Page 1 of 2

Do I have to cycle?

Posted: Tue Jan 26, 2010 1:36 am
by purplecandle
Hey it is me again!

Got all the brackish products needed for my puffer...found a mom and pop pet store who had an expert...told me how much of this and how much of that....

Now here is my question, I forgot to ask the pet store guy.

Remember I said I had upgraded my 10 gallon tank to a 20 gallon tank..put my fish in the 20 gallon tank...ask husband to buy two more fish to add to the new empty looking tank..he brings home a puffer (GSP)..put puffer in new tank..then found you guys...ok

Now, I wonder if I have to do the cycling thing. For now I want to put him in my 10 gallon tank (I promise I will get a bigger tank!)

My 10 gallon tank has been running for years...I have cleaned and did water changes regularly. I did have goldfish (4+ algae eater) in it, but for the past several days no fish have been in it and the current filter is two weeks old (max lifetime of about 6 weeks)..Last water change was 50% a week ago

Today I have changed gravel to sand-left a little bit of gravel, added some shells and it does have lots of rocks. I have also added appropriate marine salt (very low at this point) and ph stuff-he is a little guy..and I plan to use a drip method to acclimate him.

Now cycling is about bacteria, since my 10 gallon tank is already established do I have to deal with the cycling stuff?
Also what is the right temp for a GPS?

Re: Do I have to cycle?

Posted: Tue Jan 26, 2010 1:43 am
by busybones
GSPs fair best in temperates between 73-80F...You will need to be cautious while switching over your FW tank to BW. Please read over this post written by Dadof4 (viewtopic.php?f=5&t=19348)

Also what are your water parameters?

Re: Do I have to cycle?

Posted: Tue Jan 26, 2010 1:45 am
by LilGreenPuffer
If there have been no fish in it for too long, say, over 24h, then the bacteria probably died.

Re: Do I have to cycle?

Posted: Tue Jan 26, 2010 1:52 am
by purplecandle
I do not know the parameters..I will have it tested in the morning

24 hours? What about the bacteria in my filter?

Re: Do I have to cycle?

Posted: Tue Jan 26, 2010 1:56 am
by LilGreenPuffer
The fish provide the ammonia, the food, and the bacteria starves pretty fast without it.

Re: Do I have to cycle?

Posted: Tue Jan 26, 2010 1:59 am
by purplecandle
Good article busybones...yeah I am just doing a little bit at a time...

I found a gem of a pet store just down the road that will help me with testing for free. I have to order that refracto (whatever it is) and the test kits I found at the big meanie pet stores were over priced and I am sure included stuff I did not need.

Re: Do I have to cycle?

Posted: Tue Jan 26, 2010 2:01 am
by purplecandle
That is another question!! Ammonia

I have not done this!!! But, someone told me that some people have tried uping ammonia with urine..that can't be true?

Re: Do I have to cycle?

Posted: Tue Jan 26, 2010 2:04 am
by LilGreenPuffer
Weeeeell, it does have ammonia... But you really shouldn't...

Re: Do I have to cycle?

Posted: Tue Jan 26, 2010 2:39 am
by Dadof4
Urine is a biological waste and will break down to ammonia but because of all the other concentrated waste I wouldn't recommend it.

If you can get some used filter media from a healthy FW tank, add it and then the fish. Slowly raise the SG once you make sure you are cycled as FW. It's easier that way.

Re: Do I have to cycle?

Posted: Tue Jan 26, 2010 3:10 am
by purplecandle
No, I would not do that, I just figured it was an old wives tale or something.

Re: Do I have to cycle?

Posted: Tue Jan 26, 2010 3:18 am
by Pufferpunk
Have you read the 2 cycling articles in our library? One explains how to cycle with ammonia.

Re: Do I have to cycle?

Posted: Tue Jan 26, 2010 3:28 am
by purplecandle
Oh yes, I have read everything..and I am reading them over and over again..I am not sure that I have found one that specifically talks about using household ammonia...I will go look..

But, I have been reading...That is why I was asking the question..if I already have an established tank that I am turning into brackish (very slowly)-my puffer is still really little-..do I need to go through so much of the cycling or for so long...I did not know that the bacteria in my tank could die so quickly...

well, I have put some small snails in there (smaller than a pea)..wonder if that counts..I bought them for the little guy to eat later on

Re: Do I have to cycle?

Posted: Tue Jan 26, 2010 3:53 am
by Pufferpunk
That would be the Fishless Cycling article.

Re: Do I have to cycle?

Posted: Tue Jan 26, 2010 10:04 am
by RTR
The statement that your nitrification bacteria will die in a day is simply incorrect. No long-term biological system for home use could be so fragile and survive. You, you fish, your other pets, etc. will not die due a one-day fast. Nor will the nitrification bacteria. The bugs in question have no dormant form, so must have energy food (ammonia or nitrite) regularly and routinely - but they will not starve in a day. Many of us maintain biofilters for extended periods without fish by feeding the bugs. If I feed ammonia one day, then fish food two days later, and continue alternating the two different feedings 48 hours apart, the biofilter can be maintained at normal levels of colony size indefinitely. Normal tank upkeep of course continues during that time.

Human (and most land animal) urine contains urea, which in water hydrolyzes to ammonia. We must concentrate the ammonia for safer and easier holding prior to release to the outside world, so we convert the ammonia we generate to urea. When released into more water, it reverts to ammonia. But as said before, it is a waste product, and is accompanied by lots of other waste materials. You really do not want a septic tank, you want a biofilter. So don;t use human (or animal) urine. ;)

Snails can be used to cycle a tank, but it takes a lot of them. Our common feeder snails (ramshorn snails and common pond snails) are not particularly sensitive to ammonia and nitrite, so are not harmed by cycling. But you must equal or better exceed the biomass of the fish (whose visible volume is all biomass) to be housed in the tank with snail biomass. The snail's active biomass is very roughly abut one-half of its visible volume So you can see it would need a lot of snails, and then most must be removed before the fish is added. Make sense?

HTH

Re: Do I have to cycle?

Posted: Tue Jan 26, 2010 12:41 pm
by purplecandle
RTR wrote:The statement that your nitrification bacteria will die in a day is simply incorrect. No long-term biological system for home use could be so fragile and survive. You, you fish, your other pets, etc. will not die due a one-day fast. Nor will the nitrification bacteria. The bugs in question have no dormant form, so must have energy food (ammonia or nitrite) regularly and routinely - but they will not starve in a day. Many of us maintain biofilters for extended periods without fish by feeding the bugs. If I feed ammonia one day, then fish food two days later, and continue alternating the two different feedings 48 hours apart, the biofilter can be maintained at normal levels of colony size indefinitely. Normal tank upkeep of course continues during that time.

Human (and most land animal) urine contains urea, which in water hydrolyzes to ammonia. We must concentrate the ammonia for safer and easier holding prior to release to the outside world, so we convert the ammonia we generate to urea. When released into more water, it reverts to ammonia. But as said before, it is a waste product, and is accompanied by lots of other waste materials. You really do not want a septic tank, you want a biofilter. So don;t use human (or animal) urine. ;)

Snails can be used to cycle a tank, but it takes a lot of them. Our common feeder snails (ramshorn snails and common pond snails) are not particularly sensitive to ammonia and nitrite, so are not harmed by cycling. But you must equal or better exceed the biomass of the fish (whose visible volume is all biomass) to be housed in the tank with snail biomass. The snail's active biomass is very roughly abut one-half of its visible volume So you can see it would need a lot of snails, and then most must be removed before the fish is added. Make sense?

HTH
Yeah..I was thinking the same thing about the bacteria...24 hours seems to fast. I mean it takes a lot to kill bacteria..some bacteria can live in some of the craziest places.

I will not use urine!!! I was just asking. I thought it was an old wives tale...