Page 1 of 1

Percentage water changes

Posted: Sun Jun 20, 2010 8:05 am
by lilacamy931
So I think any puffer keeper knows water changes are vigiliant with such messy eaters and the given is to do between 30-50% weekly changes depending on your stocking and tank circumstances. But I wanted to ask and wondered out of the two methods below is one more beneficial to the other or does it not really matter?
Say doing a regular 30% (Example)
1. Do one off 30% per week
OR
2. Mid week 15-20% and weekend 15-20%
When Im thinking of the above Im thinking for larger tanks for the giant puffs. I currently do 30% once a week but have been wondering if the second option any more beneficial? I should add the fish in question is Nooki my Fahaka and he doesnt mind water changes one bit (in case stress factor came up)

Re: Percentage water changes

Posted: Sun Jun 20, 2010 9:09 am
by Flutter
Two smaller water changes are not as good as one larger water change.

Re: Percentage water changes

Posted: Sun Jun 20, 2010 10:04 am
by Myaj
Well, most of us do 50% or larger, whatever we have time for, not 30% ;)

But lets do the math and figure out which way is better. First we'll have to do some estimating, and use easy numbers, and the assumption that your tap water has no nitrates in it.

So, as a guess, lets say that your nitrates raise 10 during the week. So, say you start at 10 nitrates at the beginning of your week, wait til the end of your week and you are now at 20 nitrates. Do your 50% water change and you've diluted them back down to 10 (by 50%). Pretty simple.

Now figure 2x per week. Same tank, starts at 10 nitrates. Halfway through the week its up to 15 and you do a 25% water change. So you are diluting them by 25%, bringing them down to 11.25, they continue to rise that other 5 nitrates by the end of the week, so you are up to 16.25 by the end of the week, do another 25% water change and you bring THOSE down by 25%, which means at the end of your second water change later in the week, you'll have nitrates of 12.1875. So yes, the math says that doing one big one gives you better results than two half sized ones.

Obviously doing two 50% changes during the week will do better than just one 50%. Doing two 30% changes instead of one 50%? It would be closer to equal, but not really worth the extra 5 minutes of drain/refill time.

Mind you, that is in a relatively stable tank. If you are over stocked and your nitrates jump 40+ every week, you'd be better off doing multiple ones to keep things more stable.. but not multiple SMALLER ones! You'd still want big ones.

Re: Percentage water changes

Posted: Sun Jun 20, 2010 11:29 am
by lilacamy931
Thanks very much for the mathematical reasoning, that is perfect. I personally do 40-50% once a week and had been wondering on multiples but will stick to my regime after that fatnastic explanation. (and dont worry only used 30% as an example) ;) Thanks both!

EDIT: Actually I will ask now, how often to clean external filters? I am used to internals but wonder what the regime is for externals?

Re: Percentage water changes

Posted: Sun Jun 20, 2010 1:13 pm
by Pufferpunk