Page 1 of 1

Sand Question

Posted: Fri Jan 29, 2010 1:50 pm
by dmond31
Hello

I currently have white sand in my Congo puffer and I was wondering how often should I be turning the sand, and should I remove the little guy.

Re: Sand Question

Posted: Fri Jan 29, 2010 2:18 pm
by DarkStorm
theres many different beliefs of air pockets = gas = nitrates / stirring can cause ammonia etc etc
read this to see the outcome of the debate
http://www.fishforums.net/index.php?showtopic=212113

Re: Sand Question

Posted: Fri Jan 29, 2010 3:04 pm
by kilofey
i read that other thread, and it just made me a little more confused... didnt really answer a question because everyone had different opinions lol...... anyway, this is what i do....

i have a whole wall of bubblers, you can buy the really good ones at, of all places, walmart. its a long bar incased in plastic to keep it under the sand, and they can be hooked together to make it as long or as short as you like while using only one air pump. and when i clean the tank once a week, i just move the sand around with my siphon, although, playsand is a little lighter that pool filter sand which is what i have. play sand seems to get sucked up easier.... i would stop it from siphoning and just stir it up with the empty siphon. its just a habit to run the siphon through the sand as i clean, no big deal.... but if you get the bubble wall, and, if you are really paranoid, you could possibly put another bubblewall on the sides of the tank walls too, but i dont. the bubble wall under the sand gets the needed oxygen into the sand so those gasses become harmless.... ive never known anyone that has had it happen, so im guessing its not too common but i do it just as a precaution... or you could get one of those bubble curtains that you can bend, but ive had trouble witht those floating up and they dont put off that many bubbles IME

this is a pic of the airstone i use... see the plastic that holds it down http://1.bp.blogspot.com/_iWx6okUT9kw/S ... _stone.JPG

Re: Sand Question

Posted: Fri Jan 29, 2010 3:04 pm
by LilGreenPuffer
If it's over 1" deep, you should stir it all up once a week. You don't have to take him out. :) If it's less than 1" thick, you shouldn't have to stir it.

Re: Sand Question

Posted: Fri Jan 29, 2010 4:25 pm
by pufferpuggirl
I've got a Congo puffer, adult size, and the sand in his tank is that nice soft white sand, probably 2" deep. I vacuum all my tanks daily, removing any fish waste and uneaten food, so when I do that, I usually poke around in the sand, smoothing it back out for him, so he can bury himself easier next time.

Re: Sand Question

Posted: Fri Jan 29, 2010 8:34 pm
by RTR
Depth is not as important as grain size. The O2 depletion curve is steepest in very fine sand such as sugar sand, then some thing coarser such as play sand, with pool filter sand (barely below gravel size} being the least depleted with depth.

O2 depletion is not a total disaster - it is just a different chemistry and a highly mixed blessing. Planted tank folk with deep substrates (4" and over) commonly have denitrification at depth (nitrate is reduced to N2 gas and bubbles out). The potentially toxic intermediates (nitrite and ammonia) never make it to the surface - they get oxidized back to nitrate by other bacteria if they do move upward. But if the substrate if fine and relatively shallow, any distrurbance of long-untouched substrate can release toxic materials into the water column. So, if you use fine substrates, do not keep diggers unless- like PP - you keep the substrate stirred. The very low O2 tension or relatively anoxic bugs are slow growers, they cannot establish when you operate as PP does - she has a digger, but needs the soft/fine substrate for that digger, so she tends it carefully.

BTW, the bit of vacuuming out waste dailyis a boon also. I confess I am not as conscientious, but with the big puffers I had to be yo keep the tank in control. It really helps with the keeping the dissolved nitrate levels down. Daily rinsing of pre-filters does the same, but I do not do that in FW.

Re: Sand Question

Posted: Fri Jan 29, 2010 9:53 pm
by Flutter
How often would you stir the sand if it's 3" deep but a mixture of pool filter sand, laterite, gravel (normal size), and Fluorish gravel (medium size)? I'm guessing none where the plants are but what about where they aren't? We've got an open area at the front and under a large decoration too.

Re: Sand Question

Posted: Fri Jan 29, 2010 11:33 pm
by RTR
You are correct - plant roots do not like disturbance, that stays undisturbed. Unplanted areas full-depth vacuumed or stirred at least weekly.

Re: Sand Question

Posted: Sat Jan 30, 2010 2:00 pm
by omplmpa3
I have various types of sand in all five of my tanks. After I vacuum up any debris from the sand's surface I use a wooden dowel that's about 1/3 of an inch in diameter to stir the sand. If needed, I do a second light vacuuming to remove any debris that may have been buried. I've actually found the wooden dowel to be one of the best and cheapest tools for the aquarium. From stirring and smoothing out sand, to pushing any exposed roots back into the sand, even for feeding, I use wooden dowels for it all.

Re: Sand Question

Posted: Sat Jan 30, 2010 2:02 pm
by Pufferpunk
I sometimes use a chopstick for stirring but mostly, just my hand.

Re: Sand Question

Posted: Sat Jan 30, 2010 2:55 pm
by RTR
I have been a chopstick user for ages - multipurpose tools. I have also used plastic or glass rods,