Page 1 of 1

Rocks or sand

Posted: Fri Feb 05, 2010 6:24 pm
by purplecandle
So, this morning I check my levels...Way too high..
After light cleaning, levels still too high.
So, I decide to do a water change-I have good tap water (live in the country) but the water always has a slight color to it so I like to use bottled water.
I drive out, in a snow storm, to get bottled water.
Come home and I do an 80% water change.
Levels are better but still too high..
I take everything out the tank..clean them lightly.
Levels still too high.
I get out my vacuum and start getting into the sand and WOW...nasties all over the place...mostly food debris-turns out my hubby now loves my puffer and likes to feed him before he goes to work in the morning (I want to hit him)..and then I feed them at their normal time(late afternoon)..so, it is no mystery why my levels are high
So, I am am now just taking out the sand ..there is so much debris that after an hour of just vacuuming, I am going to give up and take out the sand.

My question is, should I replace with sand or rock? I have both, but I think cleaning the rock (gravel) is much easier than the sand + I will be better able to see food debris.
But, does using gravel hurt the puffer? I know that gravel encourages bacteria growth, but is it the wrong kind of bacteria?

Re: Rocks or sand

Posted: Fri Feb 05, 2010 6:38 pm
by RTR
It is really personal choice - except that some puffers like to bury themselves - those should be on sand if possible.

To me, gravel is easier to mange/vacuum. In unplanted tanks I full-depth vacuum with every water change. Sand is stirred with every change and then only light just-above-the-surface vacuumed after.

HTH

Re: Rocks or sand

Posted: Fri Feb 05, 2010 6:39 pm
by rocket
Hi Purp, how oftern do you hover the tank?

Re: Rocks or sand

Posted: Fri Feb 05, 2010 6:42 pm
by pufferpuggirl
I'm sorry, but I had to laugh when you said that your husband feeds the puffer and you want to hit him.
I prefer sand in most of my tanks, I've got 19 tanks and only 3 of them have gravel, the rest are sand. I know what you're saying though about food getting trapped. What I do is I take a stake and I stir the sand, which brings up any food that was covered over by the sand. And I vacuum my tanks every morning, to get all the uneaten food and fish waste out of the tank.
It's a personal choice though whether you want sand or gravel.
The bacteria that collects on gravel is the good kind, what I call "beneficial bacteria", so there's nothing bad in having gravel, although it can trap food too. I think it's just a matter of what you like and what's easiest for you. I agree that sand can be a pain at times, but I like it, seems more natural to me.
You have to decide what you like better though as a GSP will never bury itself (at least I've never heard of them doing that), so it's not going to matter much whether there's sand or gravel to the puffer. In fact, one of my tanks that actually is gravel is my GSP tank. :)

Re: Rocks or sand

Posted: Fri Feb 05, 2010 7:01 pm
by purplecandle
rocket wrote:Hi Purp, how oftern do you hover the tank?

I normally only need to vacuum once or week or so-when I do water changes. My puffer eats his food at the same place every day(he likes to eat blood worms that hank from one of my plastic plants)..so normally it is just a matter of using a net to pick up extras or poops.

Re: Rocks or sand

Posted: Fri Feb 05, 2010 7:11 pm
by purplecandle
pufferpuggirl wrote:I'm sorry, but I had to laugh when you said that your husband feeds the puffer and you want to hit him.
I prefer sand in most of my tanks, I've got 19 tanks and only 3 of them have gravel, the rest are sand. I know what you're saying though about food getting trapped. What I do is I take a stake and I stir the sand, which brings up any food that was covered over by the sand. And I vacuum my tanks every morning, to get all the uneaten food and fish waste out of the tank.
It's a personal choice though whether you want sand or gravel.
The bacteria that collects on gravel is the good kind, what I call "beneficial bacteria", so there's nothing bad in having gravel, although it can trap food too. I think it's just a matter of what you like and what's easiest for you. I agree that sand can be a pain at times, but I like it, seems more natural to me.
You have to decide what you like better though as a GSP will never bury itself (at least I've never heard of them doing that), so it's not going to matter much whether there's sand or gravel to the puffer. In fact, one of my tanks that actually is gravel is my GSP tank. :)
I do want to hit him! I can't believe he was feeding them extra and based on how much stuff I found, it looks like he has just slung handfuls of blood worms all over the place-I found a small fortune in blood worms under the sand in the cave. He did not like my puffer at first, then he finds a second baby starving puffer at Wal-Hell and brings it home, and now he is sneaking them food....And I catch him on the internet shopping for cool things for the puffers..bigger tanks and play things..he is trying to steal my babies! He could care less about my tank of gold fish..but now he is under some puffer spell.

I have taken out the sand and the levels are getting better, I think I am going to go with gravel..

Re: Rocks or sand

Posted: Sat Feb 06, 2010 6:51 am
by pufferpuggirl
"And I catch him on the internet shopping for cool things for the puffers .... bigger tanks and play things ... he is trying to steal my babies! ...."

That is just too funny! :lol: My husband likes to pretend that he has nothing to do with my puffer obsession, but then he too will surf the net looking at aquariums and stuff, and I also hear him talking to the puffers. So he may pretend has has nothing to do with them, but I know otherwise.

However, I can certainly understand your frustration with the extra food being given because that means they're being double fed and also the extra mess that you have to clean up.

But at least he's not against the puffers, so that's a plus! :D

Re: Rocks or sand

Posted: Sat Feb 06, 2010 7:26 am
by LilGreenPuffer
I love gravel! It's so easy to clean. I color-coordinate it with the bettas that live in those tanks (black plus a little blue for the blue ones, orange for the orange one). When I vacuum my planted puffer tank, I always have to worry about keeping the siphon juuuust at the right height, where I can suck up debris and not suck up sand. And I have to stir it in a couple of spots, where it's deeper than 1", which is a PAIN because of the slate, driftwood, and plants in the way. Then again, the sand does look great, very natural, and of course it's good for the plants, since it's flourite. Which one you choose really does depend on personal preference and purpose.