What to do about puffers, get them or no?

Neurotic · Post by **Neurotic** » Fri Feb 27, 2009 7:54 pm

So I was going to get the dwarf puffers tomorrow, but my sister is sad that they will eat the snails. se likes the snails the most in my tank. :-/ so now I feel guilty for getting them lol shes a junior in college and she loves the snails. Im older and love the puffers.. sigh what to do what to do

LilGreenPuffer · Post by **LilGreenPuffer** » Fri Feb 27, 2009 8:23 pm

You would choose the snails over the puffers? Blasphemy!

kelsi.nikoel · Post by **kelsi.nikoel** » Fri Feb 27, 2009 8:34 pm

Seriously! Move the snials you have and get different ones to feed at the very least. :durr:

Neurotic · Post by **Neurotic** » Fri Feb 27, 2009 8:40 pm

yeah i was thinking of getting a 2g tank or something and breed the snails in there.

Only thing I dont lke is my gravel Ihave. I have the eco complete substrate but I kinda want sand now so I can see the empty shells :-p

Post by **puffertt77** » Fri Feb 27, 2009 8:50 pm

Neurotic wrote:yeah i was thinking of getting a 2g tank or something and breed the snails in there.

Only thing I dont lke is my gravel Ihave. I have the eco complete substrate but I kinda want sand now so I can see the empty shells :-p

why not just buy the sand and cover the gravel witrh about 2 inches of it?

Also buy your sister a tiny all in one tank and stick the snails from your big tank in there for her!

Then buy yourself a Puffer

You can breed snails in a square box net/fish breeding net that hangs at the top of your tank (that's what I'm doing)

kelsi.nikoel · Post by **kelsi.nikoel** » Fri Feb 27, 2009 9:00 pm

You can breed snails in a square box net/fish breeding net that hangs at the top of your tank (that's what I'm doing)[/quote]

Has that really worked for you? Im trying to breed some snails.

Post by **puffertt77** » Fri Feb 27, 2009 9:07 pm

kelsi.nikoel wrote:You can breed snails in a square box net/fish breeding net that hangs at the top of your tank (that's what I'm doing)

kelsi.nikoel wrote:Has that really worked for you? Im trying to breed some snails.

Yeah I put some Ramshore in there and they laid their eggs on the flat round stones I put in there with them. There's no big ramshore snails left in there now though as I gave in to Naboo and fed them to him but there are some minute baby snalis in there. I just give them a carrot and they love that. I also have 10 5mm cherry shrimps in there with them which are going to be food when their big enough

Neurotic · Post by **Neurotic** » Fri Feb 27, 2009 9:27 pm

I would just pour the sand over it, but physics stop me cause the smaller grained sand will fall and the coarser pieces of eco will still be at the top

Post by **puffertt77** » Fri Feb 27, 2009 9:37 pm

Neurotic wrote:I would just pour the sand over it, but physics stop me cause the smaller grained sand will fall and the coarser pieces of eco will still be at the top

Just put loads in there, it'll fill the cracks and crevises first and then build it up to about3 inches maybe more

kelsi.nikoel · Post by **kelsi.nikoel** » Fri Feb 27, 2009 10:28 pm

puffertt77 wrote:
kelsi.nikoel wrote:You can breed snails in a square box net/fish breeding net that hangs at the top of your tank (that's what I'm doing)

kelsi.nikoel wrote:Has that really worked for you? Im trying to breed some snails.
Yeah I put some Ramshore in there and they laid their eggs on the flat round stones I put in there with them. There's no big ramshore snails left in there now though as I gave in to Naboo and fed them to him but there are some minute baby snalis in there. I just give them a carrot and they love that. I also have 10 5mm cherry shrimps in there with them which are going to be food when their big enough

Sweet! Could you possibly post pictures of the box net and snails? Im just curius what it looks like.
Ive set up my snails in a 10gal and no luck yet

Neurotic · Post by **Neurotic** » Fri Feb 27, 2009 11:25 pm

I would like to see that too.

do the puffers ever try to eat them through the box? lol or look at them?

Post by **puffertt77** » Sat Feb 28, 2009 1:04 am

Neurotic wrote:I would like to see that too. do the puffers ever try to eat them through the box? lol or look at them?

No the Puffers take no notice of it although my Fake Simese Algea Eaters and Guppies suck the orange carrot poo's through the net from the bottom

I also think they may've sucked some of the very very tiny shrimp through the net

kelsi.nikoel wrote:
puffertt77 wrote:
kelsi.nikoel wrote:You can breed snails in a square box net/fish breeding net that hangs at the top of your tank (that's what I'm doing)

kelsi.nikoel wrote:Has that really worked for you? Im trying to breed some snails.
Yeah I put some Ramshore in there and they laid their eggs on the flat round stones I put in there with them. There's no big ramshore snails left in there now though as I gave in to Naboo and fed them to him but there are some minute baby snalis in there. I just give them a carrot and they love that. I also have 10 5mm cherry shrimps in there with them which are going to be food when their big enough
Sweet! Could you possibly post pictures of the box net and snails? Im just curius what it looks like.
Ive set up my snails in a 10gal and no luck yet

Here's a couple of pix of the net box, you cannot really see the snails very well and you can see one cherry shrimp that is starting to turn red, I've circled them all so you can have a look (it's still hard to make them out)

DSC00111small.jpg

DSC00112small.jpg

DSC00109small.jpg

DSC00110small.jpg

Let me know what you think

kelsi.nikoel · Post by **kelsi.nikoel** » Sat Feb 28, 2009 2:28 am

I think the net box is a really great idea, if they really would breed in there. I like how you put plants and rocks in yours

I do not like keeping my snails in a separete tank, I want to put mollies and danios in that tank.
Do you think fish and/or shrimp would eat the baby snails? Im considering a net box now, lol

Post by **puffertt77** » Sat Feb 28, 2009 4:07 am

kelsi.nikoel wrote:I think the net box is a really great idea, if they really would breed in there. I like how you put plants and rocks in yours

I do not like keeping my snails in a separete tank, I want to put mollies and danios in that tank.
Do you think fish and/or shrimp would eat the baby snails? Im considering a net box now, lol

No I asked the guy I got the shrimp from whether they would eat the baby snails and he said no, your fish wouldn't eat them either

Having a net box is great because they're really cheap and you don't have to have an extra tank with a filter and heater

The snails and shrimp breed quicker in a warm tank aswell

If you do get a net box and have the other tank empty maybe you could get some Dwarf Puffers for it

kelsi.nikoel · Post by **kelsi.nikoel** » Sat Feb 28, 2009 4:33 am

puffertt77 wrote: No I asked the guy I got the shrimp from whether they would eat the baby snails and he said no, your fish wouldn't eat them either

Having a net box is great because they're really cheap and you don't have to have an extra tank with a filter and heater

The snails and shrimp breed quicker in a warm tank aswell

If you do get a net box and have the other tank empty maybe you could get some Dwarf Puffers for it

Have your shrimp bred in there?

And I am trying to get the mollies and danios out of my SAP tank, so no extra aquarium

unless I totally get rid of them.

The Puffer Forum

The Puffer Store

What to do about puffers, get them or no?

What to do about puffers, get them or no?

Re: What to do about puffers, get them or no?

Re: What to do about puffers, get them or no?

Re: What to do about puffers, get them or no?

Re: What to do about puffers, get them or no?

Re: What to do about puffers, get them or no?

Re: What to do about puffers, get them or no?

Re: What to do about puffers, get them or no?

Re: What to do about puffers, get them or no?

Re: What to do about puffers, get them or no?

Re: What to do about puffers, get them or no?

Re: What to do about puffers, get them or no?

Re: What to do about puffers, get them or no?

Re: What to do about puffers, get them or no?

Re: What to do about puffers, get them or no?