1st post here so I'll introduce myself here rather than making a separate thread.
I'm Jason, born and raised on Vancouver Island and I am now 27. I currently have 7 piranhas(1 was a rescued fish) in a 170g filted with a single fx5 filled top to bottom and sides(took the prefilter foam out) with ceramic rings. Having Piranhas I'm able to say I know how messy fish can be and how important it is to keep the tank clean for their health, so I am well prepared for a puffer.

A few month ago I scored a 90g for free, as well as a 30g for free. The 90g is going to be resealed once I'm finished moving into the new house I bought (YaY I get a fish room!!) and I planned on using the 30g as a sump (as I also scored a 600gph overflow box and a return pump for free).
My whole life I always wanted Piranhas(done) and a porcupine puffer but after realizing it'd cost all my arms and legs for enough live rock for one fish I decided it might be better to stick with fresh water, witch is ok cause I really enjoy planted tanks. Next I looked up a bunch of photos and video's of Fahaka puffers, and none the less fell in love! I know a Fahaka would never be ok in a 90g for life and I am ok with upgrading to a 6foot x 2foot tank but at the same time I'd really rather not since I plan on getting another 6 or 8foot tank for a arrowana in the future and don't really want more than two 6+foot tanks to tend to.
Why am I here?
Well since I've never owned a puffer this would be a great place to start and learn, it would be 6month at the soonest before the 90g is fully ready to be filled again and I have lots of patience and I'm the type of person that wants to know everything before jumping in rather than doing something blind and learning from my own errors.
My question is simple, is there any type of puffer that would do well in a 90g for life? Would you guys be able to re-convince me into getting a porcupine? Or maybe is a puffer fish just not for me?
Also, I'm new to the whole sump thing, I'm very handy but if any of you have any plans/photos of sumps made for fresh water it would help huge.
Thanks for all the help and thoughts.
Also, really like these forums, so tidy and welcoming.
-Jason






