Page 1 of 2

my tank set up looks very odd... pls help

Posted: Mon Mar 01, 2010 9:56 pm
by kilofey
so, i just got a bunch of new plants for my palembang's 55gal. he is alone. his decor consists of a 1' tall volcano, a 1' tall t-rex, and a large piece of drift wood with a large anubia plant. as for plants, there is 1 aponogeton, 2 amazon swords, 6 vallisneria, and another unknown plant (commonly found at petco, nothing special)

i have everything evenly distributed in the tank... but it looks very odd... does anyone have any pix of their planted tank?... id like to group them together somehow so they look good... just cant figure out how to make it look right. ive been messin with it for about an hour and probably making my palem pretty irritated...
PS- those are 2 breeder boxes at the top, ones for my cherry shrimp/ghost shrimp babies, and the other box is a holding tank for crayfish dinners... sorry the pic is so crooked :shock: didnt look that way when i took it lol

heres my set up:
Image

Re: my tank set up looks very odd... pls help

Posted: Mon Mar 01, 2010 10:08 pm
by J-P
The volcano is a little too dominant. Back a bit and too the right.

APC (aquatic plant central) has good ideas http://www.aquaticplantcentral.com/
http://www.aquascapingworld.com/ <== another cool site for ideas

The journals from Ammano have arrived but I can't post it on the internet. Copywright issues

Re: my tank set up looks very odd... pls help

Posted: Mon Mar 01, 2010 10:13 pm
by kilofey
J-P wrote:The volcano is a little too dominant. Back a bit and too the right.

APC (aquatic plant central) has good ideas http://www.aquaticplantcentral.com/
http://www.aquascapingworld.com/ <== another cool site for ideas

The journals from Ammano have arrived but I can't post it on the internet. Copywright issues
i agree, the volcano is a little much... its what is left over from my red devil tank... he was so rambunxious, that i had to get very large decorations with wide bases so he didnt knock them over. should i ditch it and just leave the t-rex in there? or would he look out of place without the volcano? btw, thanks 4 the links, ill check em out now

Re: my tank set up looks very odd... pls help

Posted: Mon Mar 01, 2010 10:31 pm
by J-P
this is a panorama of the last 1/2 of my 210

I used the drift wood to keep the eyes off the pumps. most of the plants in the fore ground are new and will be transplanted later (once they sprout).

It is a little cloudy but it is FAR from being ready for a serious photo

Re: my tank set up looks very odd... pls help

Posted: Tue Mar 02, 2010 1:09 am
by kilofey
that drift wood is gorgeous. ive been looking for something like that... found some today at a LFS, but go figure, it wasnt for sale... they had some christmas moss growing on it... i was going to buy the whole thing... probably like 200 bucks for the whole thing with as much moss that was on it... but they wouldnt even sell it to me, eventhough i offered to buy the entire thing... grrrr

Re: my tank set up looks very odd... pls help

Posted: Tue Mar 02, 2010 1:13 am
by kilofey
this is the tank's inhabitant :love: (finally got a good pic)
Image

Re: my tank set up looks very odd... pls help

Posted: Tue Mar 02, 2010 1:37 am
by Pufferpunk
Group like plants together in at least 3s, in a triangular pattern, not next to each other.

Re: my tank set up looks very odd... pls help

Posted: Tue Mar 02, 2010 2:10 am
by kilofey
okay :) thanks PP, ill do it now & see if it helps... it just looks too much like plants that have been purchased... im tryin to get the natural look... almost like it grew there by itself... ill try it out

Re: my tank set up looks very odd... pls help

Posted: Tue Mar 02, 2010 2:13 am
by Pufferpunk
Believe me--i'm pretty good at aquascaping. ;)

Re: my tank set up looks very odd... pls help

Posted: Tue Mar 02, 2010 1:27 pm
by purplecandle
+ 1 to PP

In nature..things may seem random, but more often than not there is some sort of pattern at play..even though we may not see it. (Particularly for small plants, sticking together helps the plants to survive, repopulate and choke out other plants) Setting like plants together in some sort of pattern..in this case a triangular pattern..would give a more natural effect.

Bigger plants in the back or corners might help too...

IDK, I am horrible with growing plants..It is fake plants for me!

Re: my tank set up looks very odd... pls help

Posted: Tue Mar 02, 2010 4:27 pm
by RTR
One of the best hints that I can offer is to avoid having it look like the for sale plant tanks at the LFS. Only large, or potentially large, plants can ever be solitary - swords, aponogetons, etc. - all others are always in "drifts". A drift is multiple of the same plant, largest in a corner or the center of the clump, smaller ranging out from it, and with a"trail" of a few of the smallest plantlets visibly trailing off from the clump, as if the group is spreading) and if it is val, it will, and create its own trails - you just pick one to keep for a while and transplant the others. Later pick another trail and remove the former one, etc - you control the spread but make it look like it is spreading wild.

Another of my things is avoid too may species and/or cultivars on one tank. It is difficult to make what looks like a still life look real to me. Plants in nature do not grow at all like that. One type of plant flourishes and crowds out the others but a bit deeper or shallower or higher or less current and something else dominates. Check out some of Amao's single-species tanks - most are wonderful. You do not have to have an artist's eye, or a horticulturist's skill to pick out 3 or 4 plants which do well for you and use multiples of each - I promise you, it will be easier and look better than a Noah's Ark plant tank does in unskilled hands.

I do not grow that many different plants, all are ones that do well for me without a lot of care. It has been said of my tanks that they show how you can vary the effect of using 3 or 4 genera of plants making any number of quite different-looking setups using very close to the same materials differently in each tank. It simplifies my life a lot, and my displays usually look pretty good without much work on my part.

Never use pairs, they look phony. Use 3s, 5s. 7s,etc. -for whatever reason, odd numbers look more natural to people (the fish accept anything, but will look and live best if the tank is set for them - i.e., no carpets with a palembang, they block sight lines to live food and make fish stealth difficult). Trim the bottom leaves of sword in the same tank, for the same reason -the palembang's sight lines. But it will just a bit slow the sword's growth - which makes it last longer in the setup before it ha to be dug out and replaced with a smaller plant (which is a massive and messy chore).

Are you at all a gardener? You have to learn when selecting and planting not just for this season's "look", but how it will look year-round, and how it will or will not not fit a it matures.

HTH

Re: my tank set up looks very odd... pls help

Posted: Wed Mar 03, 2010 4:38 am
by kilofey
cool, thanks RTR... i have it rearranged right now... ill try to get some pix up in the next day or so

Re: my tank set up looks very odd... pls help

Posted: Wed Mar 03, 2010 6:48 am
by pufferpuggirl
And don't forget that it's going to take a little time for the plants to "grow in", and when they do, it will look more natural. :)

Re: my tank set up looks very odd... pls help

Posted: Wed Mar 03, 2010 8:40 am
by RTR
You are welcome.

PPG is correct- a 'new' aquascape takes a bit of time to 'grow in' and look right. If you set forit to look right initially, you will be doing a lot of pruning/thinning too soon. it is not only easier, it is to me better to make minor changes while the plants are a bit thinner than the 'look' you want. Before long, it will look more mature and then it is fine-tuning upkeep. I should have added that bit initially.

After you have more experience aquascaping, you can get closer to your final look initially. But it still easier for me to fine-tune before the plants grow-in fully.

Re: my tank set up looks very odd... pls help

Posted: Wed Mar 03, 2010 12:59 pm
by marksrush
Well I kind of thought your tank didn't look so bad, although I might have not used the volcano or the T-rex. But then I have a very poor sense of design - unlike the popular stereotype of my "team". Learning to keep it simple with a lot of one kind of plant rather than dozens of different species was a big step for me.