Page 1 of 2

Lotus lost the bulb

Posted: Wed Feb 24, 2010 7:07 pm
by J-P
I was working on the tank today and decided to transplant one of my Lotus plants.

Oddly enough it came apart from the bulb but still had the roots intact. I re planted it and the bulb wich also showed root growth. Was this the correct thing to do? As this is a fairly new set up I am not certain how these plants propagate.

Re: Lotus lost the bulb

Posted: Wed Feb 24, 2010 8:17 pm
by RTR
You just did it. You separate the growing points from the tuber and plant them separately. Other (dormant) "eyes" will likely sprout.

BTW, aquarium "lotus" are water lilies. True lotus are huge emerse plants with elevated leaves and tall flower stalks, they grow from slender elongated tube like long skinny bananas - chained end-to-end. Massive plants and hugely invasive, would likely break any aquarium they were put into.

HTH

Re: Lotus lost the bulb

Posted: Wed Feb 24, 2010 8:29 pm
by J-P
Thank you! I wasn't sure if I was doing things correctly.

The bulb was ID'd as aquarium "Tiger Lotus"

I have kept water lillies in the pond before (I think I still have 1 that has survived) and yes they get HUGE. I just wish I could have more. Very beautiful.

Re: Lotus lost the bulb

Posted: Thu Feb 25, 2010 5:14 pm
by Nick
I used to try water lilies regularly in my tanks, but found that either by some quirk of genetics or the lighting they were getting, they would only put out a couple aquatic leaves, then shoot massive numbers of pads to the water surface, blocking light to the other plants and requiring weekly trimming.

Re: Lotus lost the bulb

Posted: Thu Feb 25, 2010 5:19 pm
by J-P
Nick wrote:I used to try water lilies regularly in my tanks, but found that either by some quirk of genetics or the lighting they were getting, they would only put out a couple aquatic leaves, then shoot massive numbers of pads to the water surface, blocking light to the other plants and requiring weekly trimming.

I don't think this is a pond lilly. Although that is next om my list:
http://www.aquaticplantcentral.com/foru ... water.html <== the last pic on the bottom is my goal.

The one that lost the bulb is just a little guy with lotus shaped leaves... I don't think it is a true lotus as RTR pointed out. APC said Tiger Lotus ... maybe a "mini" tiger :)

it looks exactly like NYMPHAEA LOTUS 'RED" but not the same size.

Re: Lotus lost the bulb

Posted: Thu Feb 25, 2010 5:31 pm
by Nick
I'd get them as dried-up bulbs in the aquarium store, and they did this:
http://i566.photobucket.com/albums/ss10 ... gem022.jpg
All surface pads, no real aquatic leaves.

Re: Lotus lost the bulb

Posted: Thu Feb 25, 2010 5:48 pm
by J-P
Here you can see the leaves, and a solid root structure.

The little brown thing just infront of it was the old bulb which is sprouting again.

At the moment no CO2 or ferts added (I'm medicating)

or possibly NYMPHAEA MICRANTHA but red instead of green ....

Re: Lotus lost the bulb

Posted: Thu Feb 25, 2010 6:43 pm
by RTR
To avoid floating leaves on water lilies (even if they come labeled "lotus" they are lilies) you need to have two things in place - a non-nutritious substate and a good eye - you can see the difference in leaves destined to be floating pads, and you must cut them off before they reach the water surface. If both conditions are not met, your tank will be doomed to be shaded out by lily pads - or banana plant pads (which are much more attractive - the undersides are quite similar in look, if less prichky, than the Victoria Regina pads, without the walled edges or underside prickles - magnificent!). Those will shade out everything else in the tank excepting Java Moss and Anubias nana (which will not grow, but will not die either. It makes a glorious roof for the Gourimis of the genus Trichogaster, and they love the pads for spawning sites. So for that matter do the porthole and flagtail catfish, and likely other bubblenest builders. It is a good topping for shade tanks such as the baby whale group also - the lighting, though strong above the surface, is dimmmed a lot below.

The smallest miniature water lily - which these bulbs are far from - will fill a 3'' diameter tub solid and pile up leaves atop one another if well grown (rich substrate and full sun). That is over 7 square feet as minimum housing. 12 square feet is about right IME. The banana plant has very nice flowers BTW, and produces baby plants in the leaf axils - with bananas!

Water lilies are not small plants, even when miniature. Big ones - such as the Victorias - one can take over a pool larger than the average suburban swimming pool in weeks. Neither are banana plants small when gown at all well. The two main hobby forms were chosen for attractive submerse foliage, which to the plant is relatively short growth phase. You have to starve them and not let them "know" how far it is to the surface to keep them in control.

HTH

Re: Lotus lost the bulb

Posted: Thu Feb 25, 2010 6:51 pm
by J-P
RTR you made my day!

I can not express how happy I am (if I was a woman I'd hug you).

A) this may solve my plant problem on the top tank once they mature

B) I was paying $40+ for lillies for our pond. Now I can grow my own!

I really hope they mature. I am very excited!

Re: Lotus lost the bulb

Posted: Thu Feb 25, 2010 7:16 pm
by Flutter
J-P wrote:I can not express how happy I am (if I was a woman I'd hug you).
Guys are so silly... Sheesh. A hug is a hug. I just don't get why guys have these touching phobias...

Re: Lotus lost the bulb

Posted: Thu Feb 25, 2010 8:36 pm
by RTR
I have a couple of friends (males) who are huggers. The first time is a shock, but you do get over that. Now,one guy in particular, I would think that I had offended him if he did not do a good-bye hug.

J-P You are welcome! Some tropical lilies are vivaporous (= produce miniature plantlets at the leaf axils) just as are banana plants. I don't know if these are or not. I'll try to look it up.

Re: Lotus lost the bulb

Posted: Thu Feb 25, 2010 8:40 pm
by J-P
:hijack:

well I hope I am doing the right thing.

I really would like to see these grow to maturity.

:ontopic:

Re: Lotus lost the bulb

Posted: Thu Feb 25, 2010 11:41 pm
by Nick
That explains why my banana plants always do that, too. I gave up on them for another reason though - the banana portion always rots off, then the plant dies, at some random point between 3 months and one year. I take care not to let it get submerged in substrate, and still, it seems it's only a question of how long before I kill the poor thing. These dwarf lilies are cheap at pet stores, so I may try the trim and starve method next time I have a large freshwater tank... I mean, after I upgrade the salt water tank to a 180 or 220, I'll still have a very nice 72 bow with a stand, sump and return pumps... all of that stuff will be far too small for the new tank.

Re: Lotus lost the bulb

Posted: Fri Feb 26, 2010 9:34 am
by RTR
Nick: if the storage tubers are above the substrate, the plant will put down roots between or beside them into the substrate, and those will take over the plants nouurishment needs, as well as anchoring it in place to mature. Is your substrate at all fertile (either long established or enriched)?

In the wild, the adventitious plantlets from the older floating leaves break lose when the leaf breaks up from old age, allowing the plantlet (with storage tubers to sustain it) to float free. It eventually strands itself somewhere in shallow water, roots, and restarts the life cycle. All that is in parallel with seed production. These plants,like the vivaporous water lilies (all are tropical, no hardy types, and only some tropical lineages show this trait) do pretty much the same.

HTH

Re: Lotus lost the bulb

Posted: Fri Feb 26, 2010 10:26 am
by Nick
Yup, they root well... I generally do planted tanks with gravel above and a thin layer of sand down below, so any nutrients that really break down can seep into the sand and nourish the plants, while I can still vacuum large wastes from out of the gravel layer. Then the tubers die, and a month or so later the plant is dead.