Page 1 of 1

Might this work?

Posted: Thu Apr 15, 2010 2:31 pm
by ~reefchik~
I have a heavily planted FW tank with a rose shark (barb), a Celebes rainbow, and a Banded rainbow (M. trifasciata). There are also 3 orange mexican crawdads. Any chance two irrubescos would be ok in there? I imagine the crawdads would be in some danger although they are larger than the puffers at this point.

Re: Might this work?

Posted: Thu Apr 15, 2010 6:04 pm
by pufferpuggirl
I don't know enough about those other fish to be able to make a good comment, but keep in mind that irrubesco can be nippy sometimes, so that's always a possibility with them being around other fish. Is that the 30-gallon high tank? If it is, then I'm not so sure because I think longer is better with puffers, as they tend to stay nearer to the bottom than mid-water or top. :?

Re: Might this work?

Posted: Thu Apr 15, 2010 9:37 pm
by ~reefchik~
It would be my regular 20 gallon tank.

Re: Might this work?

Posted: Thu Apr 15, 2010 11:57 pm
by purplecandle
I would not put puffers with fish with fins... I had a GSP (I know a different species) Living alone in a 30 gallon high by himself..he was barely an inch..really small fella (he has grown since then though) anyway..I bought a tank off craigslist and the tank came with some fish 2-3 inches long..after I got the tank and got home it was so late and I did not want to leave the fish in bags overnight and my little GSP was at a VERY low salt level..I said.."what could happen" and put the fish in -acclimated of course

(I knew these fish were healthy...I did not know the tank came with fish...that has happened to me several times from CL).

so I did not have place for the fish..

I put the fish in..turned around, got dressed for bed, came back in 15 minutes...fish had no top fins...I moved them to a cooler overnight until I took them to live with someone else---and these were all fish that appeared to be faster than my coconut

My little coconut (GSP) was not stressed out or hungry...I really think he did it because he could..

Point is..they might hurt your fish they might not, but they can...

Re: Might this work?

Posted: Fri Apr 16, 2010 3:41 am
by pufferpuggirl
Very good point Purple yup

Re: Might this work?

Posted: Fri Apr 16, 2010 1:18 pm
by ~reefchik~
Thank you for your advice. And....Well, we're going to find out, because I am now a Puffer Mom! :smitten:

(ETA: I got a pair of irrubescos)

I also believe I have a M-F pair. The smaller one has more distinct markings and the larger one is more dull colored but with red showing on his tail. As for their tankmates, so far so good. Nobody reacted much to their arrival. She scooted around a little bit out of the bag, but he just settled underneath a plant leaf and peeked out at the world until lights out.

They are keeping to themselves, doing the usual puffer dance up and down one corner of the tank. They seem very shy.

I have a funny feeling that these tiny puffers are like potato chips...you can't have just one :lol: They're so adorable.

The big tank is cycling pretty well. I saw nitrites on the test yesterday morning, so my addition of mysis shrimp seems to have kicked off well. I moved my already-in-use Fluval 405 canister onto that tank, so I hope to have it cycled a bit sooner than usual.

Re: Might this work?

Posted: Fri Apr 16, 2010 1:21 pm
by pufferpuggirl
Just remember to keep feeding the big tank so you don't lose whatever bacteria that's in your Fluval 405.

Congrats on the irrubesco, they are quite nice puffers. :D

Re: Might this work?

Posted: Fri Apr 16, 2010 1:29 pm
by ~reefchik~
Thanks, yes I'm monitoring it closely and counting down the days, hours and minutes til I can stock it with my next puffers!

On a related note, I was able to find an amazon sword positively covered with tiny, tiny snails, so I bought it (my goodness how our priorities change with puffs, eh?) The sword went into the big tank (SG 1.004 yesterday) and all the snails went in with the puffers.

I've not seen much yet on raising small snails or other inverts for our puffs, so can someone direct me with a link? I have an Eclipse tank (5 gal) that seems to be perfect for that task and I'd like to get started right away. Fortunately the irrubescos are eating bloodworms and mysis but I want to have the snail rearing tank up and running ASAP.

Re: Might this work?

Posted: Fri Apr 16, 2010 2:08 pm
by pufferpuggirl
I hope you have better luck than I did with getting your irrubesco to eat snails, mine will peck at them, but won't really eat them, and they do have some dental issues. I've had their teeth trimmed before and they need it again. In fact, I've just ordered some cuttlefish bones to put in their tank, with the hopes that they will bite on it, and I might even try smearing it with puffer food, or something to make them peck it. I need to do something to get them to trim their own teeth. Do you know how hard it is to see where the teeth are on a tiny puffer? :scared:

Re: Might this work?

Posted: Fri Apr 16, 2010 2:35 pm
by Pufferpunk
I know they're not cheap, but your barb is a schooling species & should be kept so. Impressive school they make too!

Re: Might this work?

Posted: Fri Apr 16, 2010 9:45 pm
by ~reefchik~
Yes, they would make an impressive school.

I'll have to consider another tank to do that though. OTOH, I can see giving the irrubescos their own 20-30 in about a year and see if they'll breed. That would be a treat! Then there will be room for a couple more roseline barbs. They are truly lovely fish.

Also, I'm happy to report both puffers are happily slurping bloodworms tonight. Do most of you (in the US) order blackworms online for yours, or what?