Page 1 of 3

Which puffer...

Posted: Sat Jan 30, 2010 11:02 pm
by bibbles
So, always wanted a puffer, etc... and also wanted to do an aquascape with a "tree" like this ( http://www.aquascapingworld.com/gallery ... o_2008.jpg ) and I was wondering, would a puffer be a good choice? I was thinking like, a couple puffers, maybe something that would enjoy cleaning the glass for me.

Given that aquascapes like this are fresh water, that narrows down the puffers to choose from, and I really like bright fish (love the GSP). My only worry is that the scape might be a little too minimalist for fish that like to hide and explore...

I'm undecided on what size tank to get, though I figured I would let the fish define the tank unless I found a really cool one (I like the Fluval EDGE, not a tank I have or am set on getting due to size, just like the design). I very much like the Dwarf Puffer (especially the females as from what I've seen they are brighter) but feel like they are... maybe a little smaller than I want. I've also looked at the Figure 8 and GSP as mentioned... but the later two say brackish water (though I've read they do fine in fresh water a bunch of places so I'm not sure).

Another question I had was though the PufferPedia lists how many gallons a single fish would enjoy, how much more should each additional one get? Is it just double, or half again as much, etc... I've seen a number of things said all over the Internet and really don't know... :/

PS. I like to figure out as much as I can before hand and be thorough about it... sorry about all the questions. :X

Re: Which puffer...

Posted: Sat Jan 30, 2010 11:19 pm
by Pufferpunk
[welcome]
Your best bet for a tank like that would be dwarf puffers. No way would those plants survive in the saltiness GSPs require. The only other puffer that would be really happy in there (& not mess up the garden), would be the South American puffer & it would be difficult to catch them for the regular teeth trimming with not ruining the complicated aquascaping.

Re: Which puffer...

Posted: Sat Jan 30, 2010 11:24 pm
by busybones
Maybe some C. Loretis or C.Irrubescos?

Re: Which puffer...

Posted: Sat Jan 30, 2010 11:41 pm
by bibbles
Pufferpunk wrote:[welcome]
Your best bet for a tank like that would be dwarf puffers. No way would those plants survive in the saltiness GSPs require. The only other puffer that would be really happy in there (& not mess up the garden), would be the South American puffer & it would be difficult to catch them for the regular teeth trimming with not ruining the complicated aquascaping.
That tank was just an example of what I thought was a cool tank, I'd probably get a larger tank...

The reason I was asking about the GSP and Figure 8 was that I keep reading posts around the Internet where people say they did fine in fresh water, others saying they wanted salt water or brackish water, and still others saying they needed different water at different stages... very frustrating... >:(

EDIT: http://www.ehow.com/how_5160233_keep-sp ... water.html Blah...

EDIT: Oh, also, you mentioned teeth trimming - that was mentioned somewhere else, but it was like, either feed them snails or trim their teeth... is it either or both?
busybones wrote:Maybe some C. Loretis or C.Irrubescos?
I liked the later, though on the small side and says it wants a lot of room, and I can't figure out what the former is... :/

Also, the Colomesus asellus is pretty cool.

Re: Which puffer...

Posted: Sun Jan 31, 2010 12:01 am
by Pufferpunk
Colomesus asellus are the SAPs I mentioned, with dental problems. I always forget about those other 2 smaller, FW species, they might work. Do best in pairs & not so sure you could keep a lot of them in 1 tank. GSPs & F8s definitely need BW.

Re: Which puffer...

Posted: Sun Jan 31, 2010 12:23 am
by bazil323
Most puffers can get by with a good diet of crunchy, meaty foods for them to grind down their teeth. However, SAPs will need regular teeth trimming even with a good diet.

GSPs start out in fresh/light brackish water as fry and then gradually move into full saltwater as adults. There are no ifs, ands, or buts about that. However, there is some confusion regarding figure 8 puffers. Most people keep them in light brackish water because they are much healthier and live longer with these conditions because they must have very hard water with a high pH. For this reason, some people have kept figure 8s in very hard freshwater, but it's more feasible for most people to just add some marine salt to the water and use crushed coral or aragonite to raise the hardness.

Re: Which puffer...

Posted: Sun Jan 31, 2010 12:39 am
by bibbles
Pufferpunk wrote:Colomesus asellus are the SAPs I mentioned, with dental problems. I always forget about those other 2 smaller, FW species, they might work. Do best in pairs & not so sure you could keep a lot of them in 1 tank. GSPs & F8s definitely need BW.
I see... hrm... I just wish Dwarf Puffers were a little bigger, the female ones are exactly what I want...

I guess I could do a 15 gallon tank with a few of those though. I just wish the fresh water ones were more colorful, ya know? Perhaps I'll forgo the aquascaping and get GSPs... lots to think about.

Re: Which puffer...

Posted: Sun Jan 31, 2010 12:55 am
by busybones
Here are a couple photos of my C. Loretis they aren't that small about 2-3inches now. I have these two in a 45 gallon tank.

Male
Image
Female
Image

Re: Which puffer...

Posted: Sun Jan 31, 2010 1:33 am
by bibbles
busybones wrote:Here are a couple photos of my C. Loretis they aren't that small about 2-3inches now. I have these two in a 45 gallon tank.

Male
Image
Female
Image
Ooo, those are cute! :D
They aren't in the PufferPedia I don't think though, I might have just missed them though.

Also, it looks like most of the plants I want to use CAN survive in brackish water, I need to look more into that though... How many gallons would two Green Striped Puffers need? Someone mentioned having them in a 37 gallon tank and another person said 55 when I was searching the forums. I read 30 would be fine somewhere as well, but I think they meant for when they were very young or something.

Also, are there any weird quirks with GSPs like needing to clip their teeth or something like that? And how fast do they grow?

Re: Which puffer...

Posted: Sun Jan 31, 2010 1:42 am
by Pufferpunk
If you look really hard, there are some DPs out there with iridescent blue stripes in them.

Re: Which puffer...

Posted: Sun Jan 31, 2010 2:58 am
by LilGreenPuffer
bazil323 wrote:Most puffers can get by with a good diet of crunchy, meaty foods for them to grind down their teeth. However, SAPs will need regular teeth trimming even with a good diet.

GSPs start out in fresh/light brackish water as fry and then gradually move into full saltwater as adults. There are no ifs, ands, or buts about that. However, there is some confusion regarding figure 8 puffers. Most people keep them in light brackish water because they are much healthier and live longer with these conditions because they must have very hard water with a high pH. For this reason, some people have kept figure 8s in very hard freshwater, but it's more feasible for most people to just add some marine salt to the water and use crushed coral or aragonite to raise the hardness.
Actually, RTR did a study and found out that F8s in FW don't live as long and tend to be sicklier, even with a high pH.

Re: Which puffer...

Posted: Sun Jan 31, 2010 7:54 am
by bibbles
busybones wrote:Maybe some C. Loretis or C.Irrubescos?
Where would I go about finding Carinotetraodon irrubesco? I can't seem to find any info, and there aren't many LFS around here, the one I went to just had Dwarf Puffers and um... some other puffer that was $350 or so...

Re: Which puffer...

Posted: Sun Jan 31, 2010 2:17 pm
by busybones
You can call around to your LFS and see if they have any on their stock list. Puffers are odd balls and you may have problems finding what you want. My Loretis were sent to me by mistake but I kept them (they aren't in the Pufferpedia, but comparable to the Irrubesco). You may need to find out what is available to you before you decide what you want.

A GSP will need 30 gallons of water, now that is per fish and will sustain him for life. These are wonderful fish and one of my favorites. They have great personalities. I keep mine in a 55 gallon tank but a 30 would suit him just fine. You can keep them in pairs, but most puffers enjoy being alone.

Re: Which puffer...

Posted: Sun Jan 31, 2010 3:22 pm
by Myaj
Irrubescos and Lortetis are pretty rare. There is a local store here that has some in right now, but I've been watching for them for over 10 years and this is the first I've seen of them!

There are online places to order from, but be sure to check out if they are reputable or not.

When listening to people say they have kept fish like Figure 8 and Green Spotted Puffers in freshwater, ask them how long they've kept them alive. These fish should live 10+ years, and most people that try to keep them in freshwater find they only live a few months. Obviously, that's not good fishkeeping!

Dwarf puffers are very beautiful, just tiny little fish!

Image
Image

Re: Which puffer...

Posted: Sun Jan 31, 2010 3:35 pm
by LilGreenPuffer
+1, Myaj. I love my DPs.

My male does have that blue-green tint to his stripes sometimes, depending on the light. It's very pretty. I really think that they're gorgeous little fish. They're subtle, but lovely.