Page 1 of 2
Are garden pond snails ok
Posted: Wed Apr 07, 2010 5:14 pm
by Poddington
Hi,
I have just got my first GSP which I have put in a 30 gallon long tank on his own. I've got some frozen brine shrimp and bloodworm to give him but was wondering if it would be ok to give him snails from my garden pond till I've got a breeding tank of snails set up?
I hope I've posted in the right place

Re: Are garden pond snails ok
Posted: Wed Apr 07, 2010 5:16 pm
by purplecandle
how big are the snails and how big is the GSP?
Re: Are garden pond snails ok
Posted: Wed Apr 07, 2010 5:16 pm
by Hilly
Can be risky, theres always a chance theyve been exposed to chemicals used in gardens, maybe not from your garden but from someone elses.
Re: Are garden pond snails ok
Posted: Wed Apr 07, 2010 5:49 pm
by L!$A
I wouldn't risk it.. +1 about chemicals, you never know what the snail may have come across! It is pretty easy to breed your own snails, I hear ramshorn snails are pretty easy to breed.

Re: Are garden pond snails ok
Posted: Wed Apr 07, 2010 6:24 pm
by pufferpuggirl
Indeed, ramshorn are incredibly easy to breed, and just right for a puffer to bite into. Personally, I would not put anything in my tank that came from outside. If you ever want to breed snails and have a tank to devote to them, there's a good seller on eBay that has very good prices and nice quantities too.

Re: Are garden pond snails ok
Posted: Wed Apr 07, 2010 6:41 pm
by Poddington
Thank you for fast replys.
He is only a baby at about 1.5 inches so I would of been hunting for the tiny baby snails. I don't have any nearby gardens but likely could be a risk from the farmer spraying the field by us. Seems a shame as the pond is full of them. I'll have a look in my other tank and see if theres any lurking in the plants that I can use to start a breeding tank, problem is my kribs seem to love them as well unless they got a taste just for apple snails.
I've just tried him with some brine shrimp....he was not impressed but loves the bloodworm. How much of the cube should I be giving?
Re: Are garden pond snails ok
Posted: Wed Apr 07, 2010 6:54 pm
by pufferpuggirl
I would only give him about 1/4 of the cube, seeing as he's that small .... but you might also want to try him with pieces of prawn and mussel (mine love the mussels). I always try to give a variety of foods to my puffers, keeps things interesting. I've also just recently bought cockles in the shells. Most of them are already open a bit, so it's not hard to pull them all the way open, and the smaller puffers seem to enjoy biting at the bits of meat that are left on the shell, but my Mbu just decimates the entire cockle all in one go.

Re: Are garden pond snails ok
Posted: Wed Apr 07, 2010 7:12 pm
by Poddington
Thank you Pufferpug girl.....good to know as he didn't seem to want to tell me he'd had enough
I'll start having a look around to see what different kinds of shellfish are available by me.
I will try putting some ghost shrimp in the tank for him to play with also

Re: Are garden pond snails ok
Posted: Thu Apr 08, 2010 4:54 pm
by Iliveinazoo
Poddington wrote:Hi,
I have just got my first GSP which I have put in a 30 gallon long tank on his own. I've got some frozen brine shrimp and bloodworm to give him but was wondering if it would be ok to give him snails from my garden pond till I've got a breeding tank of snails set up?
I hope I've posted in the right place

I wouldn't take them directly from your pond and feed them straight away but you could breed them if you set up another tank in your house, leave them in the breeder tank for about a month and they should be ok by then. You're better off feeding the offspring - about the size of the puffers eye - otherwise you should crush the larger ones and feed the appropriate amount.
Re: Are garden pond snails ok
Posted: Fri Apr 09, 2010 1:10 am
by SammyDee
Nothing from outside. Not even worms. No ramshorn either. They're too hard. I feed them but I'm not trying to breed them. The best are common snails and nerite snails. They breed just as easy IMO. Ramshorn and trumpet snails are too hard and can crack their teeth. If I do use em I feed super small ones so they can crack them. But they also present a choking hazard even death. No ramShornnor trumpet snails at all. I'm just trying to get rid of mine.
Re: Are garden pond snails ok
Posted: Fri Apr 09, 2010 1:22 am
by Pufferpunk
At the end of every summer, we'd drain our swimming pool 1/2 way. all the water on the ground would make the worms come out in hundreds. Pufferfeast for weeks!
Re: Are garden pond snails ok
Posted: Fri Apr 09, 2010 1:36 am
by SammyDee
I am scared for my lil guys to catch something from
outside prey. Like worms.
Re: Are garden pond snails ok
Posted: Fri Apr 09, 2010 6:03 am
by pufferpuggirl
SammyDee wrote:Nothing from outside. Not even worms. No ramshorn either. They're too hard. I feed them but I'm not trying to breed them. The best are common snails and nerite snails. They breed just as easy IMO. Ramshorn and trumpet snails are too hard and can crack their teeth. If I do use em I feed super small ones so they can crack them. But they also present a choking hazard even death. No ramShornnor trumpet snails at all. I'm just trying to get rid of mine.
I don't understand why you think ramshorn snails are bad for puffers? I feed mine ramshorn all the time and they have got to be one of the better snails to use. Their shell isn't very hard to crack, it's very easy in fact. On the other hand, I agree that Malaysian Trumpet snails (MTS) are not good to use because they ARE too hard.
I'm also confused that you are using nerite snails, unless we are talking about different things, because I've bought nerites and their shell is very thick. I would not want my puffer eating them, and in fact, I had some in my tank with my Mbu and he did eat a few and when I seen how thick their shell was, I was glad that it didn't hurt him. Also my understanding is that nerite eggs can't hatch without being in brackish water. They live in freshwater and then travel into brackish water to lay their eggs? Has anyone else heard about this?

Re: Are garden pond snails ok
Posted: Fri Apr 09, 2010 8:18 am
by Iliveinazoo
pufferpuggirl wrote:SammyDee wrote:
I'm also confused that you are using nerite snails, unless we are talking about different things, because I've bought nerites and their shell is very thick. I would not want my puffer eating them, and in fact, I had some in my tank with my Mbu and he did eat a few and when I seen how thick their shell was, I was glad that it didn't hurt him. Also my understanding is that nerite eggs can't hatch without being in brackish water. They live in freshwater and then travel into brackish water to lay their eggs? Has anyone else heard about this?

Yeah SammyDee I think that you may have got the Ramshorns and Nerites mixed up. Ramshorns are freshwater and multiply, Nerites have thick shells and require both males and females and brackish water to breed, the young then go through a larval stage which, I think, can take them out to sea before they return. I can't think of anyone who has succesfully managed to breed them - brilliant algae eaters but not puffer food.
Re: Are garden pond snails ok
Posted: Sat Apr 10, 2010 4:37 am
by SammyDee
Idk these are fw the lfs sold em to me as fw and breed extremely well. Ramshorn pointed right?