Page 1 of 1

Trumpet snails >:[

Posted: Wed Feb 24, 2010 4:11 pm
by zombiefetus
I have an infestation of stupid trumpet snails, unfortunately they came with the tank. There were what seemed like thousands at one point, but now it's down to maybe 200 +/- still pretty annoying. I don't want to kill them all because there's also a nice colony of ramshorn in there I'd like to keep in there. so I've been scooping a bunch of the invaders out with a net everyday and siphoning some out.
I'm planning on getting a trio of Green Spotted Puffers for the tank in the next few weeks, hopefully I can find some to adopt, otherwise I'll have to resort to petstore fish. The tank is 100 gallons, currently houses some FW fish I'm rehoming.

Most of the trumpet snails left are super tiny. Is it worth it to keep trying to get them out, or do you think it'd be safe to let the puffers have their way with them. lol. I've heard of cases of puffers chipping teeth on the hard shells, but is the same true of super tiny snails?
The substrate is sand (pool filter sand) it's not too hard to sift through the sand with a net, but the snails left are fairly tiny and most of them slip through the holes of the net.

Re: Trumpet snails >:[

Posted: Wed Feb 24, 2010 5:18 pm
by Nick
In my experience, huge puffers and mid brackish-salt water puffers, which encounter very tough shelled snails in the wild, can deal with trumpet snails alright. I know F8's and freshwater puffers have been known to chip their teeth on them, and probably small GSPs are at some level of risk as well, but Shakespeare can tear through even larger MTS, and he's about 4". I've never heard an account of any salt water puffer damaging its teeth unless they were severely overgrown(longer teeth mean more force transferred back to the puffer when biting) - and I have only one account of that, a large golden puffer who knocked most of one of his teeth off(on live rock, incidentally, not on a snail).

I suppose their is SOME level of risk, but if the snails really are coarse-sand sized, I would not expect it to be very high.

Re: Trumpet snails >:[

Posted: Wed Feb 24, 2010 7:15 pm
by RTR
It will be a cold day in Manos before I allow any puffer in my care to have any coiled spiral snail. I consider that extremely dangerous practice and it will never be done to any puffer in care, and has not been in past for many years. I think that I can justify my point with experience, as I would be willing to bet that I have more tank-years of puffer care in my experience than anyone else on the this forum.

Caveat emptor. The teeth or perhaps life you save may be your puffer's.

Re: Trumpet snails >:[

Posted: Wed Feb 24, 2010 9:07 pm
by Pufferpunk
Don't the really tiny juvie ones have softer or more brittle shells?