Page 1 of 1
Male vs Female
Posted: Sun Jan 31, 2010 1:48 pm
by bibbles
OK, so as far as I can tell, the majority of puffers have no visual differences between sexes right? Is there any way to go about getting a male and a female, assuming that they are NOT the few that are easy to tell apart?
Re: Male vs Female
Posted: Sun Jan 31, 2010 2:23 pm
by busybones
Which type of puffer? Most you cannot tell which is which without seeing mating behavior,egg laying, or having them dissected. This is to my knowledge. I've never tried to breed any type of puffer, but do have a pair of Loretis. (RTR would be best to answer this question):)
Re: Male vs Female
Posted: Sun Jan 31, 2010 2:52 pm
by Dadof4
Well, you could try putting them in a tank, low lights, a glass of clam juice, nice dinner, a little romantic mood music...if they look awkward, you have two males or two females!
Honestly, it's a dangerous proposition and even out of mating times male and females are risky to keep together. I know Suvatti's do OK together once you find a male/female pair and have been bred multiple times.
Re: Male vs Female
Posted: Sun Jan 31, 2010 3:13 pm
by Myaj
There are only a handful of species that you can visually tell which is male and female. Dwarf puffers, red eye species.
Otherwise, its just a big risk. And even if you do happen get a male and female, its very likely that they may try or succeed in killing each other. Lots of cover, lots of room.. go with much higher than your typical minimum tank sizes per specimen and have an extra tank ready to move one of the "pair" to in case things get out of hand.
But how do you know? Unless you have a female that happens to purge eggs at some point, or you see actual mating behavior, you just don't know.
Re: Male vs Female
Posted: Sun Jan 31, 2010 8:32 pm
by RTR
Unfortunately, I'm no better than anyone else at sexing puffers. The best way that I know is the same as with immature schooling species - numbers. If you buy 6, the odds are that you have at least one male and one female. The problem is, you will need to house them individually - in separate tanks. I'd set two rows of three tanks each, with all tanks having at least one end and side up against another tank with conspecifics. The downside is that you have to re-arrange periodically, so everybody gets to at see and interact with everybody, And you spend a lot of time watching and making lots of notes on behavior. When they are mature (usually within 2-3 years) and you suspect some fish to be likely male or likely female, then you set some significantly larger tanks with grid barriers and add the fish to each side and continue observing when they now have access to taste/smell and pheromones. When you are confident that you have a pair,you carefully pull the grid out and do not leave them alone again without the barrier in place. If they remain compatible, you separate and condition them well until the are flirting avidly, remove the barrier and hope. Total investment: 6 normal tanks with all fittings, plus a couple of largish ones, 6 fish of the same approximate age/size, hundreds of hours of observation, thousands of gallons of water and lots of watts of power. An expensive project in a number of ways. I have not the time, money, or energy.
But do let us know if you do it... )
I don't have the energy. I did get hints which I did not follow up on during the F_8 study some years back from watching fish interact through two panes of glass - very interesting stuff. But those tanks could not be rearranged (different water conditions).
With 3 Fahakas, I knew one was female (she dumped eggs priodically) and suspected the other two were male (one of those being the only fish I have ven kept of which I was physically afraid), After the death of the two males, I did confirm their gender by necropsy. There my guesses were right, but I would not have bet on it.
Only the puffers know for sure.
Re: Male vs Female
Posted: Tue Feb 02, 2010 11:48 pm
by bibbles
Thanks! That's about what I expected, I'm looking for a couple very small puffers anyway, so I'll most likely end up going with Dwarfs or Redeyes anyway, I was mostly just curious.

Re: Male vs Female
Posted: Wed Feb 03, 2010 12:30 am
by busybones
Even though I got my Loretis by mistake, I really do like them. They watch every move I make when I'm in my office, always begging of course.
