Page 1 of 2

What's a good snail w/ fast reproduction and growth as food?

Posted: Thu Mar 11, 2010 2:57 am
by emartin
What's a good snail that reproduces fast and grows fast to be used as a puffer food?

And with this snail, what can I do to water chemistry and feed them to even further increase their growth rate?

I was thinking of adding trace amounts of Lawn Lime for the shells.

Will a very high water temperature (82-90F) (with air stones for major aeration (turbulent aeration!)) improve growth and reproduction rates?

Obviously I know nothing about snails except that they are nearly impossible to kill... I have a snail infestation in my overflows and sump of my 265g but they are "dwarf" pond snails that don't get bigger than maybe 5mm I've seen one grow to so those are useless. I nuked that sump with Copper sulfate ('Had-A-Snail three whole bottles (MEGA OVERDOSE)) and 1/3 of a gallon of clear ammonia and the overflows each with a gallon of ammonia, and all of them had lethal amounts of sea salt added... Killed all the LIVE SNAILS... Two weeks later I see over a hundred snails again... By that point I gave up and learned to live with them LOL.

~Ed

Re: What's a good snail w/ fast reproduction and growth as food?

Posted: Thu Mar 11, 2010 4:34 am
by Nick
Temperature 78-80 degrees. Use ramshorns for bigger puffs. MTS are really easy to breed, and I find my puffers demolish them, but they are too controversial for me to recommend them with general confidence; better fishkeepers than I have said they can cause problems. They generally thrive in very clean water and large tanks. Set up a 29 or a 55, and you will be in snails for LIFE. Set up a 2.5 like I have, or a 10, and you'll be scraping, but probably have enough for a few puffers. I combine decent feedings of foods that don't rot too fast(blanched veggies) and quick snacks(algae pellets) and mine seem to grow decently fast even in the small tank. It is live planted, and the ramshorns do supplement their diet by eating the plants a bit, though not as fast as they grow with over ten watts over a 2.5.

Re: What's a good snail w/ fast reproduction and growth as food?

Posted: Thu Mar 11, 2010 6:08 am
by emartin
I was thinking of getting a plastic 55g drum or the like for a snail culture.


I know of some LFS nearby me that sell MTS snails for $2 a piece.... Kind of hilarious isn't it?

Re: What's a good snail w/ fast reproduction and growth as food?

Posted: Thu Mar 11, 2010 6:27 am
by emartin
I have thought of putting them in a rubbermaid stock tank or indoor above ground miniature-pond (I can't see myself wasting a 55g for snails even if it did supply constant food for a pufferfish... My cichlids would get pissed!).

On a positive note, thanks to aquabid I found out what snail likely is infesting my 265g's sump and overflows: Physa fontinalis

The shells, adult size, and empty shells (how they are sort of transparent) all match up.




Also..."mystery snails"... I've seen them for sale. Are they easy to breed/fast growing? Or are ramshorn the best bet?

I've also been seeing HUGE "pond" snails at a local pond place about 30 minutes from where I live. They were all easily golfball size. Any idea on what those are and if they are easy to breed and fast to raise?

~Ed

Re: What's a good snail w/ fast reproduction and growth as food?

Posted: Thu Mar 11, 2010 6:39 am
by pufferpuggirl
In my experience, ramshorn seem to reproduce the quickest. I've got both ramshorn and the pond snails (shells sort of shaped like a football). I've got a small tank devoted just to snails, but I noticed that the snails in my puffer's tank (a lurker, not one that will eat the snails) were multiplying quicker than the ones in my snail tank and the reason is that the mussel meat that I was putting in for the puffer was being eaten by the snails. Now I do give them algae wafers as well, but it seems that they really grow quick when you feed them meat, either mussel or chopped up shrimp.
I'm not sure what your "huge" pond snails are, but the tiny pond snails that I have in my tank will also reproduce fairly quickly, although I'm not sure they will multiply as fast as the ramshorn. But I've quite a few puffers and so far, the snails that I have are supplying enough for me to feed all my puffers some snails once a week. There are times when they get more than once a week, but I think it would wipe out my supply if I were to feed more often. :)

Just a note, but if you're going to breed snails in a Rubbermaid container, will they be getting light and a source of heat?

Re: What's a good snail w/ fast reproduction and growth as food?

Posted: Thu Mar 11, 2010 8:09 am
by emartin
Source of heat of course. Why would they need a source of light? They'd get light pollution from windows, other tanks, and the garage light (motion sensor goes on whenever i or dogs go in there)

Re: What's a good snail w/ fast reproduction and growth as food?

Posted: Thu Mar 11, 2010 8:47 am
by pufferpuggirl
I suppose as long as they're getting some source of light, then that's okay. It's just that I think every living thing (well most) need a source of light.

Re: What's a good snail w/ fast reproduction and growth as food?

Posted: Thu Mar 11, 2010 9:08 am
by RTR
I am one of the folks who would never feed a MTS to any puffer, under any circumstances.

Depending on what puffers you plan to feed,either common pond snails (family Physidae) or ramshorn snails (family Planorbidae) will grow fast. Either will do best in a tank of their own. If you want large snails, larger tanks are needed, or keeping the population lower to reduce competition.

Snail breeding tanks should be handled just as any other FW tanks - clean water, plenty but not too much food, tank temperatures similar to tropical tanks.

HTH

Re: What's a good snail w/ fast reproduction and growth as food?

Posted: Thu Mar 11, 2010 11:09 am
by Tigerlilly
I have had Ramshorn ones about a week now ... theres 12 in the tank and 16 egg blobs since yesterday, maybe more today... each egg blob has about 20 eggs.
So about 16 x 20 .. 320 snails in 4 weeks if they all survive.

I've just been feeding them cucumber.

Re: What's a good snail w/ fast reproduction and growth as food?

Posted: Thu Mar 11, 2010 6:42 pm
by RTR
A varied diet is best, but veggies are good.

Re: What's a good snail w/ fast reproduction and growth as food?

Posted: Thu Mar 11, 2010 7:59 pm
by emartin
Which kind of ramshorn snails? Just normal red ones for example, or the giant ramshorn snails?

Re: What's a good snail w/ fast reproduction and growth as food?

Posted: Thu Mar 11, 2010 8:41 pm
by Tigerlilly
The normal red/pink ones, about 1cm big.

Re: What's a good snail w/ fast reproduction and growth as food?

Posted: Thu Mar 11, 2010 9:58 pm
by emartin
they only get 1cm big? that's kind of useless for food for a fahaka puffer...

Re: What's a good snail w/ fast reproduction and growth as food?

Posted: Thu Mar 11, 2010 10:01 pm
by Tigerlilly
I'm not sure how big they get sorry, but thats what mine are at the moment :) if that's the size they stay then yeh that's not great!
I know apple snails get big, just not sure how they are to breed.

Re: What's a good snail w/ fast reproduction and growth as food?

Posted: Thu Mar 11, 2010 11:27 pm
by LilGreenPuffer
I've had some ramshorns up to 3/4", but if you're feeding a fahaka, you should breed mysteries/apples. I have a friend who breeds them and gets great results. They lay huge clutches. But they will eat the eggs of other snails, so don't keep them with other breeding species.