video's of Fahaka puffers, and none the less fell in love! I know a Fahaka would never be ok in a 90g for life and I am ok with upgrading to a 6foot x 2foot tank but at the same time I'd really rather not since I plan on getting another 6 or 8foot tank for a arrowana in the future and don't really want more than two 6+foot tanks to tend to.


Why am I here?

Well since I've never owned a puffer this would be a great place to start and learn, it would be 6month at the soonest before the 90g is fully ready to be filled again and I have lots of patience and I'm the type of person that wants to know everything before jumping in rather than doing something blind and learning from my own errors.

My question is simple, is there any type of puffer that would do well in a 90g for life? Would you guys be able to re-convince me into getting a porcupine? Or maybe is a puffer fish just not for me?

Also, I'm new to the whole sump thing, I'm very handy but if any of you have any plans/photos of sumps made for fresh water it would help huge.

Thanks for all the help and thoughts.

Also, really like these forums, so tidy and welcoming.

-Jason

Re: Help me chose the right puffer for me.

Posted: Mon Jun 21, 2010 5:22 pm
by pufferpuggirl
Hi Jason, let me welcome you to the forum!

Well, I'm no good with marine tanks, so I can't really say much about the porcupine puffer, except that I know it gets very large, so you would need a rather large tank.
Actually, you still could go for a Fahaka because you wouldn't need a 6 x 2 tank, all you would need is a 120-gallon, which could be 4 x 2, not that large.
Or, if you want to stay with the 90-gallon you've got a few choices. If you might want the slight challenge of a brackish tank, you could have 2 Ceylon puffers, I have 3 of them and they are active, personable and I think attractive to look at too.

It might be a good idea for you to take a look through the PufferPedia (click on the "learn" tab above) and have a look through all the freshwater puffers. See what tickles your fancy. The tank sizes are listed at the bottom of the bio. There's a nice variety of puffers for you to choose from, so have a look. Then you might be able to narrow down which puffer you might want to try. :D

Re: Help me chose the right puffer for me.

Posted: Mon Jun 21, 2010 6:05 pm
by lesleyanndunn
hi and welcome!
another puffer-holic in the making!

Re: Help me chose the right puffer for me.

Posted: Mon Jun 21, 2010 6:10 pm
by L!$A
Hello Jason, and welcome to the forum, always nice to have another Canuck :D

+1 With Pufferpuggirl, if you are willing to upgrade to a 120 I would highly recommend a fahaka puffer.

Re: Help me chose the right puffer for me.

Posted: Mon Jun 21, 2010 7:42 pm
by HGI
Yea, like I said I have no problems upgrading though obviously I'd rather not.

I took a look threw the PufferPedia, it is very amazing by the way and good work to whom ever put that together, it looks like I'm going to follow my heart and stick with my first choice and get a Fahaka. Though I would really like a Porcupine Puffer, I've never had a salt tank before and the guy at the local salt water shop said that a standard 90g is plenty big enough for a single Porcupine for life... It's just the price of live rock that really turned me off. Basic rule of thumb is 1lb per gallon, 1lb from most stores around here are about $10 (maybe cheaper if I score off Craigslist) but that's still almost $900... Then a skimmer would have to be added to that as well.

In the mean time I'll be keeping my eyes open for a 48x24x24 being a 120g, would my 30g tank still be good enough for a sump or should I be looking at something bigger?

Re: Help me chose the right puffer for me.

Posted: Tue Jun 22, 2010 5:33 am
by pufferpuggirl
I would just like to add that I disagree with the information you were given by the guy at your local saltwater shop, I don't think a 90-gallon is big enough for a Porcupine puffer. I would think 120-gallons would be a starting point and possibly bigger better for a Porc, especially when you figure in the live rock taking up so much space.

Re: Help me chose the right puffer for me.

Posted: Tue Jun 22, 2010 5:53 am
by Hilly
I think the main issue with the 90g is the typical 90g footprint of 18" width, especially when a Porc can potentially reach this size. A 90g might be good for a decent amount of time but if it starts getting to the point where its getting more difficult for it to turn the a 2ft wide tank would be preferable. The same could be said for a Fahaka getting to that size. Although transferring a Fahaka to a larger tank would be a lot easier than tearing down a marine tank with a Porc and transferring it all over to a bigger tank.

Re: Help me chose the right puffer for me.

Posted: Tue Jun 22, 2010 10:21 am
by Pufferpunk
#1, I can't imagine my fahaka living his life out in a 90g.

Re: Help me chose the right puffer for me.

Posted: Tue Jun 22, 2010 10:25 am
by Hilly
Change the footprint of the 90 and make it 2 ft wide and 18" high. With the appropriate water changes that would be the same floor footprint as a 120g with a 6" loss in height.

Re: Help me chose the right puffer for me.

Posted: Wed Jun 23, 2010 7:17 am
by Nick
A large sump would help push up the water volume and make water changes less stressful, no matter which way you want to go.

Re: Help me chose the right puffer for me.

Posted: Thu Jun 24, 2010 1:05 am
by HGI
Hilly wrote:Change the footprint of the 90 and make it 2 ft wide and 18" high. With the appropriate water changes that would be the same floor footprint as a 120g with a 6" loss in height.

Just finished moving to the new place, well that was fun.... not...

Anyways there's someone near me that's selling a 48L x 24w x 18h (basically a lay down 90g) for cheap so I'd thought I'd ask and see if the 18" height would be to short but like Hilly said I'm going to guess it would be a good idea?

Re: Help me chose the right puffer for me.

Posted: Thu Jun 24, 2010 10:59 pm
by HGI
Well, found someone who wants to trade their lay down 90g n stand for my normal 90g n stand so epic!

Re: Help me chose the right puffer for me.

Posted: Sat Jun 26, 2010 5:41 pm
by Myaj
Good deal! But do add in the sump too just because they are messy fish and can use any and all extra water volume.

So you're going for the Fahaka then, right? I would pass on the Porc, they really do need 120-150 gallons minimum. The live rock you can go cheaper.. use "dead rock" as a base and just add a few chunks of the expensive "live rock", takes longer but saves a bunch of $$. But the tank isn't big enough, and it truely is a pain to tear down and "upgrade" to a new tank, its so much easier to start with the correct size, especially saltwater.

Re: Help me chose the right puffer for me.

Posted: Sat Jun 26, 2010 7:02 pm
by HGI
Yea, I'm going to pass up on the Porc and go with a Fahaka.

I got the stand and tank all planed but it's the sump I'm having trouble with, been searching all over the internet(forums, utube, google) and just can't find anyting.... Then I come here and try these forums search menu and found this.

(This img is not mine so don't credit me)
Image

I was going to contact puffertt77 and ask what he/she ended up doing, but he/she's been Suspended and haven't been active for 12month now.

Aside that and back to the photo, I don't see the use of the filter sock but everything looks good to me and I'm down with using that plan. The only question I have is how many gallons of Bio Balls should I be looking to use in this set up? 90g tank, 30g sump 1 Fahaka. My lady works at a landscaping place and they carry bio balls for ponds for $0.10 each plus she gets discount, so there's no issue in getting them cheap.

Re: Help me chose the right puffer for me.

Posted: Sat Jun 26, 2010 10:37 pm
by Myaj
It doesn't really need to be that complicated, and honestly, what I would do instead (mind you this is my own personal opinion) is make it a reverse lighting fuge instead.

Where the bioballs are, instead you use some extremely fast growing, nitrate absorbing plants. At a hardware store you can get these clamp on lights, put a nice bright compact flourescent bulb in there, clamp it securely over the plant area, and put it on a timer. Set the timer to turn the light on the sump ON when the light on the main tank turns OFF, so the those plants start drawing nutrients out of the water column while the main tank plants "sleep". Of course, this means you'll have some live plants, which you may not have planned on.

If you don't want to do that, the number of bioballs really won't matter.. you're doing this more for extra water volume than anything else.

Some simple plans and sump explainations here:
http://www.melevsreef.com/allmysumps.html

I made my own sump once out of a 29 gallon tank, acrylic, a table saw and silicone. Not hard at all, really, if I could do it, pretty much anyone could.

Image
Image
Image

If the tank isn't drilled, I do like the Tidepool SOS overflow boxes (mine is the dual one), or I think you can always set something up with a cannister filter as well. I used that and a nice sized return pump, and sat in the plumbing aisle one night for a couple hours playing with the PVC like it was legos until I had something I liked. Don't forget though, drill a hole near the top of the output tube.. if the power goes out the tank will backsiphon into the sump, and the siphon won't break until it hits an airhole. Don't ask my landlord his feelings about people who forget to drill that hole ;)

The key though with any sump is watch for evaporation, it all happens in that final sump chamber and if it runs dry you'll burn out your return pump. So if you make your own, make sure you don't make that final chamber too small!