Page 1 of 2
Interesting response by Seachem on Prime
Posted: Wed Feb 24, 2010 10:20 pm
by Kungpaoshizi
I'll let you read this for yourself, I think it's a serious joke...
Been using Amquel Plus, and it totally rocks, as far as for Prime, after reading this AND doing multiple tests with tap water, Amquel+ is freaking awesome... Just an fyi if anyone is wondering about the 2.
The only reason I wanted to try Prime was it said it detox's heavy metals, which Amquel doesn't..
But I see a clear winner in this comparison, especially after the novel response from the company.. lol!
It makes me laugh
Oh ya, and normal dose versus normal dose, Amquel wins. Whereas evidently with Prime "it must be an overdose" lol
Just my experience with the 2 products..and straight from the horses mouth.
__________________________________________________________________________________________
To be honest, we do not have a specific number of nitrates that are removed/detoxified with one dose of Prime. Prime will detoxify nitrates for up to 48 hours until your biological filter can remove/consume them. Here is a quote from our FAQ page on Prime and nitrates:
Q: How does Prime make a difference in reducing Nitrates?
A: The detoxification of nitrite and nitrate by Prime (when used at elevated levels) is not well understood from a mechanistic standpoint. The most likely explanation is that the nitrite and nitrate is removed in a manner similar to the way ammonia is removed; i.e. it is bound and held in a inert state until such time that bacteria in the biological filter are able to take a hold of it, break it apart and use it. Two other possible scenarios are reduction to nitrogen (N2) gas or conversion into a benign organic nitrogen compound.
I wish we had some more "concrete" explanation, but the end result is the same, it does actually detoxify nitrite and nitrate. This was unexpected chemically and thus initially we were not even aware of this, however we received numerous reports from customers stating that when they overdosed with Prime they were able to reduce or eliminate the high death rates they experienced when their nitrite and nitrate levels were high. We have received enough reports to date to ensure that this is no fluke and is in fact a verifiable function of the product.
http://www.seachem.com/support/forums/s ... p=7770#pos t7770
Re: Interesting response by Seachem on Prime
Posted: Wed Feb 24, 2010 10:30 pm
by Pufferpunk
That's completely idiotic! How can a company make/sell a product they don't understand how or why it works?
Re: Interesting response by Seachem on Prime
Posted: Thu Feb 25, 2010 7:50 am
by pufferpuggirl
Well I still like it as Amquel over here is VERY expensive, and Prime is better than what's available. I accept that it might not be perfect, but not many things are.

Re: Interesting response by Seachem on Prime
Posted: Thu Feb 25, 2010 8:46 am
by Nick
There are 3 main stages in technology. First, there is observation. This stage is generally promoted in text books as "Eureka!" moments, but the VAST majority of actual observations which lead to inquiry are actually much like the statement about prime above... the scientific equivalent of "Huh, THATS strange..." Something is repeatedly observed that the current understanding of the subjects of observation do not account for based on what we currently know about them.
IMO, Seachem should be applauded for saying "we don't understand how this happens yet, but it is observed to be so" rather than making up some BS mumbo-jumbo or answer by tautology(for instance "Prime uses sulfur based compounds which affect the chemical structure of nearly all simple nitrogenous wastes in some way and the formula was designed to keep aquarium water as safe as possible for your fish by neutralizing dangerous wastes and chemicals almost immediately while still being safe to overdose for emergency spikes.") - which sound better, are not technically lies, and inspire much more confidence. This is what most companies do, even with human pharmaceuticals and, more rampantly, with human dietary supplements. Seachem chose NOT to do that, and telling the whole truth about something they could have EASILY given a very satisfying partial truth answer should be considered a virtue, not a detriment.
After observation, there comes, as mentioned above, repeatability: after we have a weird, repeatable, and unexplainable observation, we can form a theory about what is occurring. Once we have such a theory, we can use the scientific method to study it and modify/replace it with more accurate theories and very precisely explain what has occurred.
Re: Interesting response by Seachem on Prime
Posted: Thu Feb 25, 2010 11:00 am
by RTR
Prime was not designed to affect nitrite or nitrate. It was created to break up chloramines and lock ammonia dissolved gas into the ammonium ion form, (which is available to biofilter bacteria) plus converting chlorine dissolved gas into the chloride ion form and it does those very well indeed at normal doses. That is all that the company intended, and all that was claimed.
Customer responses and inquiries led them to look a overdose situations involving the other two partially oxidized nitrogen metabolites, and they did notice and agree that the effect was real and valid.
Sorry PP, your criticism does not hold water. Drugs and chemical agents are lab and clinically or application-area tested extensively prior to release, but unexpected side effects - especially in OD situations are outside and far beyond any government required government or specialized industry-supported agency requirements, and are common as dirt. Huma drug OD levels are determined, and OD symptoms added to drug data sheets as required. Do not expect the applied world to be any different for industries such as the hobby world, where there are no, repeat no legal requirements for use labeling, only for human hazard and potential human contact toxicities. I promise you, we are in an effectively regulation-free hobby as far as the water and fish treatments we buy and use.
To me, Prime is so far superior to existing Amquel formulations (they have multiple, choices depending on water conditions) that comparisons are a farce. Amquel was the only game in town way back when, but after Prime came out, I along with many others immediately switched. None of the Amquel formulations are the original and effective one BTW, and none are as effective or as efficient as Prime in its primary use, to detoxify the secondary disinfectants added by utilities for water protection post processing plant. That is what and exactly all I look for in a "conditioner" The rest is largely bogus in any case - the heavy metal "detoxification' is a farce expected of the average hobbyist, and any OD use is at the user's risk and choice - the manufacturer will not recognize the validity of any claims from users to the contrary. Prime is unusually free of issues from ODing - for which we should be grateful. Don't try that with most Amquel formulations - if you pick the wrong one for you water profile, you could be in deep trouble.
Many folks use Excel OD for algae issues. If they destroy plants or the tank, it is their problem not the manufacturer's. That is the industry standard. Has been forever and is very likely to remain so indefinitely. The gov and the industry do not have regulations and support staffing and cannot afford to police such industries any more that they do - for clear and present human hazards.
Hope that clarifies...
Edited for typos.
Re: Interesting response by Seachem on Prime
Posted: Tue Mar 02, 2010 12:59 am
by Myaj
I still prefer the original Amquel. I'm just looking for a dechlor and Prime smells horrible to me.
Actually, I prefer Yamato Green's dechlor, but I never seem to remember to order it, and since I buy Amquel or Prime in big bottles, its not very often I need more!
Re: Interesting response by Seachem on Prime
Posted: Tue Mar 02, 2010 7:22 pm
by RTR
But the "original Amquel" isn't.
And yes, Prime smells of sulfur. Sulfur compounds are very useful (thiosulfate for example), but nobody is going to offer them as perfume.
Re: Interesting response by Seachem on Prime
Posted: Wed Mar 03, 2010 12:29 pm
by Myaj
Well, I meant Amquel vs Amquel Plus actually
Though for someone with a cycling tank, Amquel and Prime can really help the process along.
Re: Interesting response by Seachem on Prime
Posted: Wed Mar 03, 2010 7:32 pm
by RTR
The original Amquel was great stuff. too bad they "improved" it. And then had to do more variations.
Re: Interesting response by Seachem on Prime
Posted: Mon Mar 08, 2010 8:43 pm
by Kungpaoshizi
The main thing I thought was pretty interesting was not the fact they came forward and said all that, but how come they don't "refine" their instructions...
I wouldn't use it for the nitrite/nitrate effect after reading that, but I'm sure it works fine for chlorine/amine/metals...
I was just disappointed it said that stuff on the bottle and come to find out you HAVE to overdose for that particular effect and they don't specify "overdose"...
Could cause quite the problem in the long run.. especially when you stop using it, and if something in the tank was going on perhaps a mini cycle, then BAM everything isn't bonded anymore and it would be an ultimate spike in every direction...
Re: Interesting response by Seachem on Prime
Posted: Mon Mar 08, 2010 8:47 pm
by Flutter
They can't say the doses until they do legitimate and serious testing on it. Perhaps that's happening or they're planning on it. Perhaps it's more economical to put it forward just the way they have.
I don't really see the big deal in all of this.
Re: Interesting response by Seachem on Prime
Posted: Tue Mar 09, 2010 9:45 am
by Kungpaoshizi
Unless you do testing, you waste 10$ on a product that defines nitrite/nitrate management...
Technically, I bet they could be sued over false advertising...
I've heard of other people who had bad experiences and lost fish because of this.
<insert expected responses on proper management for both through size/natural biological processes here>
Re: Interesting response by Seachem on Prime
Posted: Tue Mar 09, 2010 10:14 am
by RTR
Go right ahead. They have deep pockets.
The product is designed for pre-coditioning water, to neutralizes the negative effects of chlorine or chloramines on tanks dwellers. Use it for that.
Nitrite/nitrate issues are cycling/tank management issues. If you have those, they are fish-keeper problems, not water disinfectant neutralization issues. Prime is safer than any other product i am familiar with on overdoses, but I see no reason why a tank should require such use when properly handled. If you don't like or don't want to OD prime, do your water changes to alleviate the problem, but you still need an effective neutralizer for the water disinfectant. then correct the situation that led to the need for extra water changes.
Re: Interesting response by Seachem on Prime
Posted: Tue Mar 09, 2010 8:12 pm
by Kungpaoshizi
Ahh yes, I'm finding the most satisfying intolerance of everyone new in all the fish forums... lol
You say it's 'not a water disinfectant neutralization issue' whatever dude, can you not read?
Next time, read the label, and put yourself in the shoes of someone who is new to all this.
Then re-read your post, and understand how difficult it is, to NOT use profanity.
I thought some people would LIKE to know what Seachem ACTUALLY says about their product, but then people get all defensive and drag the newbs over the coals. Same situation with other forums and people who have cycling/crashing issues.
Thanks for the productive criticism? Ha!
Re: Interesting response by Seachem on Prime
Posted: Tue Mar 09, 2010 8:25 pm
by Flutter
I just want to say that in general I've found this board quite friendly. I know there have been some interpersonal issues but overall it's pretty darn good.
The two other fish BBs I belong to are extremely friendly as well, even more so than this one. You seem to have opposite experiences. I just have to ask, what's the common factor in your experiences?