Page 1 of 1
The right filter.
Posted: Sat Feb 06, 2010 12:29 am
by bibbles
So, I keep reading that over filtration is a must with any puffer, but how much over filtration is right? I've got this 45 gallon tank, and it'll house a couple puffers, which every they are, they'll end up 2" or smaller fully grown, and that's it.
Filters I see listed say they are good for up to a certain size, but I'm going to assume that's not accurate when filtering for puffers, but since my puffers are going to have a tank larger than necessary, should I be filtering for tank size or for the waste produced?
I was looking at a power filter, since they are cheaper, and I don't think I would mind the noise, but a canister would probably be OK too. Any advice I could get would be awesome as I've done a good deal of searching and can't find any real concrete answers.
Thanks!

Re: The right filter.
Posted: Sat Feb 06, 2010 2:35 am
by purplecandle
I am not a complete expert on puffers..so someone else can give you better advice about the specific puffers you have.
But, I will say..."going cheap" on a filter system for any fish is never a good idea...but going over expensive is not a good idea either...find a middle ground.
And you might not mind the sound, but your puffers will mind the sound and some of them will mind a blasting current..believe me they are sensitive fish.
What I do is buy a filter system that is for a bigger tank than what I have..I go a level up.
And remember that a filter is only part of a solution
Good Luck!
Re: The right filter.
Posted: Sat Feb 06, 2010 2:54 am
by Pufferpunk
I prefer Aquaclear filters. The largest one would be good for your tank. I believe that is the AC110.
http://www.fosterandsmithaquatics.com/p ... catid=3610
Re: The right filter.
Posted: Sat Feb 06, 2010 10:55 am
by RTR
I tend to buy expensive filters, because they last effectively forever. I've been playing with tanks over 50 years - this is not a fad. I ahve multiple 30-year old filters still going strong.
I size filters (for any fish) by considering the middle of the manufacturer's stated range to be the max, not the midline.
Plus I multi-filter everything. I am compulsive on that. Most folks do not. But I have not in decades had to panic because a filter quit or is acting up - if it is and I do not have a spare (rare), well, the other filter or filters will handle the load.
It all boils down to how much you value the fish and personal choice.
Re: The right filter.
Posted: Sat Feb 06, 2010 1:40 pm
by Dadof4
All manufacturers tend to over rate their filters. I go by gallons per hour not tank size when I buy a filter and I always shoot for around 10x the tank volume for my filtration, no matter the fish in the tank. Keeping a second filter on your tanks is always a great idea. I am but just a poor peasant laborer and can only afford to keep one extra filter running in the house right now just to keep some extra media on hand in case of a crash.
Re: The right filter.
Posted: Sat Feb 06, 2010 4:23 pm
by Myaj
Since manufacturers overrate their filters, I go strictly by GPH (gallons per hour) that the filter is rated for. Of course, once you add in the lift and friction from the media and all that stuff, they don't come anywhere even close to their "rating".
So, I aim for right around, or even somewhat over 10x per hour when considering a power filter.. so if you have a 30 gallon tank, you'd want a filter that has a 300gph rating, 75 gallon tank you want a filter that can do 750 gph (or combination of filters). Cannister filters you can go less, as they are more efficient, for example, I ran a Filstar XP2 on a 33xl tank and had some VERY strong current going on in there, and that's a 300gph filter, but I wanted a strong river like current. It gave me that very well. A 300gph power filter would have not come even close.
So for a 45 gallon tank, you want at least 450gph. As PP said, an AC110 would be about perfect, but keep in mind this is a HUGE honkin filter and you'll need a lot of room between the tank and wall for it. It will stick out about 5" behind the tank.
As far as what type.. I love cannister filters. Why? Because they are QUIET! Some people love that waterfall/trickling noise, it drives me batty.. My personal cannister filter of choice is Filstar. Works great, easy to use. I have a Fluval 300 series and can't stand it. The standard Eheim line will serve you well and last forever, but I don't like the mixed media basket where everything is layered, I'm lazy and prefer the individual media baskets like the Eheim Pro series, Fluvals and Filstars have.
If cost is more important than sound, you can't go wrong with Aqua Clear filters. I also was given a different brand filter that I really do like, it runs a bit quieter than my AC's (no motor hum) and is extremely reliable, but I am not sure what brand it is. However, this one only uses cartridges, and I much prefer the sponge/floss/media layering you can do in an AquaClear.
What shape tank is it too? If its a long tank, sometimes you are better off with two smaller filters, one at each end, or you get dead spots. This way too, you have a backup, if one fails for some reason, at least the fish still are getting oxygen and all the bacteria won't die.
Best advice? Find the model you want and shop around! Often you'll find a sale or free shipping and save $20 or more.
Re: The right filter.
Posted: Sat Feb 06, 2010 11:14 pm
by RTR
Myaj's comments are right on - much of what she says applies to my use as well.
Rated flow is highly unrealistic on HOBs and only slightly better on canisters. Rated flow is the drive unit at zero head (intake and out put at exactly the same level, no head, no lift, and no filter box or media to make turbulence. Relationship to reality? Slim to none.
Efficiency matters more than turnover.
My canister of choice is the Classic Eheim, but in my use, an open and empty canister is all that I want or need. I use bio-only, these days one brand and size of bioball only, no other internal media at all. All I need is an empty tube with decent flow. Mechanical filtration is all done elsewhere. And when the units last forever and require little upkeep, they are cheap. I do replace the tubing about every ten years more or less - when I use the filter on a different set-up . Even their power use is low. Most of my mechanical filtration equipment is younger - 10-20 years old, but I do expect it to last me out. I use the same selection criteria- ease of use, long-term reliability, and they do one job well with little power drain. I have not used disposable media in decades.
But I also have had a lot of experience in working with a lot of different filtration techniques. I only fairly recently gave up most of that. I like what I have and use, it is "right" for my tank-keeping style if you will. It will take some trial and error for you to find out what "fits" you personally.
I strongly agree with Myaj on silence. I am not that picky in the tank room, there is so much water moving around everywhere that there is noise. But out in the house,tanks must be seen and not heard, period. I will not have any, repeat any, sound from a tank. We are music people - you must hear music, but not fish tanks.
Re: The right filter.
Posted: Sun Feb 07, 2010 5:06 am
by bibbles
Myaj wrote:Cannister filters you can go less, as they are more efficient, for example, I ran a Filstar XP2 on a 33xl tank and had some VERY strong current going on in there, and that's a 300gph filter, but I wanted a strong river like current. It gave me that very well. A 300gph power filter would have not come even close.
How much less? I like the Eheim filters with built in heaters, thus even less stuff in the tank... but the only one that will do 450+GPH is the Pro III which is like $450 or so... Maybe I'll find one for less, but, ya know...
EDIT: Or are there any other thermofilters you'd recommend?
Re: The right filter.
Posted: Sun Feb 07, 2010 11:32 am
by soggydrysuit
There are so many excellent comments on this thread, is it possible to 'sticky' it?

Re: The right filter.
Posted: Sun Feb 07, 2010 2:23 pm
by Pufferpunk
Too many stickys...