Page 1 of 1

Bacteria

Posted: Fri Mar 05, 2010 2:37 pm
by Flutter
I'm doing some research just for fun (means I can delay doing my bioinformatics report) and I thought I'd share some of the information I find.

This product works (ABIL Nitrifying Solution):
http://www.tmc-ltd.co.uk/commercial/abil-remus.asp
It's been scientifically tested for both FW AND SW. Same bottle.

"The nitrification process is catalysed by two phylogenetically unrelated groups of chemolithoautotrophic bacteria: the ammonia-oxidizing bacteria (AOB) and the nitrite-oxidizing bacteria (NOB). AOB form two monophyletic groups within the Betaproteobacteria and Gammaproteobacteria [7], while the NOB belong to four different genera within the Alphaproteobacteria, Gammaproteobacteria and Deltaproteobacteria and the phylum Nitrospira [8]. The Betaproteobacteria contains the highest diversity of AOB, encompassing the genera Nitrosomonas, Nitrosospira, Nitrosolobus and Nitrosovibrio."

"In this study, the initial nitrite oxidation rate was also significantly lower in the artificial seawater biofilters than in freshwater biofilters. After 5 days these differences disappeared."

"Nitrosomonas marina is considered to be obligate halophilic, although N. marina strains have been detected in freshwater biofilters"

"According to a PCR–DGGE analysis, the nitrifying inoculum used in this study is characterised by the presence of one dominant AOB strain, closely related to N. marina. This strain is able to colonize biofilters both in freshwater and seawater systems in a reproducible way and persisted in all systems throughout experiments."

Grommen R., Dauw L., Verstraete W. 2004. Elevated salinity selects for a less diverse ammonia-oxidizing population in aquarium biofilters. Microbiology Ecology.

End result: Ammonia oxidizing and nitrate oxidizing bacteria indeed CAN be the same for both SW and FW and establishes permanent colonies.

Re: Bacteria

Posted: Fri Mar 05, 2010 2:49 pm
by Flutter
There are several articles that Hanovec has done however they are all obviously funded by Aquaria Inc. I looked into several of his papers and none have been cited by another paper, not even once over the years. We are taught that this means the paper is "insignificant" and has not contributed to advancement of the field.

Re: Bacteria

Posted: Fri Mar 05, 2010 4:35 pm
by J-P
so he's a quack?

Re: Bacteria

Posted: Fri Mar 05, 2010 4:54 pm
by Flutter
No no. His research may still be completely valid!

It's just that no one else has found it 'important' enough to use. Studies directly and obviously funded by a business could have some bias as well.

There have been quite a few studies on ammonia and nitrite oxidizing bacteria and not a single one used any of his papers as a reference. I think that's significant, though it doesn't mean that this guy isn't doing valid research.

I have no interest in bacteria but I'm so temped to start approaching profs and saying I want to study this for my masters. LOL.

Re: Bacteria

Posted: Fri Mar 05, 2010 9:58 pm
by RTR
Not a quack, a development (read as: marketable product) oriented scientist can do just as valid work as any ivory tower resident. BUT, their finding are already protected by patent applications and cannot be used without $$ by another researcher. Starving grad students and funding-hungry post docs and researchers have little interest in things which cost extra to work on and cannot pay off for them or their institution.

Dr Hovanec's early work turned the biofiltration world on its ear by effectively studying tank biofilters to see what actually did the job in stable mature tanks and maintained permanent colonies there.

Flutter: If you still have the reprint, or easy access to it, what was "...the term of the experiment." As in how long did it run? That is key to "permanent" colonies. The initial differences in rates are trivial - especially if the inocula came from water unlike that into which it was placed - some lag is expected in any adaptation, Not all metabolic pathways are created equal, and not all are likely to be in place if not currently in use, but once established tend to be pretty close to equally effective to the organism - otherwise they would not use them.

The hedging on 'strains' does imply that any given wild-type species picked out randomly may likely not work in either case equally well. The refs to such strains might also be interesting as well.

Re: Bacteria

Posted: Fri Mar 05, 2010 11:40 pm
by Flutter
I don't have the article so lets see what I can remember.

The product was able to seed both tanks and the experiment went on for months. 6 maybe? No fish or water that had had fish went into the tanks, they were simply seeded with ammonia. The FW tank was filled with RO water and the SW tank had prepared salt water which was able to provide guaranteed analysis of the contents.

They found that the bacteria were able to tolerate very wide ranges in salinity. However, there was much more diversity in FW than SW. Not all could tolerate the full SW which is why there was a bit of a lag (the 5 days mentioned).

Some of his papers did contain patent numbers but many did not. I have never heard of needing to pay someone for citing their article, that doesn't make sense to me. Being a grad student is a paid position anyways and the money for getting that permission if necessary would not come from their pocket.

Re: Bacteria

Posted: Sat Mar 06, 2010 8:59 am
by RTR
You do not pay for citing, but if you want their bugs, you pay, and any application using the bugs you pay very well indeed. You can bet the patents are very broad brushes. That does not always hold up in court, but patent lawsuits are massively expensive and researchers go out of their way to avoid even the remotest possibility of such.