Page 1 of 1

Can you sedate a Puffer safely?

Posted: Mon Feb 01, 2010 11:44 am
by studmaster
Hi guys,

I will be changing stands in the near future for my 50 gal tank. The stand I'm moving to is about 8 inches taller, so most of the water and live rock in the tank currently needs to be removed. The problem is that my 5-6" green spotted puffer is very skittish and will smash violently into whatever is left in the tank. I was wondering if there is any way to sedate him safely so that I could either leave him in the tank with a tiny bit of water, or so that I can net him out. Without sedating him, I doubt I would be able to net him out without causing him significant damage.

Thanks in advance!

Re: Can you sedate a Puffer safely?

Posted: Mon Feb 01, 2010 12:05 pm
by Dadof4
Well, you could do it with MS222 but I wouldn't suggest it for how long you would have to do it. What I have done in similar situations is capture him in a clear water pitcher and then move him to a 5 gallon bucket filled with tank water, an air stone, and a heater. I then put a lid on the bucket (in my case a piece of Plexiglas). If he's really skittish you could put a small piece of plywood over the top to make it dark and make him more secure.

Re: Can you sedate a Puffer safely?

Posted: Mon Feb 01, 2010 12:23 pm
by studmaster
Dadof4 wrote:Well, you could do it with MS222 but I wouldn't suggest it for how long you would have to do it. What I have done in similar situations is capture him in a clear water pitcher and then move him to a 5 gallon bucket filled with tank water, an air stone, and a heater. I then put a lid on the bucket (in my case a piece of Plexiglas). If he's really skittish you could put a small piece of plywood over the top to make it dark and make him more secure.
Honestly I don't think I could capture him in a clear container. First problem being trying to get him in the container, then once he realized he was trapped in container, he would start to spaz out and hurt himself. The only other option I could think of is to sedate about 1/10th of the tank with water in it. Then remove half of that water, and move the tank up to the new stand. I guess I would then have a problem removing the medicated water from the tank.

I was wondering if I lowered the temperature of the water enough, would that slow him down.....or would I do damage? I was thinking mid 60's.

Re: Can you sedate a Puffer safely?

Posted: Mon Feb 01, 2010 12:27 pm
by LilGreenPuffer
Temperature swings can be very dangerous. I would just try to net him and take my chances.

Re: Can you sedate a Puffer safely?

Posted: Mon Feb 01, 2010 12:27 pm
by Pufferpunk
That's more stressful than just catching him, IMO.

Re: Can you sedate a Puffer safely?

Posted: Mon Feb 01, 2010 1:11 pm
by studmaster
Pufferpunk wrote:That's more stressful than just catching him, IMO.
I've never had any fish as big as Zephyr, but he really is violent when he spazzes. Trying to net him wouldn't be for the faint of heart.

Re: Can you sedate a Puffer safely?

Posted: Mon Feb 01, 2010 1:12 pm
by studmaster
LilGreenPuffer wrote:Temperature swings can be very dangerous. I would just try to net him and take my chances.
what about a gradual decrease over a few days to like 68 or so?

Re: Can you sedate a Puffer safely?

Posted: Mon Feb 01, 2010 1:18 pm
by Dadof4
The temperature drop that far could kill him. I have caught my spastic and generally neurotic GSP with the pitcher method. It does take two people though. My wife holds the pitcher under water and I heard him in to it with a net. Hank didn't freak out as bad as I thought he would have.

I see what you are trying to accomplish with a low dose MS222 but the prolonged exposure at low dose would anesthetize him deep enough to stop his breathing.

Re: Can you sedate a Puffer safely?

Posted: Mon Feb 01, 2010 1:43 pm
by studmaster
Dadof4 wrote:The temperature drop that far could kill him. I have caught my spastic and generally neurotic GSP with the pitcher method. It does take two people though. My wife holds the pitcher under water and I heard him in to it with a net. Hank didn't freak out as bad as I thought he would have.

I see what you are trying to accomplish with a low dose MS222 but the prolonged exposure at low dose would anesthetize him deep enough to stop his breathing.
From articles I've read, GSP range is 72-80. He's much less aggressive in lower temps.

When Zephyr even sees his reflection, he runs full steam into the live rock or usually into the side of the tank. I don't know how he hasn't killed himself yet. Many cuts, scrapes and eye infections later, he's still swimming away. I've never seen a fish swim that fast, it's like he's shot out of a cannon (literally). He has splashed us on the couch 6-7 feet away. (eggcrate secured top)

If I'm going to need to net him, I'm going to have to come up with a better method. More like some sort of trap.....which he will freak out about as well.

Re: Can you sedate a Puffer safely?

Posted: Mon Feb 01, 2010 5:32 pm
by Dadof4
studmaster wrote:If I'm going to need to net him, I'm going to have to come up with a better method. More like some sort of trap.....which he will freak out about as well.


This is why I herd mine in to a clear container. The pitcher I use is acrylic they can't see it and it makes it easier.

Re: Can you sedate a Puffer safely?

Posted: Tue Feb 02, 2010 8:27 am
by studmaster
Dadof4 wrote:
studmaster wrote:If I'm going to need to net him, I'm going to have to come up with a better method. More like some sort of trap.....which he will freak out about as well.


This is why I herd mine in to a clear container. The pitcher I use is acrylic they can't see it and it makes it easier.

Unless the container is like 5 gallons, Zephyr will freak out and more than likely i won't be able to catch him. I can see how that idea would work for normal fish, but not for spazzy mcspazz a-lot here.