Which puffer...
-
RTR
- Mentor
- Posts: 6155
- Joined: Tue May 31, 2005 4:39 pm
- Gender: Male
- Location (country): East Coast, USA
Re: Which puffer...
I do like the tree myself, but I doubt that I would ever house a puffer in such a barren tank. There are quite a few planted tanks with visually large open spaces - it is what gives them their "punch". Puffers as a rule want or need or do best in visually complex environments. Several do not mind open spaces, but would suffer boredom and be less active in such tanks. No puffer for me in the admittedly striking tanks such as this.
I seem to be the only one around who has not had major dental issues with SAPs, but I have only kept them with a diet of 95% keeper-raised snails - ramshorn and common pond snails specifically. I have had rare problems with them breaking a dental plate of other snails - which were difficult to mange well.
F-8s may or may not be FW, or BW in the wild. I do not know for certain, and frankly do not care. I do know that in captivity they can average about 15 years in captivity in light BW and a good (largely snails again) diet. Many folks who claim "success" in FW have never kept anything alive over ten years, if they have even been in the hobby that long. We have had folks come here claiming great luck with some bizarre scheme or another, after a few weeks with immature fish. Immature puffers are flexible,as most young fish are past early fry stages. Mature fish are more demanding, and more likely to absolutely require a suitable environment for long life and health. Setting up so that young fish can adapt to me and my care, and grow to full wild size or larger in my care, and live a multiple of their wild cousin's lifespan is my goal. I try to make the setups aesthetically pleasing to me as well as interesting to the fish, but the bottom line is the fish's lifetime well-being. Anything else is secondary.
None of my "show tanks" have ever used puffers.
HTH
I seem to be the only one around who has not had major dental issues with SAPs, but I have only kept them with a diet of 95% keeper-raised snails - ramshorn and common pond snails specifically. I have had rare problems with them breaking a dental plate of other snails - which were difficult to mange well.
F-8s may or may not be FW, or BW in the wild. I do not know for certain, and frankly do not care. I do know that in captivity they can average about 15 years in captivity in light BW and a good (largely snails again) diet. Many folks who claim "success" in FW have never kept anything alive over ten years, if they have even been in the hobby that long. We have had folks come here claiming great luck with some bizarre scheme or another, after a few weeks with immature fish. Immature puffers are flexible,as most young fish are past early fry stages. Mature fish are more demanding, and more likely to absolutely require a suitable environment for long life and health. Setting up so that young fish can adapt to me and my care, and grow to full wild size or larger in my care, and live a multiple of their wild cousin's lifespan is my goal. I try to make the setups aesthetically pleasing to me as well as interesting to the fish, but the bottom line is the fish's lifetime well-being. Anything else is secondary.
None of my "show tanks" have ever used puffers.
HTH
Where's the fish? - Neptune
- Dadof4
- Tech Team
- Posts: 2862
- Joined: Sun Oct 19, 2008 5:50 am
- Gender: Male
- My Puffers: 1 GSP (Microfiche) RIP, 1 Monotrete Turgidus (Leon) in a 30gal. 1 Monotrete suvattii in a 40 gal FW. 120 gallon BW with 3 juvenile Dragon Gobies (so cool). 55 gal with a 2" GSP named Hank. 180 gallon being set up for a Fahaka in the next few months!
- Location (country): United States
- Location: North Wisconsin
Re: Which puffer...
It appears no one answered this. For GSP's I wouldn't keep one in anything under 30 gallons, even when they are young. They do stunt easy, are some of the messier eaters, and stunt relatively easy and quickly. If you do decide to keep two I would go to a 55 gallon with plenty of cover and hunting/hiding area.bibbles wrote:How many gallons would two Green Striped Puffers need? Someone mentioned having them in a 37 gallon tank and another person said 55 when I was searching the forums. I read 30 would be fine somewhere as well, but I think they meant for when they were very young or something.
Yes, a lot of times you can get juvenile GSP's to do OK together but once they hit sexual maturity there is no guarantee they will continue to be amicable. I know people have kept them together as juveniles and had one turn on the other a few years later.bibbles wrote:Also, are there any weird quirks with GSPs like needing to clip their teeth or something like that? And how fast do they grow?
"Darwin swings...annnnnnd a miss. Boy Jim, Chuck's suffered at the plate tonight. He's 0 for 3 and I'm not sure he's recovered from that shoulder pull a few weeks ago. I'll bet the front office is re-thinking that contract."
- kilofey
- Fahaka Puffer
- Posts: 683
- Joined: Sun Jan 10, 2010 2:49 am
- My Puffers: **PUFFERS
2 Dwarf puffers, but I had an 11" fahaka that I miss soo much!
**OTHER FISH
betta, black oscallaris clown, orange oscallaris clown, purple firefish, blue spotted goby, coral beauty angelfish
**NON-AQUATIC PETS
Chihuahua, springer spaniel/dachund mix, and a barn cat - Location (country): California
Re: Which puffer...
i like the idea of some dwarf puffers for a few reasons... since they are small. they require less gallons per fish, so you could have more.... ive heard 5 gallons for the first DP, then 3 gallons for each DP after that... though some may argue with me on it... but thats what i heard from even some people on this site....
i also like DPs for the tank because if you are going to have a moss tree, it will make the tree look more proportionate. the tree wouldnt look very much like a tree if you had a 6" GSP in the tank... but if you had a few 1/2" to 1" DPs in there, it would look more substansial.... like little children running around and playing
instead of a big monster coming to wreck the city
also, if you do the tree theme, have you considered weeping moss? that would look GORGEOUS because it will look less like a kids interpritation of a tree and more like a weeping willow. the moss would kind of flow in the water like a real tree would in the wind. also, the weeping moss would probably give the DPs a little more coverage and shelter than the other moss would because the moss in the pic seems to kind of stay in a cluster... this is what the weeping moss looks like http://images.google.com/imgres?imgurl= ... US326US326
you could really run with this idea, i think it would be an awesome set up, and i think the DPs would be absolutely perfect in this set up
well good luck
i also like DPs for the tank because if you are going to have a moss tree, it will make the tree look more proportionate. the tree wouldnt look very much like a tree if you had a 6" GSP in the tank... but if you had a few 1/2" to 1" DPs in there, it would look more substansial.... like little children running around and playing
also, if you do the tree theme, have you considered weeping moss? that would look GORGEOUS because it will look less like a kids interpritation of a tree and more like a weeping willow. the moss would kind of flow in the water like a real tree would in the wind. also, the weeping moss would probably give the DPs a little more coverage and shelter than the other moss would because the moss in the pic seems to kind of stay in a cluster... this is what the weeping moss looks like http://images.google.com/imgres?imgurl= ... US326US326
you could really run with this idea, i think it would be an awesome set up, and i think the DPs would be absolutely perfect in this set up
"everyone is a genius. But if you judge a fish on its ability to climb a tree, it will live its whole life believing that it is stupid"
-Albert Einstein
-Albert Einstein
Re: Which puffer...
@busybones: I live in LA, I've called a few places about different fish and they usually either have them, can get them, or refer me to a store than can... The big city have a few benefits, but only a few... :/
@Myaj: If dwarf puffers were the size they are in those pictures, they would be my most favoritest things ever... but as is, idunno, they're just too small, and the only small tanks I like are way too expensive, like this one:

Also, I think it's very interesting, in most species the male is much more striking visually, but with puffers I feel the opposite is true if there is sexual dimorphism.
Also, as an update, looks like I may be getting a 60 gallon tank tomorrow for cheap, but we'll see, I'll have the tank by tomorrow night I think, so that'll help figure stuff out. Either way, I'm going with fresh water puffers, not brackish or marine... so long GSP... T_T
That said, those are pretty common, so it'll be nice to have something different, and if I can get a redeye redtail they'll make a nice striking yet subtle impression against the green backdrop.
On the topic of Dwarf Puffers though, they probably wouldn't do well in a tank with other larger puffers right? Even with lots of extra room? If I got a pair of those and a pair of the redeye redtails that might be cute, but it seems like a bad idea, and I just see baby puffers becoming food if they do breed... :/
EDIT: Oops, didn't see there was a page 2!
@RTR: Mine will be more complex, for sure, I'm just giving a general example, ya know?
@kilofey: I agree, which is why I'm looking at redeye puffers, given that it looks like I'm getting a 60 gallon tank... They are bigger than the DPs, but still under 3 inches.
@Myaj: If dwarf puffers were the size they are in those pictures, they would be my most favoritest things ever... but as is, idunno, they're just too small, and the only small tanks I like are way too expensive, like this one:

Also, I think it's very interesting, in most species the male is much more striking visually, but with puffers I feel the opposite is true if there is sexual dimorphism.
Also, as an update, looks like I may be getting a 60 gallon tank tomorrow for cheap, but we'll see, I'll have the tank by tomorrow night I think, so that'll help figure stuff out. Either way, I'm going with fresh water puffers, not brackish or marine... so long GSP... T_T
That said, those are pretty common, so it'll be nice to have something different, and if I can get a redeye redtail they'll make a nice striking yet subtle impression against the green backdrop.
On the topic of Dwarf Puffers though, they probably wouldn't do well in a tank with other larger puffers right? Even with lots of extra room? If I got a pair of those and a pair of the redeye redtails that might be cute, but it seems like a bad idea, and I just see baby puffers becoming food if they do breed... :/
EDIT: Oops, didn't see there was a page 2!
@RTR: Mine will be more complex, for sure, I'm just giving a general example, ya know?
@kilofey: I agree, which is why I'm looking at redeye puffers, given that it looks like I'm getting a 60 gallon tank... They are bigger than the DPs, but still under 3 inches.
- kilofey
- Fahaka Puffer
- Posts: 683
- Joined: Sun Jan 10, 2010 2:49 am
- My Puffers: **PUFFERS
2 Dwarf puffers, but I had an 11" fahaka that I miss soo much!
**OTHER FISH
betta, black oscallaris clown, orange oscallaris clown, purple firefish, blue spotted goby, coral beauty angelfish
**NON-AQUATIC PETS
Chihuahua, springer spaniel/dachund mix, and a barn cat - Location (country): California
Re: Which puffer...
that actually sounds perfect then! with a 60 gal you could make a big moss tree!! and the red eyes would also look proportionate... i was thinking you were going for a 30gal or something, so i thought the tree was going to be small, i guess thats just what i pictured. anyway... that sounds soo cool... where do you plan on finding the tree trunk? are you going to make it or do they sell them? is it just a tree branch? post pix when you get it set up??? we would love to see them... oh, what about a grassy looking moss for the bottom? and some bushy looking plants to look like shrubs, and maybe some duck weed floating on the top to look like clouds... oh man youd almost have to set up a toy playground in there for your red eyes hahahahaha man... im so jealous.. your tank is gonna look so cool...i bet it will be awesome... ok well good luck!
"everyone is a genius. But if you judge a fish on its ability to climb a tree, it will live its whole life believing that it is stupid"
-Albert Einstein
-Albert Einstein
Re: Which puffer...
Ideally, I want to find a dead bonsai tree, then "replant" under water so there's still that sexy root and trunk detail, then put the moss on the branches... but I'm not sure I'll be able to find some, have to go hit up nurseries to see if they have any dead/dying ones, or hope someone replies to my CL ad. Maybe find a cheap one to let die in China Town? Otherwise a branch, or the stock/root of a dead bush from up in the canyon would work I think... we'll see.kilofey wrote:that actually sounds perfect then! with a 60 gal you could make a big moss tree!! and the red eyes would also look proportionate... i was thinking you were going for a 30gal or something, so i thought the tree was going to be smaller, i guess thats just what i pictured. anyway... that sounds soo cool... where do you plan on finding the tree trunk? are you going to make it or do they sell them? is it just a tree branch? post pix when you get it set up??? we would love to see them... even if the tree looks a bit sparce at first, it will grow out... we would love to see it for sure... ok well good luck!
The tank is still up in the air, cruising CL looking for stuff, there's a LFS going out of business, the sale ended today, but tomorrow is probably fine i think, and there were a few other things too...
There's someone selling a 240 gallon tank too! It's got a little shelf cause it was for turtles, but I figure i could have stuff hanging off it under water, but 30x30x60 is kind of huge, and at that thickness it would get harder to see the brightness of the colors, ya know? They are moving and are taking the best offer, and i doubt many people have made offers at all given the size, so who knows...
EDIT: Oh also what do you think would be good glass cleaners? I was thinking I could put some cheap shrimp and snails to help clean the moss of food bits and the glass, but I feel the snails would probably rather eat the moss than the algae, what do you think? The tiny catfish are cute, but I feel like they might ruin the feel of the tank.
EDIT EDIT: Oh, there's a 120 gallon tank with 4 sections, I was toying with the idea of a spring/summer/fall/winter scene across the four, but that would mean the fall one would have no plants probably, which might not be so tight, and I don't know of any white moss which will grow under water, but who knows, I'm gonna look around anyway.
- kilofey
- Fahaka Puffer
- Posts: 683
- Joined: Sun Jan 10, 2010 2:49 am
- My Puffers: **PUFFERS
2 Dwarf puffers, but I had an 11" fahaka that I miss soo much!
**OTHER FISH
betta, black oscallaris clown, orange oscallaris clown, purple firefish, blue spotted goby, coral beauty angelfish
**NON-AQUATIC PETS
Chihuahua, springer spaniel/dachund mix, and a barn cat - Location (country): California
Re: Which puffer...
when i got this really cool piece of wood that i just HAD TO HAVE in my tank, everyone here told me to remove all the bark, and bake at 350 degrees for 1 hour. i did that, then let it soak for an hour, and let it dry out for a day, and did it 2 more times, to make sure it was good and dead, and sterelized, might have been a little over kill but it worked... so even if you have to buy one, you could always kill it quicker.... if it has small branches sticking off, you may have to cover them in foil or something to make sure they dont get toasted... but 350 was a good safe temp for me when i did it and i used the seccond to the lowest rack in my oven.
"everyone is a genius. But if you judge a fish on its ability to climb a tree, it will live its whole life believing that it is stupid"
-Albert Einstein
-Albert Einstein
Re: Which puffer...
Oh, haha, thanks! I was wondering how I was going to deal with making sure it was all the way dead and clean!kilofey wrote:when i got this really cool piece of wood that i just HAD TO HAVE in my tank, everyone here told me to remove all the bark, and bake at 350 degrees for 1 hour. i did that, then let it soak for an hour, and let it dry out for a day, and did it 2 more times, to make sure it was good and dead, and sterelized, might have been a little over kill but it worked... so even if you have to buy one, you could always kill it quicker.... if it has small branches sticking off, you may have to cover them in foil or something to make sure they dont get toasted... but 350 was a good safe temp for me when i did it and i used the seccond to the lowest rack in my oven.
EDIT: Well, no one's gonna be up now, but maybe tomorrow morning before I go look. There are a couple aquariums that have two tanks, a top and bottom, one has two separate tanks, the other is a breeder tank, which I'm assuming means the fish live in the top, and there's a pipe connecting them (or so it looks in the picture), and the babies can hide in the bottom via the connected pipe... I was thinking one of those might be cool, I can do the tree and what not on top, and leave the bottom for breeding shrimp and snails to feel the puffers... or just bread puffers for funsies...
Opinions?
Re: Which puffer...
OMG YES
So I got the mystery tank (not the 100 gallon) cause it was only $30, and filters and stuff for 100 gallon tanks cost much more than those for smaller tanks, the guy said it was a 30 gallon, but I thought he was wrong so I bought it! I just measured the interior (subtracting about 1.5in from the top for air) and:
11.75 x 19.5 x 47.25 = 10,826.1563ci
12 x 12 x 12 = 1,728ci
10,826.1563 / 1,728 = 6.26513675cf = 46.866478 gallons
(Exterior is 13 x 48 x 21)
I'm not sure how they do it normally, either measuring the interior or the exterior and so on, so if anyone wants to correct me go for it; I just kind of figured out what to do as I was doing it. It's not the 60 gallons I was thinking of, and it's not the 100 gallons I was lusting after, but for the price I think it was a pretty good deal, and I like that it's thinner than most tanks as it's going to be in a window so light will pass through it. Height was my main concern, usually people build backdrop and since mine isn't going to have one, the difference is negligible. The 60 gallon tanks I saw were 18 x 18 x 48, and the back drops I've seen are usually like 3-4 inches of rock and/or moss, this seems fine.
Still probably just going with a couple small 2-3 inch puffers, and this should give them enough room I hope, the 100+ gallon amazing can wait till later.
So I got the mystery tank (not the 100 gallon) cause it was only $30, and filters and stuff for 100 gallon tanks cost much more than those for smaller tanks, the guy said it was a 30 gallon, but I thought he was wrong so I bought it! I just measured the interior (subtracting about 1.5in from the top for air) and:
11.75 x 19.5 x 47.25 = 10,826.1563ci
12 x 12 x 12 = 1,728ci
10,826.1563 / 1,728 = 6.26513675cf = 46.866478 gallons
(Exterior is 13 x 48 x 21)
I'm not sure how they do it normally, either measuring the interior or the exterior and so on, so if anyone wants to correct me go for it; I just kind of figured out what to do as I was doing it. It's not the 60 gallons I was thinking of, and it's not the 100 gallons I was lusting after, but for the price I think it was a pretty good deal, and I like that it's thinner than most tanks as it's going to be in a window so light will pass through it. Height was my main concern, usually people build backdrop and since mine isn't going to have one, the difference is negligible. The 60 gallon tanks I saw were 18 x 18 x 48, and the back drops I've seen are usually like 3-4 inches of rock and/or moss, this seems fine.
Still probably just going with a couple small 2-3 inch puffers, and this should give them enough room I hope, the 100+ gallon amazing can wait till later.
- kilofey
- Fahaka Puffer
- Posts: 683
- Joined: Sun Jan 10, 2010 2:49 am
- My Puffers: **PUFFERS
2 Dwarf puffers, but I had an 11" fahaka that I miss soo much!
**OTHER FISH
betta, black oscallaris clown, orange oscallaris clown, purple firefish, blue spotted goby, coral beauty angelfish
**NON-AQUATIC PETS
Chihuahua, springer spaniel/dachund mix, and a barn cat - Location (country): California
Re: Which puffer...
are you sure you want to put it in a window? algae will grow ridiculously fast, as well as your fish could become stressed with the changing tepmeratures of day and night.... just something to consider.
"everyone is a genius. But if you judge a fish on its ability to climb a tree, it will live its whole life believing that it is stupid"
-Albert Einstein
-Albert Einstein
Re: Which puffer...
I thought about that, and the window doesn't get direct sunlight, though I'm not sure how large a difference that makes... I put a large glass of water in the window last summer (was going to get a tank then but put it off) with a thermometer and checked it 3-4 times a day and the temp never went above 80, even on the hottest days in LA. It would dip a little in the night, but I was going to get a heater anyway. The puffers I was looking at like it between 74 and 80, or a little hotter, so... that didn't seem like too much of a problem.kilofey wrote:are you sure you want to put it in a window? algae will grow ridiculously fast, as well as your fish could become stressed with the changing tepmeratures of day and night.... just something to consider.
Algae on the other hand, I don't mind cleaning the tank more often, or putting a couple guys to help me keep it clean in there... I feel like this is going to be more than just a couple pets, more like living art, given the lengthy decoration process I plan.
Also there aren't many places that aren't close to large windows in my apartment where a tank would fit since it's on the end of the building, and the one wall with no windows is a hall from front to back... :/
- kilofey
- Fahaka Puffer
- Posts: 683
- Joined: Sun Jan 10, 2010 2:49 am
- My Puffers: **PUFFERS
2 Dwarf puffers, but I had an 11" fahaka that I miss soo much!
**OTHER FISH
betta, black oscallaris clown, orange oscallaris clown, purple firefish, blue spotted goby, coral beauty angelfish
**NON-AQUATIC PETS
Chihuahua, springer spaniel/dachund mix, and a barn cat - Location (country): California
Re: Which puffer...
i have that same problem in my apartment... trying to find places out of direct sunlight for 2 55 gals and a 16 gal is challenging, especially since the living room is the only place we can put them, and that has 2 sliding glass doors leading to the patio... and my boyfriend LOVES to open the curtains. lol im constantly fighting alagea (spelling?)bibbles wrote:Also there aren't many places that aren't close to large windows in my apartment where a tank would fit since it's on the end of the building, and the one wall with no windows is a hall from front to back... :/kilofey wrote:are you sure you want to put it in a window? algae will grow ridiculously fast, as well as your fish could become stressed with the changing tepmeratures of day and night.... just something to consider.
"everyone is a genius. But if you judge a fish on its ability to climb a tree, it will live its whole life believing that it is stupid"
-Albert Einstein
-Albert Einstein
- Pufferpunk
- Queen Admin
- Posts: 32988
- Joined: Tue May 31, 2005 11:06 am
- Gender: Female
- My Puffers: Puffers I have kept:
T lineatus
T miurus
A modestus
T biocellatus
C valentini
C coranata
C papuan
C lorteti
DPs
suvattii
burrfish
T niphobles - Location (country): USA, Greenville, SC
- Location: Greenville, SC
- Contact:
Re: Which puffer...
Most puffers will eat those algae-eating creatures.Algae on the other hand, I don't mind cleaning the tank more often, or putting a couple guys to help me keep it clean in there... I feel like this is going to be more than just a couple pets, more like living art, given the lengthy decoration process I plan.
You are getting sleepy... you only hear the sound of my voice... you must do water changes... water changes... water changes... water changes...
"The solution to pollution is dilution!"
"The solution to pollution is dilution!"
- kilofey
- Fahaka Puffer
- Posts: 683
- Joined: Sun Jan 10, 2010 2:49 am
- My Puffers: **PUFFERS
2 Dwarf puffers, but I had an 11" fahaka that I miss soo much!
**OTHER FISH
betta, black oscallaris clown, orange oscallaris clown, purple firefish, blue spotted goby, coral beauty angelfish
**NON-AQUATIC PETS
Chihuahua, springer spaniel/dachund mix, and a barn cat - Location (country): California
Re: Which puffer...
oh how true that is... i put one of my large plecos in with kukah... watched them for about 2 hours, decided they seemed fine together... then went to bed... MISTAKE! we named him "Bones", appropriately named because when i woke up the next morning, Bones had absolutely no fins... he only had the bones where his fins used to be... so he had to be moved back with my red devil to heal with the aid of some melafix... this, of course, was before i knew just how fiesty fahakas werePufferpunk wrote:Most puffers will eat those algae-eating creatures.Algae on the other hand, I don't mind cleaning the tank more often, or putting a couple guys to help me keep it clean in there... I feel like this is going to be more than just a couple pets, more like living art, given the lengthy decoration process I plan.
"everyone is a genius. But if you judge a fish on its ability to climb a tree, it will live its whole life believing that it is stupid"
-Albert Einstein
-Albert Einstein
Re: Which puffer...
I'm actually going to put it in front of two such double doors, though like I said, cleaning I can deal with, and it looks like I may end up going with DPs given how things are shaping up with the tank design. http://www.dwarfpuffers.com/ Says that Otocinclus are fine tank mates, but I may also go with some Redeyes, not too sure about those, we'll see when the tank is done which puffer looks right.
@kilofey: You made a very good point about the fish being to scale with the rest of the tank, given that I'm making it very terrestrial, so I'm gonna wait till then to choose. Hope Redeyes will look OK, otherwise DPs it is... I like them both just fine, so... we'll see.
EDIT: Also some shrimp to clean up, maybe, perhaps they'll turn into food, either way they go to a good cause...
Also, I'll post updates as the project goes along... A few people seemed interested in the premise of the design, so...
@kilofey: You made a very good point about the fish being to scale with the rest of the tank, given that I'm making it very terrestrial, so I'm gonna wait till then to choose. Hope Redeyes will look OK, otherwise DPs it is... I like them both just fine, so... we'll see.
EDIT: Also some shrimp to clean up, maybe, perhaps they'll turn into food, either way they go to a good cause...
Also, I'll post updates as the project goes along... A few people seemed interested in the premise of the design, so...