Please help with dropping ph
Please help with dropping ph
I just finished cycling my tank (fishless) two days ago. I did a large water change to bring down the nitrates and then tested the water. The pH was at 7.6, which is what it is straight out of the tap. I didn't check it yesterday, but tested this morning because I was planning on buying my fish today. I was disappointed to see that the ph had dropped to around 6.1 or 6.2. Why did this happen? I did have the same problem once when I was cycling it, but used baking soda to raise it. I am pretty sure I am not supposed to use baking at this point. Obviously I know that I will not be getting the fish today, but my question is: how do I raise the ph and keep it stable?
-
coldmachineUK
- Former Staff Member
- Posts: 382
- Joined: Wed Sep 06, 2006 7:20 pm
- My Puffers: 2x T. biocellatus
1x C. asellus - Location: Wirral, UK
Re: Please help with dropping ph
The most important thing is maintaining a stable pH rather than keeping it at an 'ideal' level. That said, if it's dropping consistently you need to identify the cause. What substrate and filtration are you using? Buffer pH naturally where necessary, using crushed coral or the like to increase and wood décor plus peat filtration to bring it down.
Did our staff successfully help you? The Puffer Forum is an incredible resource and is run completely on the donations of its viewers. Proceeds from the Puffer Forum store go towards future contests and keeping the site running. We also welcome donations!
36G: FW Planted | 53G: Brackish (F8 Puffers) | 58G: Freshwater Community (Unusual/Rare Loaches)
Interesting stock: S. mahnerti, S. vinciguerrae, S. sp. "crimson", V. maassi, N. masyai, M. guentheri, T. biocellatus, C. asellus.
36G: FW Planted | 53G: Brackish (F8 Puffers) | 58G: Freshwater Community (Unusual/Rare Loaches)
Interesting stock: S. mahnerti, S. vinciguerrae, S. sp. "crimson", V. maassi, N. masyai, M. guentheri, T. biocellatus, C. asellus.
Re: Please help with dropping ph
coldmachineUK: I have gravel substrate and am using an Aquaclear HOB filter. I did test some tap water that had been sitting out for about 48 hours and its ph was 7.0. Today I went out and got some test strips to check KH and GH, both were very low; KH looked like it was close to 0. With these readings, am I correct in saying that I will need to put some crushed coral into the tank to buffer the water? I did a partial water change which brought the ph to 6.5. Should I get some crushed coral, put it into a mesh bag and put that into the filter? How long does it usually take for the ph to rise?
On a side note, I am wondering if the ammonia I am using (ammonia hydroxide) to feed the tank could be causing the ph to fall? Has anyone heard of this?
On a side note, I am wondering if the ammonia I am using (ammonia hydroxide) to feed the tank could be causing the ph to fall? Has anyone heard of this?
- By_a_coo
- Green Spotted Puffer
- Posts: 474
- Joined: Sun Sep 03, 2006 7:14 pm
- Gender: Male
- My Puffers: 1 X GSP
- Location (country): Brazil
- Location: São Paulo, Brazil
Re: Please help with dropping ph
With a low KH, your PH can rapidly drop. I don't know why people try to avoid baking soda since it is made of bicarbonate and its adition into the water raise KH keeping a stable PH. Bacteria also use bicarbonates as a carbon source, since you have a low KH your bacteria will drop the PH while they process amonia. Have you got CO2 injection in that tank? What type of fish will you get?
Fernando
Re: Please help with dropping ph
By_a_coo: I am going to keep dwarf puffers. I do not have any co2 injection in the tank, is that something I need? At this point, what do I need to do in order to get the ph at an acceptable level and keep it there so that I can get my fish? Sorry for all the questions, this is all new to me so your help is appreciated.
- By_a_coo
- Green Spotted Puffer
- Posts: 474
- Joined: Sun Sep 03, 2006 7:14 pm
- Gender: Male
- My Puffers: 1 X GSP
- Location (country): Brazil
- Location: São Paulo, Brazil
Re: Please help with dropping ph
I mentioned the CO2 injection just in case you had a planted tank. CO2 will lower the PH since you have a high KH or not. According to the PufferfPedia:
Water Parameters: Temp: 23 - 28C (74 -82,5 F); pH: 6.5 - 7.2
So you have a very PH adaptable puffer. But I would keep (with baking soda) KH at 3-4° at least. Check if KH is dropping before water changes, if so your bacteria may be consuming bicarbonates to process ammonia or you have something lowering your ph (bogwoods/driftwoods). If you need to raise KH and GH too, add a bag with aragonite inside of your filter if you have some room.
Water Parameters: Temp: 23 - 28C (74 -82,5 F); pH: 6.5 - 7.2
So you have a very PH adaptable puffer. But I would keep (with baking soda) KH at 3-4° at least. Check if KH is dropping before water changes, if so your bacteria may be consuming bicarbonates to process ammonia or you have something lowering your ph (bogwoods/driftwoods). If you need to raise KH and GH too, add a bag with aragonite inside of your filter if you have some room.
Fernando
-
coldmachineUK
- Former Staff Member
- Posts: 382
- Joined: Wed Sep 06, 2006 7:20 pm
- My Puffers: 2x T. biocellatus
1x C. asellus - Location: Wirral, UK
Re: Please help with dropping ph
The problem with dosing bicarb is that you are going to end up with a fluctuating pH which is far worse than having a stable, albeit imperfect, pH. Your puffers will adapt. If you add some crushed coral (in a mesh bag, like you say) somewhere on the substrate then it should help buffer the pH naturally without you having to make constant adjustments.
Still not sure what the cause could be. Typically I'd have expected the things I mentioned to have contributed but they all look fine.
Still not sure what the cause could be. Typically I'd have expected the things I mentioned to have contributed but they all look fine.
Did our staff successfully help you? The Puffer Forum is an incredible resource and is run completely on the donations of its viewers. Proceeds from the Puffer Forum store go towards future contests and keeping the site running. We also welcome donations!
36G: FW Planted | 53G: Brackish (F8 Puffers) | 58G: Freshwater Community (Unusual/Rare Loaches)
Interesting stock: S. mahnerti, S. vinciguerrae, S. sp. "crimson", V. maassi, N. masyai, M. guentheri, T. biocellatus, C. asellus.
36G: FW Planted | 53G: Brackish (F8 Puffers) | 58G: Freshwater Community (Unusual/Rare Loaches)
Interesting stock: S. mahnerti, S. vinciguerrae, S. sp. "crimson", V. maassi, N. masyai, M. guentheri, T. biocellatus, C. asellus.
- By_a_coo
- Green Spotted Puffer
- Posts: 474
- Joined: Sun Sep 03, 2006 7:14 pm
- Gender: Male
- My Puffers: 1 X GSP
- Location (country): Brazil
- Location: São Paulo, Brazil
Re: Please help with dropping ph
I never had any problem with fluctuating ph related to baking soda for years, neither tanganika/mbunas keepers (they also use baking soda to keep a high ph). All buffer produtcs are made of bicarbonate and carbonate. Every place you search, the formula to raise ph is using baking soda, TPF is the only place where people say NO to bicarbonate usage.coldmachineUK wrote:The problem with dosing bicarb is that you are going to end up with a fluctuating pH which is far worse than having a stable, albeit imperfect, pH.
I don't mean it to sound rude
Fernando
-
coldmachineUK
- Former Staff Member
- Posts: 382
- Joined: Wed Sep 06, 2006 7:20 pm
- My Puffers: 2x T. biocellatus
1x C. asellus - Location: Wirral, UK
Re: Please help with dropping ph
I think the point we try to make is that dosing, manually, of any sort is not going to give a stable result by the very nature of it requiring manual input. I've kept mbuna (msobo magunga, to be precise) so I know precisely how bicarb can be used to buffer pH. I'm saying it's not as stable as putting in a permanent buffer like crushed coral or other substrate-based (or filtration-based) buffer agents.
Did our staff successfully help you? The Puffer Forum is an incredible resource and is run completely on the donations of its viewers. Proceeds from the Puffer Forum store go towards future contests and keeping the site running. We also welcome donations!
36G: FW Planted | 53G: Brackish (F8 Puffers) | 58G: Freshwater Community (Unusual/Rare Loaches)
Interesting stock: S. mahnerti, S. vinciguerrae, S. sp. "crimson", V. maassi, N. masyai, M. guentheri, T. biocellatus, C. asellus.
36G: FW Planted | 53G: Brackish (F8 Puffers) | 58G: Freshwater Community (Unusual/Rare Loaches)
Interesting stock: S. mahnerti, S. vinciguerrae, S. sp. "crimson", V. maassi, N. masyai, M. guentheri, T. biocellatus, C. asellus.
- By_a_coo
- Green Spotted Puffer
- Posts: 474
- Joined: Sun Sep 03, 2006 7:14 pm
- Gender: Male
- My Puffers: 1 X GSP
- Location (country): Brazil
- Location: São Paulo, Brazil
Re: Please help with dropping ph
Welll, if the statement of the forum is to use crushed coral as the unique source of bicarbonate to keep a stable and high PH/KH, who am I to argue with a Tech Team?
Fernando
-
coldmachineUK
- Former Staff Member
- Posts: 382
- Joined: Wed Sep 06, 2006 7:20 pm
- My Puffers: 2x T. biocellatus
1x C. asellus - Location: Wirral, UK
Re: Please help with dropping ph
No, this doesn't come from the Tech Team or from TPF, it just comes from my personal view/experience 
Did our staff successfully help you? The Puffer Forum is an incredible resource and is run completely on the donations of its viewers. Proceeds from the Puffer Forum store go towards future contests and keeping the site running. We also welcome donations!
36G: FW Planted | 53G: Brackish (F8 Puffers) | 58G: Freshwater Community (Unusual/Rare Loaches)
Interesting stock: S. mahnerti, S. vinciguerrae, S. sp. "crimson", V. maassi, N. masyai, M. guentheri, T. biocellatus, C. asellus.
36G: FW Planted | 53G: Brackish (F8 Puffers) | 58G: Freshwater Community (Unusual/Rare Loaches)
Interesting stock: S. mahnerti, S. vinciguerrae, S. sp. "crimson", V. maassi, N. masyai, M. guentheri, T. biocellatus, C. asellus.
Re: Please help with dropping ph
Thank you both for your comments. I actually went out yesterday and got some crushed coral and put it in the filter (in a mesh bag of course). When I checked this evening my ph has gone from 6.5 to around 7.2, maybe higher. Should it have rose this quickly? Perhaps I put in too much. How long will it take for the coral to have full effect on the ph--a few days, a week?