Page 1 of 1
I give up...well, not really
Posted: Sun Feb 21, 2010 12:09 pm
by marksrush
Last night I brought home 3 new blue damsels to put in my Ceylon's tank, which already had two blue damsels and three black and white striped damsels in it. The damsels had all been surviving fine for about 6 months, so I figured the new ones would be safe, too. Well, I woke up this morning, and all three of the newcomers are gone, along with one of the original blue damsels, leaving me with only one blue damsel and three black and white striped ones. I haven't seen any corpses, and my Ceylon has a suspiciously full belly - too full, considering yesterday was an "off" day, feeding-wise, so I guess I can figure out what happened. I came THIS close to putting the Ceylon on craigslist this morning. It's not so much about the money, it's just that I feel bad that those damsels could have had a good life with someone else, but since they were so lucky to go home with me, now they're dead.
I'm getting a new 55 soon, and I've decided that there will be absolutely no puffers going into it. I've had it.
Re: I give up
Posted: Sun Feb 21, 2010 12:17 pm
by J-P
LOL!! But I do feel bad for you too.
The husband of the pub owner across the street from me asked my what kind of fish I wanted to put in my tank. When I mentioned puffers, his reply was "What's with guys and these girly fish? Get a pike or something!"
Puffers "the cute killers"
Re: I give up
Posted: Sun Feb 21, 2010 12:18 pm
by bigfatfish
Sorry for the losses. Not sure you can blame the Puffer though! Think you have just been lucky that the original damsels lasted as long as they did. Clearly a fish for a species only tank - & IMO, why would you want any other fish in with him?! I love puffer only tanks & have never understood why people crave to add tankmates. That said, its a horrible thing to wake up to, but don't beat yourself up about it.
Re: I give up
Posted: Sun Feb 21, 2010 12:23 pm
by marksrush
I don't blame the puffer; I blame myself. I'm not going to beat myself up about it - at least not too much - but I think I've bought my last puffer.
Re: I give up
Posted: Sun Feb 21, 2010 12:34 pm
by Pufferpunk
I don't get it... Isn't the reason you are here is because you love puffers? In my tanks, the puffer is king & if he lets the others live with him that's great but if not, they they are kept as singletons. I think you should devote that 55g just for him, he deserves it!
Re: I give up
Posted: Sun Feb 21, 2010 1:18 pm
by marksrush
Oh I know, you're right PP and everyone else, it's just that I was still upset when I started the thread and had to vent. My dad was Italian/Sicilian, and like him, I tend to go absolutely crazy over something right off the bat - but then five minutes later it's like nothing happened. I can't say that it doesn't bother me anymore, but I am at least back to being somewhat sane.
What I'm hoping to do eventually is get him into a 90 gallon - BY HIMSELF!!! - and then I can make his former tank into either a new reef tank or a community saltwater tank. The 55 gallon I'm getting soon (would have got it today but there's ice all over everything here this morning) will be the new home of my valentini, Lu-Lu. She's been living temporarily in my 20 gallon reef tank, and after she's out of it, I think I'll just have inverts in there from here on out.
Re: I give up
Posted: Sun Feb 21, 2010 1:20 pm
by eieio
marksrush wrote:Oh I know, you're right PP and everyone else, it's just that I was still upset when I started the thread and had to vent. My dad was Italian/Sicilian, and like him, I tend to go absolutely crazy over something right off the bat - but then five minutes later it's like nothing happened. I can't say that it doesn't bother me anymore, but I am at least back to being somewhat sane.
What I'm hoping to do eventually is get him into a 90 gallon - BY HIMSELF!!! - and then I can make his former tank into either a new reef tank or a community saltwater tank. The 55 gallon I'm getting soon (would have got it today but there's ice all over everything here this morning) will be the new home of my valentini, Lu-Lu.
there ya go!

Re: I give up
Posted: Sun Feb 21, 2010 1:41 pm
by bigfatfish
Maybe change the title of this thread, from "I give up" to "I will never give up".
I quite like a man with a fiery temper - shows passion!
