About two days later, I woke up to a cloudy tank. After searching I found that the goby had simply moved her wafer into a cave and never ate it; it was decomposing and fouling the tank.
All of the fish became lethargic, and the puffers both developed cloudy eyes and what appeared to be a light "film" on their bodies, I assume from ammonia poisoning. One puffer was clearly worse than the other; yesterday he began to rest on leaves, float on the surface dead still, etc. I could actually handle him before he would snap out of it and swim for a minute, then return to floating. He passed away early this morning
The other puffer and Goby are still hanging in there. The puffer is swimming around a bit but still has cloudy eyes and is lethargic, but nowhere near as bad as the other puffer was.
I've been doing daily 35% water changes and dosing melafix since the tank got cloudy.
I'm just hoping this little guy can pull through
Let this be a lesson to everyone; always make sure there is no uneaten food in your tanks. Even a little bit can cause big problems.
