Crushed Coral Substrate Okay for FW?
- rengnath
- Dwarf Puffer
- Posts: 85
- Joined: Thu Sep 17, 2009 3:28 pm
- Gender: Male
- My Puffers: Green Spotted Puffer - 1.5"
- Location (country): United States
- Location: Southeast Wisconsin
Re: Crushed Coral Substrate Okay for FW?
Let me find the post that I saw that in .... stand by ....
- rengnath
- Dwarf Puffer
- Posts: 85
- Joined: Thu Sep 17, 2009 3:28 pm
- Gender: Male
- My Puffers: Green Spotted Puffer - 1.5"
- Location (country): United States
- Location: Southeast Wisconsin
Re: Crushed Coral Substrate Okay for FW?
Here it is! viewtopic.php?f=8&t=20023
Its the 3rd post down by lilgreenpuffer.
Its the 3rd post down by lilgreenpuffer.
- Pufferpunk
- Queen Admin
- Posts: 32988
- Joined: Tue May 31, 2005 11:06 am
- Gender: Female
- My Puffers: Puffers I have kept:
T lineatus
T miurus
A modestus
T biocellatus
C valentini
C coranata
C papuan
C lorteti
DPs
suvattii
burrfish
T niphobles - Location (country): USA, Greenville, SC
- Location: Greenville, SC
- Contact:
Re: Crushed Coral Substrate Okay for FW?
Buffers will lower the pH for a time & then it is dissipated & goes back up. It is way worse to have a fluctuating pH than the wrong one. But why put your fish through it at all, if you don't have to.
Pool filter sand is found at a swimming pool supply store or hardware stores.
Pool filter sand is found at a swimming pool supply store or hardware stores.
You are getting sleepy... you only hear the sound of my voice... you must do water changes... water changes... water changes... water changes...
"The solution to pollution is dilution!"
"The solution to pollution is dilution!"
-
L!$A
- Former Staff Member
- Posts: 1045
- Joined: Fri Nov 06, 2009 5:30 pm
- Gender: Female
- My Puffers: Fahaka - Nala
Congo - Baloo
Arrowhead - Yzma
R.I.P
Kaleeko - Mbu Puffer
Milly - Fangs Puffer - Location (country): CANADA
- Location: Pitt Meadows, BC
Re: Crushed Coral Substrate Okay for FW?
I'm trying to upload a video.. it's taking longer than I expected.. 

Wow thanks! Good to know, and good memory too!rengnath wrote:Here it is! viewtopic.php?f=8&t=20023
Its the 3rd post down by lilgreenpuffer.

- rengnath
- Dwarf Puffer
- Posts: 85
- Joined: Thu Sep 17, 2009 3:28 pm
- Gender: Male
- My Puffers: Green Spotted Puffer - 1.5"
- Location (country): United States
- Location: Southeast Wisconsin
Re: Crushed Coral Substrate Okay for FW?
No problem! I get bored at work when its slow so I just read the forums all day.L!$A wrote:I'm trying to upload a video.. it's taking longer than I expected..
Wow thanks! Good to know, and good memory too!rengnath wrote:Here it is! viewtopic.php?f=8&t=20023
Its the 3rd post down by lilgreenpuffer.
-
L!$A
- Former Staff Member
- Posts: 1045
- Joined: Fri Nov 06, 2009 5:30 pm
- Gender: Female
- My Puffers: Fahaka - Nala
Congo - Baloo
Arrowhead - Yzma
R.I.P
Kaleeko - Mbu Puffer
Milly - Fangs Puffer - Location (country): CANADA
- Location: Pitt Meadows, BC
Re: Crushed Coral Substrate Okay for FW?
for sure, I try to replicate the wild as much as I can.. which is why I want a sandier substrate!!! & more driftwood. 

- rengnath
- Dwarf Puffer
- Posts: 85
- Joined: Thu Sep 17, 2009 3:28 pm
- Gender: Male
- My Puffers: Green Spotted Puffer - 1.5"
- Location (country): United States
- Location: Southeast Wisconsin
Re: Crushed Coral Substrate Okay for FW?
Try looking in to aragonite sand ... that is supposed to buffer your ph, but I dont know how much.L!$A wrote:for sure, I try to replicate the wild as much as I can.. which is why I want a sandier substrate!!! & more driftwood.
I was so happy when I went with the crushed coral though .... it made the tank look so much more natural than just regular gravel.
- Pufferpunk
- Queen Admin
- Posts: 32988
- Joined: Tue May 31, 2005 11:06 am
- Gender: Female
- My Puffers: Puffers I have kept:
T lineatus
T miurus
A modestus
T biocellatus
C valentini
C coranata
C papuan
C lorteti
DPs
suvattii
burrfish
T niphobles - Location (country): USA, Greenville, SC
- Location: Greenville, SC
- Contact:
Re: Crushed Coral Substrate Okay for FW?
Aragonite sand will buffer the pH exactly the same as CC.
You are getting sleepy... you only hear the sound of my voice... you must do water changes... water changes... water changes... water changes...
"The solution to pollution is dilution!"
"The solution to pollution is dilution!"
- Myaj
- Tech Team
- Posts: 4587
- Joined: Sat Jun 04, 2005 12:27 pm
- Gender: Female
- My Puffers: Bubba, turgidus
Paris, lined burrfish - Location: SE Wisconsin
- Contact:
Re: Crushed Coral Substrate Okay for FW?
I've never used crushed coral in freshwater, but when I did use it in saltwater I had the most insane algae growing on it. A green hair algae.. I had mixed CC with argonite sand, and the algae only grew on the pieces of CC.
I will never use it in a tank again. When I moved, I replaced all that crushed coral/argonite mix with argonite sand and never had an algae problem (on my substrate at least) again. I think the CC has a really rough surface that lets the algae get a "grip" too easily.
I found some "very fine gravel" once at a fish store, that I've just loved in my tanks. Its bigger than sand but way smaller than gravel. Plants love it, fish can burrow in it, and its not so light and fine that the gravel siphon sucks it up. Wish I could find more!
I will never use it in a tank again. When I moved, I replaced all that crushed coral/argonite mix with argonite sand and never had an algae problem (on my substrate at least) again. I think the CC has a really rough surface that lets the algae get a "grip" too easily.
I found some "very fine gravel" once at a fish store, that I've just loved in my tanks. Its bigger than sand but way smaller than gravel. Plants love it, fish can burrow in it, and its not so light and fine that the gravel siphon sucks it up. Wish I could find more!
-
RTR
- Mentor
- Posts: 6155
- Joined: Tue May 31, 2005 4:39 pm
- Gender: Male
- Location (country): East Coast, USA
Re: Crushed Coral Substrate Okay for FW?
I don't quite understand the bit of trying to emulate the wild, and wanting sand and driftwood, and the th comments on Lake Tanganyika? Lake Tanganyika is a landlocked Rift Lake, holding massive amounts of very hard and alkaline water. Driftwood and sand is a riverine (soft and acid) environment, or an estuarine (brackish) environment. T. mbu does inhabit a major river system as well as occurring in the lake. Which are you trying to match? They are quite different in water profile.
I would never, ever ,under any circumstance use commercial buffers routinely in any tank, no more than I would ever use Stress Coat in any tank. Commercial buffers enrich the manufacture and the LFS. The only thing they do for a tank is to destabilize it. Pick your environment and mix your water to match it before you add it to the tank, or do not do any water modification in the tank. To let the fish adapt to you own local water profile. is by far the simplest technique , and the T. mbu can handle a substantial range of water conditions. Those in the Rift Lake have very stable conditions, basically unchanging of very long time periods. The riverine fish however are subject to changes seasonally, from soft and acid and silty to muddy in flood, to harder and clearer and more alkaline in the dry.
Fish cannot read external pH period - it is something for which they have no sensors whatsoever. They can and do read osmolarity very well, and a fair number of specific ions, but not pH. If your fish do not like water changes, if they are being stressed by water changes, it is because the replacement water is of a different osmolarity or temperature than the tank water. That can be highly stressful to fatal. There is no such thing as "pH shock", it is in reality osmotic shock, but few hobbyists can read osmolorarity. The pH tests are common and cheap - so it is not surprising that the confusion has arisen. Fish love water changes, but only when the water basically matches their existing water parameters other than pH, including osmolarity. When I see on the web someone saying that their fish are stressed by water changes, it is to me red flag that there are basic issues with how the the tank water is managed. When the tank and the "new" water have basically similar mineral and TDS (total dissolved solids) or oosmolarity profiles other than the wastes, the fish are brighter and more energetic after a change than before - that is not stress, it is happiness and recognition of improved water conditions. In-tank water modifications are one of the most stressful procedures hobbyists can do to their fish. "Proper" water changes are one of the least stressful, where "proper means any water modifications are done before the water goes into the tank, and those changes are of a stable nature - not something like adding commercial (especially phosphate-based) buffers whose total effectiveness is measurable in hours or to 2-3 days at beast. If you want the water harder and more alkaline, add the proper mineral mixture to produce that effect on the water profile and chemistry, and dissolve it before you add that water to the tank. No osmotic change means no stress. Do not try to "fake" it by buffers which are unstable and do not change the basic water profile other than the pH, which they fish do not read. Excuse me, that is a slight misstatement - commercial buffers, by being largely phosphate-based, make it more likely that you will have algae issues due to excessive phosphates.
Pufferpunk was kinder and gentler in her comments than I am, but I would like for folk to have some understanding of what they do to their tanks, and how it affects the fish.. If you don't like the way I say things, sorry, but that does not me that wat I say is not correct. To be even more harsh, only inexperienced hobbyists ever use buffers. Truly experienced fish-keepers know better. If they must do water modification, they do so, but not with the fish present. Your big puffer can live a very long time - longer than moist dogs - and certainly can be a full member of the family even if it lives in a separate world. Treat it well and keep that big tank for it - it will need it or more.
I would never, ever ,under any circumstance use commercial buffers routinely in any tank, no more than I would ever use Stress Coat in any tank. Commercial buffers enrich the manufacture and the LFS. The only thing they do for a tank is to destabilize it. Pick your environment and mix your water to match it before you add it to the tank, or do not do any water modification in the tank. To let the fish adapt to you own local water profile. is by far the simplest technique , and the T. mbu can handle a substantial range of water conditions. Those in the Rift Lake have very stable conditions, basically unchanging of very long time periods. The riverine fish however are subject to changes seasonally, from soft and acid and silty to muddy in flood, to harder and clearer and more alkaline in the dry.
Fish cannot read external pH period - it is something for which they have no sensors whatsoever. They can and do read osmolarity very well, and a fair number of specific ions, but not pH. If your fish do not like water changes, if they are being stressed by water changes, it is because the replacement water is of a different osmolarity or temperature than the tank water. That can be highly stressful to fatal. There is no such thing as "pH shock", it is in reality osmotic shock, but few hobbyists can read osmolorarity. The pH tests are common and cheap - so it is not surprising that the confusion has arisen. Fish love water changes, but only when the water basically matches their existing water parameters other than pH, including osmolarity. When I see on the web someone saying that their fish are stressed by water changes, it is to me red flag that there are basic issues with how the the tank water is managed. When the tank and the "new" water have basically similar mineral and TDS (total dissolved solids) or oosmolarity profiles other than the wastes, the fish are brighter and more energetic after a change than before - that is not stress, it is happiness and recognition of improved water conditions. In-tank water modifications are one of the most stressful procedures hobbyists can do to their fish. "Proper" water changes are one of the least stressful, where "proper means any water modifications are done before the water goes into the tank, and those changes are of a stable nature - not something like adding commercial (especially phosphate-based) buffers whose total effectiveness is measurable in hours or to 2-3 days at beast. If you want the water harder and more alkaline, add the proper mineral mixture to produce that effect on the water profile and chemistry, and dissolve it before you add that water to the tank. No osmotic change means no stress. Do not try to "fake" it by buffers which are unstable and do not change the basic water profile other than the pH, which they fish do not read. Excuse me, that is a slight misstatement - commercial buffers, by being largely phosphate-based, make it more likely that you will have algae issues due to excessive phosphates.
Pufferpunk was kinder and gentler in her comments than I am, but I would like for folk to have some understanding of what they do to their tanks, and how it affects the fish.. If you don't like the way I say things, sorry, but that does not me that wat I say is not correct. To be even more harsh, only inexperienced hobbyists ever use buffers. Truly experienced fish-keepers know better. If they must do water modification, they do so, but not with the fish present. Your big puffer can live a very long time - longer than moist dogs - and certainly can be a full member of the family even if it lives in a separate world. Treat it well and keep that big tank for it - it will need it or more.
Where's the fish? - Neptune
- DarkStorm
- Green Spotted Puffer
- Posts: 332
- Joined: Thu Sep 17, 2009 12:19 pm
- My Puffers: Picasso Trigger,
Burma Trigger,
Golden Heart Trigger,
Clown Trigger,
Rectangular Trigger,
Porcupine Puffer. - Location (country): Canada
Re: Crushed Coral Substrate Okay for FW?
i had cc in fw a few years back , the stuff was like razor blades i wouldnt reccomend it for any use.
- Myaj
- Tech Team
- Posts: 4587
- Joined: Sat Jun 04, 2005 12:27 pm
- Gender: Female
- My Puffers: Bubba, turgidus
Paris, lined burrfish - Location: SE Wisconsin
- Contact:
Re: Crushed Coral Substrate Okay for FW?
I do agree with RTR here big time, the phrase "my fish don't like water changes" is a huge heads up to somehting being wrong. They should love their water changes, with brighter colors and more activity in the hours and day to follow. Sure, they can be scared of the siphon, moving things around, but they get over it quick and enjoy their clean water.
Have you left your tap water out to sit for 24 hours and rechecked the pH? Sometimes it will change big time. But either way, stable water conditions are a lot more important than adjusting with chemicals. About the only time I've ever tried to adjust my water was back when I tried to breed apistos. They were surviving fine in our local hard as a rock water, but to get them to breed, they needed their more 'natural' conditions.
Have you left your tap water out to sit for 24 hours and rechecked the pH? Sometimes it will change big time. But either way, stable water conditions are a lot more important than adjusting with chemicals. About the only time I've ever tried to adjust my water was back when I tried to breed apistos. They were surviving fine in our local hard as a rock water, but to get them to breed, they needed their more 'natural' conditions.
-
L!$A
- Former Staff Member
- Posts: 1045
- Joined: Fri Nov 06, 2009 5:30 pm
- Gender: Female
- My Puffers: Fahaka - Nala
Congo - Baloo
Arrowhead - Yzma
R.I.P
Kaleeko - Mbu Puffer
Milly - Fangs Puffer - Location (country): CANADA
- Location: Pitt Meadows, BC
Re: Crushed Coral Substrate Okay for FW?
Just to clarify, Kaleeko isn't "stressed" if you must take every word to the point and literal.
He is "scared" of the water changes if that better suits your vocabulary.
He is a very happy puffer, and I do not see any harm in making sure my pH is always near or at a 7.2 (I have other fish than just a Mbu in there.)
You aren't even sure of what I am using.. try not to bite off someone's head before knowing!!
Everyone does things differently, and this works for me.
Sorry if I did not state that I wanted it to be exact to a Mbu's conditions, I just wanted to have it look more natural ..
Also I have never had any algae issues what so ever.. so pretty sure I'm okay.
Also what does a "moist" dog have over a happy mbu?
& We do treat him very well, and he will need a much larger tank in the future than a 320. That would NEVER be his permanent home.
Either way thanks for the advice, and try not to take everything someone says so literal without asking, maybe you'll save yourself a paragraph or two!

He is "scared" of the water changes if that better suits your vocabulary.
He is a very happy puffer, and I do not see any harm in making sure my pH is always near or at a 7.2 (I have other fish than just a Mbu in there.)
You aren't even sure of what I am using.. try not to bite off someone's head before knowing!!
Everyone does things differently, and this works for me.
Sorry if I did not state that I wanted it to be exact to a Mbu's conditions, I just wanted to have it look more natural ..
Also I have never had any algae issues what so ever.. so pretty sure I'm okay.
Also what does a "moist" dog have over a happy mbu?
& We do treat him very well, and he will need a much larger tank in the future than a 320. That would NEVER be his permanent home.
Either way thanks for the advice, and try not to take everything someone says so literal without asking, maybe you'll save yourself a paragraph or two!
Thanks DS, for sure.. I'm looking for more of a sandy substrate!DarkStorm wrote:i had cc in fw a few years back , the stuff was like razor blades i wouldnt reccomend it for any use.

