Page 1 of 2
MTS Snails
Posted: Tue May 18, 2010 3:24 pm
by lilacamy931
Hey peeps
When i first starting reading up on puffers, found that MTS were to be too hard for puffer beaks, but having read more recently found that people have had success at least with the newer babies of this species, what are your thoughts? I have ordered some pondnsails and also some ramshorns but from past experiences the only snails I have managed to keep alive are assasins and one nerite. Some ramshorns bred for a while but this was in a unfiltered/unheated tank, trying a heated and filtered tank has been really unsuccessful for me! What would be a good set up? Large tub and do daily water changes? I could add some to the cube tank with shrimp and DPs (96 litres) which quite a few surviving in but think there are limited chances of breeding. I ask on the MTS as a friend has billions.
p.s. just reading the snail breeding article now
Re: MTS Snails
Posted: Tue May 18, 2010 6:08 pm
by SammyDee
IMO i would use the pond and rammys only. Actually I prefer the rammys most cuz their shell is like a medium hardness. Forcing the puffers to try a bit harder to get all the meat. The pond have a soft shell and no matter how big mine eat em up in one bite. The rammys they goota play with a bit more so they get a better teeth wearing exercise.
About the Assasin snail, He wasnt with snails you were trying to breed was he?? cuz assasin snails eat all snails. Maybe tell your buddy to get one to get rid if all/some of his MTS.
Re: MTS Snails
Posted: Tue May 18, 2010 6:12 pm
by SammyDee
Heater , filter, bubbler made a huge diference in my snail tank. keep the temp highish too. around 80-82. And wait a few months to let them breed a bit. Id have to say IMO id get atleast 100 starter snails so they can be bred easily while you continue to use some for food. After a few months given WP are good you should 500 plus snails easy. I feed shrimp pellets and nori
Re: MTS Snails
Posted: Wed May 19, 2010 3:35 am
by lilacamy931
Thanks very much , so the MTS are out. Dont worry the assassin snails were a snail I was able to keep successfully at one point, I dont still have them

I will await these ponds and see how they go along with the snails I still have left and go on a huge snail spending spree on ramshorns, thanks very much for the tips xx
Re: MTS Snails
Posted: Wed May 19, 2010 1:37 pm
by Iliveinazoo
I occassionally put some baby MTS's from my fiddler tank into the F8 puffer tank but they are sucked out of the shell so they will not contribute to wearing down the beak.
Re: MTS Snails
Posted: Wed May 19, 2010 2:03 pm
by lesleyanndunn
i would agree with sammy
i have pond and ramshorns and the pond snails shell are very thin and easily chomped
thats good for smaller puffers
but my gsp and small fahaka like yours gets into them no prob, and defeats the purpose for their beaks
im sticking to ramshorns, they breed and grow quicker
and get bigger than ponds
if you have to, you can slightly crush the bigger rams if your puffs cant get into them
but gives them a bit of exercise mentally & physically trying to work out best way to get dinner instead of just eating instantly!
Re: MTS Snails
Posted: Wed May 19, 2010 2:33 pm
by lilacamy931
Thanks peeps! I think I will get some more ramshorn and give a more controlled go. I was an idiot and gave a load to Nooki when he first got here and they were all adult and pretty much sucked them out rrather than crushing lol
Re: MTS Snails
Posted: Wed May 19, 2010 2:34 pm
by lesleyanndunn
they love to slurp em rather than crush em!

Re: MTS Snails
Posted: Wed May 19, 2010 2:38 pm
by lilacamy931
Weird suggestion now, can I feed the assassin snails to the puff? I only have a couple and really dont need them anymore..sounds wee bit cruel

Re: MTS Snails
Posted: Wed May 19, 2010 3:51 pm
by lesleyanndunn
i've no experiences with asassin snails, so u need another opinion!
aint much use am i on this one lol
Re: MTS Snails
Posted: Wed May 19, 2010 4:31 pm
by lilacamy931
You are fab!

Im just grateful for assistance lol.
Re: MTS Snails
Posted: Wed May 19, 2010 4:43 pm
by lesleyanndunn
hows your lil guy doing?
Re: MTS Snails
Posted: Wed May 19, 2010 4:53 pm
by lilacamy931
He is doing great, he has only eaten bloodworm and snails this week, turned his nose up at prawn except for a little and Saturday is the day I go get him loads of other things to try. I have some healthy worms coming as well as pond and ramshorn. I will get live glass shrimp sat and see if I can find a fishmonger, he is such mummy's baby

Does yours eat varied?
Re: MTS Snails
Posted: Wed May 19, 2010 5:10 pm
by lesleyanndunn
mine would eat snails, bloodworm, cockle without the shell, woodlouse
i havent tried him on prawns, earthworms yet, but he would eat them lol
hes a wee gut!
its hard not to overfeed, so he hasnt been fed today, needs to rest his tummy lol
Re: MTS Snails
Posted: Wed May 19, 2010 9:30 pm
by J-P
Well if your puffer is a "slurper", why not try the assassin snail?
An other opinion is that you can put in the assassin and if the puffers don't eat it, it will help stir your sand bed (if you have one). The spend much of their time in the sand.