Hello all!
I've been skulking around here for a while as I'm thinking of getting a figure-eight puffer. You all seem to know what you're talking about, and my local shop generally don't, so I'd like to run my plan past you before I spend lots of money and potentially end up with a puffer I can't look after!
I have a tank which holds 15 UK gallons. It is currently empty of fish, and I will shortly be starting the nitrogen cycle using chemicals (rather than fish). Once it's ready, I intend to keep a single figure-eight puffer in there. There isn't much in the way of decoration to entertain the fish, but there's plenty of time to sort that out before the tank will be ready. The tank will hold fresh water to begin with, as that is what the shop will have, but I will gradually increase the salinity over time.
I also want to feed the fish live snails. I know that crunchy food is vital to their dental health, and whilst I can get frozen food and the like from the fish shop, it's a pain to go there and I'd rather be able to sustain a food supply without having to make regular trips. The idea I had was to buy something like a BiOrb 30 and use it to house a colony of snails. I believe that I would also be able to get something like a Siamese Fighting fish in there along with the snails, to keep the wife happy. She wants a shoal of tetra, or something like that, but I doubt that there's room in the tiny BiOrb tank for them and the snails.
I'm also aware that I'll probably need to treat the puffer for internal parasites. I won't be using feeder fish as figure-eight puffers are molluscivores, but do I also need to treat the snails? Is this even possible? Most medications that I've used (for other fish) have had warnings to indicate that they will harm snails and crustaceans.
Does this all sound sensible?
Thanks!
Jacob
New tank & snail colony.
Re: New tank & snail colony.
Something else that I should add: I've read that puffers are particularly sensitive to ammonia, nitrite and nitrate. The first two are obvious, and should be zero when it's all set up. Nitrate is interesting, however, as our tap water has about 40ppm of nitrate. The fish shop, of course, say that everything is Ok, but most guide I've seen about puffers recommend that it is kept below 20ppm. I've not seen any chemicals which can help here (though I admit that I haven't really looked), but in any case, I'd rather not be dependant on such chemicals if at all possible.
Would 40ppm be Ok? On a previous tank, it never rose above 40ppm, so any nitrate being produced by the nitrogen cycle was clearly being removed by my weekly water changes.
Would 40ppm be Ok? On a previous tank, it never rose above 40ppm, so any nitrate being produced by the nitrogen cycle was clearly being removed by my weekly water changes.
- pufferpuggirl
- Mbu Puffer
- Posts: 3979
- Joined: Mon Nov 03, 2008 3:04 pm
- Gender: Female
- My Puffers: Puffs & Stuff:
1 x M Abei
1 x M Turgidus
1 x T Palembangensis
1 x M Baileyii
1 x T Schoutedeni
1 x T Leiurus
1 x T Miurus
Rainbow crab
crayfish - Location (country): Yorkshire, GB
- Location: South Yorkshire, UK
Re: New tank & snail colony.
Hi Jacob and welcome to the Forum.
Well funny that you also have a problem with nitrates because I do too, and just like yours, mine comes out of the tap at 40ppm. At first I was freaked out, but then it occured to me that my puffers had previously been fine before I did the water test and HAVE been fine since I was shocked by my nitrate reading (which was more than 6-months ago). I think when the nitrate reading is high coming out of the tap, it's different than becoming high from contaminants making the reading that high. Does that make sense to you? That's not a scientific answer, but just how I think it is. I could be totally wrong, but I do know that my puffers all seem to be fine, healthy and fat. So I think that's an indication that the high nitrate reading isn't causing me any problems.
As for worming snails, I don't think there's anything you can get ahold of that would be safe for snails. Whether or not snails can carry IP's, I am uncertain. But I have a snail tank that I breed snails in, for the purpose of feeding my puffers, and I've not done any treatments on my tank. I even keep a little Mandarin crab in my snail tank (it's just a tiny tank, only 3 US gallons).
From what I've read, you sound like you've researched things and are on the right track to having a puffer. I wish you all the best with whatever puffer you end up with.
Well funny that you also have a problem with nitrates because I do too, and just like yours, mine comes out of the tap at 40ppm. At first I was freaked out, but then it occured to me that my puffers had previously been fine before I did the water test and HAVE been fine since I was shocked by my nitrate reading (which was more than 6-months ago). I think when the nitrate reading is high coming out of the tap, it's different than becoming high from contaminants making the reading that high. Does that make sense to you? That's not a scientific answer, but just how I think it is. I could be totally wrong, but I do know that my puffers all seem to be fine, healthy and fat. So I think that's an indication that the high nitrate reading isn't causing me any problems.
As for worming snails, I don't think there's anything you can get ahold of that would be safe for snails. Whether or not snails can carry IP's, I am uncertain. But I have a snail tank that I breed snails in, for the purpose of feeding my puffers, and I've not done any treatments on my tank. I even keep a little Mandarin crab in my snail tank (it's just a tiny tank, only 3 US gallons).
From what I've read, you sound like you've researched things and are on the right track to having a puffer. I wish you all the best with whatever puffer you end up with.
"Puffer .... man's best friend?"
- LilGreenPuffer
- Former Staff Member
- Posts: 5301
- Joined: Sun Jan 25, 2009 11:26 pm
- Gender: Female
- My Puffers: Dwarf puffer - Thumbelina (only mine in my heart now; she lives in CT with my friend)
RIP Inigo Montoya, Fezzik, and Vizinni.
RIP James Bond. - Location (country): United States
- Location: Kentucky
Re: New tank & snail colony.
Nitrates are harmful, no matter where they come from. The ammonia that they put in the tap water is exactly the same stuff produced by rotting food and excrement.
You can use vitamin C crystals to remove nitrates, though. There's a sticky on it somewhere around here...
You can use vitamin C crystals to remove nitrates, though. There's a sticky on it somewhere around here...
"I will give you a talisman. Whenever you are in doubt, or when the self becomes too much with you, apply the following test. Recall the face of the poorest and the weakest man whom you may have seen, and ask yourself, if the step you contemplate is going to be of any use to him or her. Will she gain anything by it? Will it restore her to a control over her own life and destiny? In other words, will it lead to freedom for the hungry and spiritually starving millions? Then you will find your doubts and your self melt away."
Found among the papers of Mohatma Gandhi

Come and visit http://www.thetriopsforum.com!
I AM A DUDETTE!
NEED NITRIFYING BACTERIA FOR YOUR NEW TANK? PM ME!
Found among the papers of Mohatma Gandhi

Come and visit http://www.thetriopsforum.com!
I AM A DUDETTE!
NEED NITRIFYING BACTERIA FOR YOUR NEW TANK? PM ME!
Re: New tank & snail colony.
Thanks for the advice!
I have found a couple of types of nitrate-removing filter media and the like, and a few liquid treatments too, so I'll investigate those. The vitamin C treatments appear to be aimed at marine tanks, though I imagine they would work similarly in fresh (or slightly brackish) water too. Indeed, I found the sticky thread in one of the marine forums here; thanks for pointing that out! In any case, I will not worry too much about this if you've successfully kept such a long list of puffers in similar water, but I will definitely have a look as I'd rather get the water conditions as close to ideal as I can.
This is particularly true as I don't intend to keep plant life in the aquarium. Whilst plants only use a little nitrate, they do use a bit, and this may be the reason why I never saw anything above tap water levels in my previous aquarium. Whilst I like to have plants, they tend to get messy and they make cleaning more difficult. I also have hard, alkaline water here, and many varieties of plants dislike it*. Indeed, I had a few plants in my previous tank which just disintegrated in my water, even though everything else was set up right for them. Maybe I'll change my mind once it's set up. Indeed, I may need to get plants in order to keep the puffer entertained, but I'm hoping that bits of terracotta pots and other such decorations will suffice.
* Finding plants that like brackish water is even more difficult, though I did see a thread on here about that which I haven't yet read, so it may hold useful information.
Similarly, I won't worry about treating the snails. I've certainly not seen any reports on the web about puffers contracting parasites from snails.
Thanks again for the feedback and advice!
I have found a couple of types of nitrate-removing filter media and the like, and a few liquid treatments too, so I'll investigate those. The vitamin C treatments appear to be aimed at marine tanks, though I imagine they would work similarly in fresh (or slightly brackish) water too. Indeed, I found the sticky thread in one of the marine forums here; thanks for pointing that out! In any case, I will not worry too much about this if you've successfully kept such a long list of puffers in similar water, but I will definitely have a look as I'd rather get the water conditions as close to ideal as I can.
This is particularly true as I don't intend to keep plant life in the aquarium. Whilst plants only use a little nitrate, they do use a bit, and this may be the reason why I never saw anything above tap water levels in my previous aquarium. Whilst I like to have plants, they tend to get messy and they make cleaning more difficult. I also have hard, alkaline water here, and many varieties of plants dislike it*. Indeed, I had a few plants in my previous tank which just disintegrated in my water, even though everything else was set up right for them. Maybe I'll change my mind once it's set up. Indeed, I may need to get plants in order to keep the puffer entertained, but I'm hoping that bits of terracotta pots and other such decorations will suffice.
* Finding plants that like brackish water is even more difficult, though I did see a thread on here about that which I haven't yet read, so it may hold useful information.
Similarly, I won't worry about treating the snails. I've certainly not seen any reports on the web about puffers contracting parasites from snails.
This is true, but ammonia is not nitrate. If there was (measurable) ammonia or nitrite in my tap water, I'd be rather worried. Nitrate is nitrate, regardless of where it comes from, but is normally not harmful to fish by itself unless the concentration is high. schismy007's comment that nitrate from some contaminants can be worse than nitrate from the tap is still valid, however, as the contaminants themselves may be harmful, but I don't know how nitrate gets into a typical aquarium other than from nitrite (and thus ammonia) or from tap water. Still, it gets into the tap water somehow, and it's quite possible that they add ammonia at some stage during the water purification process. Indeed, I wouldn't be overly surprised if they use similar bacteria to those we try to look after in our tanks. I'm neither a biologist nor a chemist, of course, so this is all just speculation!LilGreenPuffer wrote:Nitrates are harmful, no matter where they come from. The ammonia that they put in the tap water is exactly the same stuff produced by rotting food and excrement.
Thanks again for the feedback and advice!