Page 1 of 3
Over-Feeding My Puffers
Posted: Sat Jan 23, 2010 9:09 pm
by pufferpuggirl
Thank you PufferPunk for bringing this to my attention. After you made a comment in regards to over-feeding my puffers, I thought long and hard about it. I love my puffers very much, but I've finally admitted to myself that I'm probably killing them with kindness, in other words, I'm feeding them too much. I've just been reading about the effects of doing so, and I don't want to shorten their lifespan. I obviously want them to be very healthy, and I am someone that believes in the truth, and the truth is that I am feeding my puffers too much, which is not good for them.
Okay, so I want to change things.
My first question is, I am mainly feeding earthworms to my puffers (they've really fallen in love with them, and although I try to offer different foods, they just seem to want the earthworms). I know this may seem like a silly question, but how many worms should I aim to feed each puffer, is there a basic amount that would be suitable? Right now my Abei can eat about 4 or 5 worms, but he's not as big as my Baileyi, and I guess I'm feeding the Baileyi about 6-8 worms. And yes, I do feed daily. Once I get a better idea of how many worms to offer my puffers, I intend to skip a feeding one day a week, or should I skip more than one day a week? I don't want my puffers to become fat lazy blobs that don't do anything but beg for food. I also don't want to be cruel, but as I said, right now I think I'm probably being cruel in the kindest way. That's a hard thing to admit, but as I said, I believe in being honest. I mean, I could tell all of you anything at all and you would not know the difference, but truth is, my puffers lives are at stake, so I need to be honest about what's going on so I can do the best for them.
So, how to proceed, how much to feed, how many days to skip??!! .... And any other suggestions and/or advice is very much appreciated.

Re: Over-Feeding My Puffers
Posted: Sun Jan 24, 2010 1:24 am
by Pufferpunk
Lurkers/ambush predators should be fed every 3 days. Active hunters can be fed daily with 1day skipped/week. Large species puffers, every 4-5 days. Feed only to a slightly-rounded belly, not gorged. I do not feel earthworms are a totally natural diet for crustacean-eating fish. I'd only feed them 1x/week. It must be supplemented by a varried shelled diet, soaked in vitamins.
Re: Over-Feeding My Puffers
Posted: Sun Jan 24, 2010 8:30 am
by pufferpuggirl
Okay, that gives me somewhere to start, but I must say my Baileyi, Palembang and suvattii will not eat anything else but the earthworms, what do I do?
And really, even my Mbu is partial to the earthworms, although I can sometimes get him to eat shrimp. Thing is, the two foods that my puffers seem to eat, other than the earthworms, are shrimp and mussels, the two foods that are high in thiaminase. I've tried cockles and krill, but no one liked it. One BIG problem for me is that there's not much variety to be had in my area (I've posted about this in the past, and that's why I seem to always have a problem with feeding my puffers). None of the LFS's near me carry any crustaceans, other than some highly priced crayfish once in a while. I don't have a great deal of luck with feeding raw shrimp with the shell on, as it mostly sits in the tank, fouling the water and not being eaten. And now that I've found something they really like, you're saying they shouldn't have it very often, which is a shame because I thought I'd found something good for them and something easily available.
Alright, well another couple of questions .... I've got two young puffers, one suvattii, and one Fahaka .... I shouldn't skip any meals with them, should I? I thought they would need to be fed regularly until they grow a bit. The Fahaka is only just less than 2 inches long. The suvattii is a bit bigger.
Also, the Palembang that I have came to me VERY thin, so I'm just starting to see him getting a bit more rounded, so should I skip any meals with him? Same with my big Congo, Orangey. He wasn't eating for soooo long, and now he's taking the earthworms, but he's still looking as if he could gain some weight, he just doesn't look as nice as my other Congo, Biscuit. So I'm concerned about skipping any meals for him as well.
I'm just afraid that if I stop feeding the ones that were sick and/or very thin, they will decline. And we all know I don't want to lose any more puffers, as everyone seems to be doing rather well right now.
QUESTION FOR ALL FORUM MEMBERS
Posted: Sun Jan 24, 2010 8:59 am
by pufferpuggirl
I would appreciate everyone's input here please.
Can you all tell me what you are feeding your puffers?
How much do you feed at each meal?
How often do you feed your puffers?
Please tell me which puffers your answers pertain to, so I have an idea of what that particular puffer is getting to eat and how often.
I'm re-assessing my feeding routine, and I would very much appreciate everyone's input so I can look at all the answers and hopefully come up with something that works for me and my puffers.
Thanks everyone!

Re: QUESTION FOR ALL FORUM MEMBERS
Posted: Sun Jan 24, 2010 9:44 am
by MrHumphries
For my DPs I feed them blood worms once a day, and some snails every 3 days or so, maybe 8-10 at a time.
For Samson, This is a hard one as I have only had him for a couple days, but I have been feeding him a little bit here are there, till he's more settled, in the two days hes been here I have fed him two small amounts of blood worms, and snails, he loves hunting for them, so I place them thoughout his tank

keeps the boredom down
Don
Re: QUESTION FOR ALL FORUM MEMBERS
Posted: Sun Jan 24, 2010 10:24 am
by RTR
Too broad a question for many folks - including you I would think.. The library article covers the topic well.
Re: QUESTION FOR ALL FORUM MEMBERS
Posted: Sun Jan 24, 2010 10:33 am
by bigfatfish
As you know PPG, I have 2 GSPs. Still little at the moment (1.5") They eat anything I offer! I give frozen stuff - krill, blood worms, mussel, cockles, squid, brine shrimp, artemia, snails. Live stuff - snails, earthworms, blood worms, brine shrimp, ghost shrimp (when they're not making friends with them!). I don't have a "set" amount to feed, just stop when their tummies are gently rounded & ignore the begging. I don't necessarily have a day off from feeding every week, just sometimes if I work late I won't feed them - thats when I notice that a ghost shrimp has disappeared!
As RTR says, a very broad question!
Re: Over-Feeding My Puffers
Posted: Sun Jan 24, 2010 10:45 am
by RTR
Fish get spoiled every bit as easily as any other pet or domestic animal - or fort hat matter, as people do themselves. I dearly love both chocolate and peanut butter, but I do know that they are not good major dietary components. Believe it or not, it is very esy to seriously and harmfully over-feed pets of all sorts. It is also difficult to starve a captive fish. This is especially true with inappropriate foods. We develop favorites ourselves, we can hardly blame our fish for doing the same.
The guidelines PP gave are excellent, but as a general rule, most puffers need at least some "crunch" regularly and routinely. It reflects the natural diet for most of them. Plus, if that crunch is crustacean or mollusk based, it can give them at leasta semblance of natural hunting behavior. To me, SAPs needs are the highest in this aspect, DPs' needs the lowest.
One other consideration is that some dietary variation is generally helpful. What one food has in excess or lacks, another food may supply or compensate by its different profile. I love good portehouse steaks or filets, but they are in practice special treats, not my daily diet.
Earthworms can be quite nutritious and great for conditioning many fish for breeding, but we breed few puffers, That food can be a big help if we get an undernourished puffer into our care also, but it should never be a dietary staple routinely. I can think of few foods less well-suited for routine feeding to puffers -too rich for every day, and much too soft.
HTH
Re: QUESTION FOR ALL FORUM MEMBERS
Posted: Sun Jan 24, 2010 12:21 pm
by pufferpuggirl
Yes perhaps it is a broad question, but I don't want to read an article written by one person, I want to get an idea of what many people are feeding their puffers. I'm just very curious and appreciate any one that bothers to answer my questions.
Thank you all in advance.

Re: QUESTION FOR ALL FORUM MEMBERS
Posted: Sun Jan 24, 2010 12:25 pm
by marksrush
RTR wrote:Too broad a question for many folks - including you I would think.. The library article covers the topic well.
Wow, what a friendly response! You might as well have just said "rtfm". Maybe it would have been better if you had simply not responded. Way to set a good example, Mentor.
*********
Pufferpuggirl, I feed my 6" Ceylon every other day or every 3 days, with a single moderately sized ramshorn snail on the "off" days just so he (and I) don't go nuts from his begging. He either gets a small whole black mussel, or a couple of nice chunks of clam, shrimp, or something similar. Once in a while he gets a live crayfish, and once a week or so I drop in a clip with a little seaweed square.
My 4" GSP gets about the same as my Ceylon, except smaller portions, and often she gets only what the damsels in her tank get: bloodworms, mysis shrimp, Prime Reef, etc. She gets a little something every day, but only hefty, substantial meals every other day. She is an avid algae eater.
My DPs eat the baby snails they find in their tank, along with a bloodworm or two once a day...I don't really feed them directly. I hate to admit it but I'm pretty sure they get a tiny little bit of tetra fin here and there as well.
My modestus gets pond snails a few times per week, and he daily picks off the tiny baby MT snails produced by the adults living in his tank's substrate (sand); he had been eating flake food in the morning, because I was keeping other fish in his tank and of course they needed to be fed, but he's alone now so he daily gets either snails, bloodworms, mysis shrimp, and the occasional bit of whatever else I'm feeding my other puffers.
My valentini gets either mysis, bloodworms, or Prime Reef every day, and sometimes a little clam or oyster strip, or a few tiny pond snails. She used to get a few copepods from time to time, but I think she's pretty much cleaned those out, and she still gets a red-legged hermit leg segment once in a while if the hermits aren't quick enough.
Re: QUESTION FOR ALL FORUM MEMBERS
Posted: Sun Jan 24, 2010 12:26 pm
by Lil' Swimz$
I feed Peaches bloodworms every day and then skip 2 days a week, usually Tuesday and Thursday. I also give her small snails and some freshwater limpets during the weekend.
Re: Over-Feeding My Puffers
Posted: Sun Jan 24, 2010 12:38 pm
by pufferpuggirl
Thank you RTR, I do understand what you are saying, and it does make sense -- however, can you please try to give me some suggestions for how I should wean these puffers that are only taking earthworms, and get them to take other foods.
As I stated in my posting, the variety in this area sucks to be blunt. I can get shrimp, mussels, cockles, cockle-meat, krill, bloodworm, brineshrimp, maybe a few others, but finding any live crustaceans is just about non-existent. Shrimp and mussels seem to be what is most commonly taken by most of my puffers, with the exception of those 3 that only want earthworms. I have had no real luck getting my puffers to eat much else in the way of variety. I did get some of them to eat some crickets, but not all of them.
Should I just stop feeding altogether, and wait until everyone is seriously hungry? I do want to do what is best, but I'm just trying to figure how to get my puffers to accept other foods, what little bit of variety I can get that is.
All the things I read sound good in theory, it's actually getting the puffers to take the other foods. It seems like I take one step forward and two steps back lately.
Oh, by the way, I do actually feed snails to my puffers on a regular basis, so I've got that much in order anyway.

Re: QUESTION FOR ALL FORUM MEMBERS
Posted: Sun Jan 24, 2010 12:40 pm
by Pufferpunk
marksrush wrote:Wow, what a friendly response! You might as well have just said "rtfm". Maybe it would have been better if you had simply not responded. Way to set a good example, Mentor.
LOL, RTR is a self-proclaimed "Grumpy old man"! We can expect comments occasionally like that sometimes.

The other responses he gives are usually thorough & very helpful.

He also gave a longer response in her similar thread, which sounds like a double post & I will be combining the 2 for lack of confusion. The library articles
are gone over by the entire staff for approval, so it is definitely not the opinion of one person.
Re: QUESTION FOR ALL FORUM MEMBERS
Posted: Sun Jan 24, 2010 12:45 pm
by marksrush
PP you're right, maybe it's just me being a "grumpy old man" this morning.

Re: Over-Feeding My Puffers
Posted: Sun Jan 24, 2010 12:46 pm
by Pufferpunk
Were they eating anything before the earthworms? I believe your miurus wasn't but he may have been in starvation mode when you got him. Earthworms have that wonderful seductive squirm that will attract any fish that was wild-caught, used to eating live foods. We have an article in the Library (again...) on how to feed difficult to feed fish & also ones who are used to live foods. Have you tries soaking other foods in garlic?