Page 1 of 1

I had no idea this was out there.

Posted: Sun May 09, 2010 4:10 pm
by Brandon8521
I was just wandering if many of you guys knew about this kind of infection. I had no idea something like this even existed. I found it while browsing around the anemone site PP likes so much.

http://www.reefkeeping.com/issues/2003- ... /index.php

Re: I had no idea this was out there.

Posted: Sun May 09, 2010 4:37 pm
by J-P
Yep Fish TB ... very scary stuff. We had a very brief thread on that

Re: I had no idea this was out there.

Posted: Sun May 09, 2010 4:59 pm
by nmonks
The thing with "Fish TB" is its talked about rather more often than it actually occurs. Without doing some microscope work on tissue samples from the fish, no hobbyist can distinguish Mycobacterium marinum from any of the other Mycobacterium infections, of which several occur. Furthermore, other Mycobacterium infections are quite common, and probably far more likely in freshwater tanks than Mycobacterium marinum. So before jumping to conclusions from what is a fairly old article, I'd encourage you to read this piece over at Conscientious Aquarist written by a microbiologist:

http://www.wetwebmedia.com/ca/volume_6/ ... actera.htm

To quote:

"The truth about M. marinum is that it is not very common, and the term Fish TB, while popular, is usually inappropriate and used for other types of disease that display broadly similar symptoms.... However, there are now known to be several species of Mycobacterium that infect fish, and not all of them produce tuberculosis-like lesions similar to those seen on mammals. For this reason, rather than calling the disease Fish TB, it is probably best to refer to it as “Fish Mycobacteriosis”."

In other words, Fish TB isn't common anyway, and confirmed instances of humans becoming infected are even rarer. In fact you are infinitely more likely to contract a Salmonella infection from your aquarium than Fish TB. Yet hardly anyone worries about that!

Cheers, Neale
J-P wrote:Yep Fish TB ... very scary stuff. We had a very brief thread on that

Re: I had no idea this was out there.

Posted: Sun May 09, 2010 5:02 pm
by pufferpuggirl
I love it, you always bring us back down to earth Neale, thank you once again. :grats:

Re: I had no idea this was out there.

Posted: Sun May 09, 2010 5:19 pm
by nmonks
Always a pleasure!

Cheers and good night, Neale
pufferpuggirl wrote:I love it, you always bring us back down to earth Neale, thank you once again. :grats:

Re: I had no idea this was out there.

Posted: Sun May 09, 2010 6:30 pm
by Brandon8521
I had never really looked online for alot of fish related stuff untill I got my first GSP. So i had never really herd of catching something like from the fish you keep in an aquarium. I understand it is probably like a 1 in a mil kinda thing but really had never heard of anything like it. And thnx for the article nmonks. I spend a rather large portion of my day researching all kinds of stuff about fish and fish tanks now that im really starting to get into the hobby of it and not just the house pleaseing asthetics of it.

Re: I had no idea this was out there.

Posted: Mon May 10, 2010 5:20 pm
by nmonks
What are called "zoonoses" -- diseases caught from animals -- are actually quite common. There are obvious cases in recent history of things being caught from farm animals for example, e.g., swine flu. Quite a few diseases we consider to be human diseases probably evolved only once we started living closely with animals, i.e., we started farming, or else lived sufficiently densely that parasites adapted to things like rats and mosquitoes were able to make the jump from those species to us.

In any case, fish aren't a major source of human disease. In general it's a good idea to avoid getting aquarium water in your mouth primarily because of salmonella, which is easily promoted through things like rotting fish flake in warm, damp corners of the aquarium. Bites by moray eels and puncture wounds from catfish are also well-recognised sources of potential infection, less because of venom, and more because of secondary infections. If you have a strong stomach for such things, take a look at this article over at Wetwebmedia:

http://www.wetwebmedia.com/morayeelbitesart.htm

But it's important to put this into context. You far more likely to get a disease or injury from a pet mammal, and even more likely to get either from a human being. In the big scheme of things, fish tanks are a very, very minor health risk.

Cheers, Neale
Bcummings8521 wrote:So i had never really herd of catching something like from the fish you keep in an aquarium. I understand it is probably like a 1 in a mil kinda thing but really had never heard of anything like it.

Re: I had no idea this was out there.

Posted: Mon May 10, 2010 5:53 pm
by Pufferpunk
Everyone always asks me if I'm afraid of sharks, when I go diving. No, it's the green morays I keep my distance from! Good thing they don't see very well.

Re: I had no idea this was out there.

Posted: Mon May 10, 2010 6:17 pm
by davew
salmonella from fish water you say :yikes: , i might have to stop the way i change water then i have a clear pipe that i use as the valve on my siphon always sticks so i just use the pipe and suck to get the siphon going which usually means i get a mouth full of fish water :)

Re: I had no idea this was out there.

Posted: Mon May 10, 2010 6:23 pm
by Pufferpunk
You're NEVER supposed to suck on fish water!

Re: I had no idea this was out there.

Posted: Sun May 16, 2010 4:01 pm
by Nick
It's also good to keep in mind even salmonella is not a threat to most people, generally only becoming so when you have a compromised immune system. I spent my childhood and most of my teens handling frogs and turtles while not washing nearly so often as I should (you think getting fish water in your mouth is bad, try turtle water! YUCK!!!!), owned chickens, ate plenty of fresh raw eggs, raw beef(gored gored is better than steak tar-tare, sorry fine French chefs), etc, and have never had a salmonella infection. Partly luck, but mostly having always had a good immune system. Children under 3, the elderly, the immuno-suppressed, the unlucky, etc could easily have gotten an infection and been very sick from the same list of indiscretions.

I mention this not to encourage this kind of activity (Except eating gored gored, that I do encourage) but to calm down anyone that has accidentally been exposed to fish water or the like: Probably nothing going to happen.

Re: I had no idea this was out there.

Posted: Sun May 16, 2010 4:59 pm
by Dadof4
I've swallowed lots of fish water before the advent of the Python and I'm fin....

Re: I had no idea this was out there.

Posted: Sun May 16, 2010 5:01 pm
by Pufferpunk
Yeah me too but we try not to recommend it. ;)

Re: I had no idea this was out there.

Posted: Sun May 16, 2010 7:25 pm
by J-P
ahhhh but when dealing with a fish that is sick and has the signs of illness... you have to be extra careful. This isn't the laxy-daisy day to day stuff.

Re: I had no idea this was out there.

Posted: Mon May 17, 2010 4:06 am
by Dadof4
Yeah...that didn't come out like I intended...it's hard to cut the word "fine" off abruptly and there is no sick person smiley....