Page 1 of 1

Sad news!

Posted: Sun Jan 24, 2010 1:34 pm
by sb62nova
I have a fairly new 135g tank with 50lbs live rock and 60 lbs base. The tank cycled for about 3 weeks and was testing really well.
ammonia 0
nitrite 0
nitrate 0.5
ph 8.4
sg- 1.022

Went to the lfs and he tested the water as well. Bought my first porcupine puffer. Acclimated him to the tank slowly over about an 1 1/2 hrs. Offered some frozen krill (which is what he had been getting) and left him be for the night. The next morning I woke to find him dead under a rock less than 12 hrs after getting him. Took him back to lfs where he said he probably was just stressed and it was nothing we did. Had him retest our water. The water tested great. He felt it was just bad luck and sent us with another young porc.
We came home with the second one... and causiously acclimated him. We left him be for 24 hrs (didnt turn the lights on or offer him food, just let him get adjusted. after 24 hrs he seemed very happy, was swimming all around, even when we were by the tank. Offered him some krill and octo... and again left him for the night. Woke this am to find him dead too! I feel so bad! Does any body have any ideas what might be wrong or what I should do? Gonna go back to the lfs.... but definately gonna wait. Dont want to see this happen again!!!!!

Re: Sad news!

Posted: Sun Jan 24, 2010 1:44 pm
by marksrush
Welcome to the forum - sorry it had to be for such a sad occasion.

You should post this to Hospital, even though it's too late for the porcs. Or maybe PP will catch it and move it.

Re: Sad news!

Posted: Sun Jan 24, 2010 1:45 pm
by Pufferpunk
[welcome]
So sorry for those losses! :( Where did this rock come from? Any chance there could have ever been copper used previously with either the rock or tank?

Re: Sad news!

Posted: Sun Jan 24, 2010 1:53 pm
by sb62nova
Bought the rock from lfs. The tank was bought used. The previous owner used it as a reef tank. Dont think it could have copper, but i guess I'm not for sure. btw... I have a coco worm in there that is doing great. Both these fish were together at lfs, could that mean anything? Could it be related to the krill at all? Thanks!

Re: Sad news!

Posted: Sun Jan 24, 2010 1:56 pm
by sb62nova
and by together... I mean the same shipment... and water supply. not in the same tank. =)

Re: Sad news!

Posted: Sun Jan 24, 2010 2:07 pm
by marksrush
Well, fwiw, when we get porcs at the store where I work, maybe half of them live long enough to get homed. Nine times out of ten they ich out really bad right off the bat, and often they refuse any and all foods. I don't know if these guys are super-sensitive to stress, or if they were collected in a harmful way, or what, but I hate to see them come in because it just usually doesn't turn out well. Once I start doing the ordering, we won't be getting any more.

Re: Sad news!

Posted: Sun Jan 24, 2010 2:21 pm
by sb62nova
Thanks. Maybe thats why the lfs didnt seem surprised. He insisted on trying the second, I should have went with my gut feeling. We are in there all the time... and I know he only had them for a day or two before we bought them. I should have waited until he knew they were eating etc.... Was just excited to buy one.

Re: Sad news!

Posted: Sun Jan 24, 2010 3:08 pm
by Pufferpunk
Did they have a round or concave belly?

Re: Sad news!

Posted: Sun Jan 24, 2010 9:53 pm
by Mrs.Puff
Oh gosh!!! That's HORRIBLE! I'm sooooo sorry sb62nova.

Re: Sad news!

Posted: Mon Jan 25, 2010 3:01 am
by Dadof4
Also, how old was the LR and is it possible there were any unwanted hitchikers?

Re: Sad news!

Posted: Mon Jan 25, 2010 4:00 pm
by sb62nova
Their bellies were concaved, definately not round. The live rock was in the tank for about 3 weeks and had recently finished cycling. As for unwanted hitchikers... we had a couple. At any rate... took the second one back to the lfs and he suggested doing a different fish. Seeing that the porc puffers didnt do so well... I wasnt about to have that happen again. The good news is that my firefish seems to be doing very well. Gonna wait a while and see how things go. Hopefully in a few weeks I can be back on my puffer venture. Seeing that one of the main fish I wanted for this tank was a puffer... I cant wait to get one! For now, just gonna lay low and see how things go. Any suggestions??? I was thinking of a toby. Possibly crowned or papuan.