Page 1 of 2
Ill Figure 8 Puffer
Posted: Wed Jan 20, 2010 9:42 am
by Jacob
Hello all,
I have a sick Figure 8 puffer and I'm hoping that someone here can help.
A couple of weeks ago, the fish started looking a little thin, and has been slowly getting thinner ever since. I suspected worms, and I recently added some Waterlife Sterazin to treat it. I know that this isn't the medication usually recommended, but I couldn't get hold of the usual recommendations. I was doing half-doses, according to the instructions for sensitive species, but after three doses I aborted the treatment because the fish did not seem to be responding well.
Currently, he is very lethargic, and whilst he will swim around (and does eat), he is not his usual energetic self. This morning, he was resting on the floor, barely moving. Once the lights turned on, he started swimming around, but I've never seen him resting like that before, even with the lights off.
1) Your water parameters - pH, Ammonia, Nitrite, Nitrates and salinity (if appropriate).
pH: 8.2
Ammonia: 0
Nitrite: 0
Nitrate: 40ppm (as it comes from the tap)
Salinity (s.g.): 1.004
2) Tank size and a list of ALL inhabitants.
The tank holds 15 imperial gallons, and the puffer is the only inhabitant.
3) Feeding, water change schedule and a list of all products you are using or have added to the tank
I feed one snail, about the size of his eye, each day. I used to miss out a day or so each week, but since he's been looking thin I haven't done so. The snails are either pond snails or ramshorn snails, depending on what I see first, and the snails are fed on bits of vegetable. Most recently, they've been eating carrot, which I hadn't fed them before and didn't think they'd eat. Occasionally I give him mosquito larvae, which I thaw separately before feeding.
He gets a 25-30% water change weekly, though yesterday morning he had an emergency 25-30% change before work and another 50-60% change (with a thorough clean) in the evening.
I have recently added Sterazin, but it didn't appear to do him any good so I stopped treatment. After performing large water changes, most of the medication should be gone.
4) What changes you've made in the tank in the last week or so.
Only the Sterazin, but the real problem started before I added that.
5) How long the aquarium has been set up, and how did you cycle it?
The aquarium has been set up for several months. It was properly set up (using a fishless method), and the fish has never been exposed to high ammonia or nitrite levels to my knowledge. I've never noticed any behaviour that I would consider worrying until recently.
Any ideas?
Jacob
Re: Ill Figure 8 Puffer
Posted: Wed Jan 20, 2010 10:26 am
by bigfatfish
Hi Jacob. Sorry your puffer is not well. How long have you had him? The nitrates are pretty high for a puffer to tolerate for long periods of time - you may have to do something to get them lowered. I think most people would advise a standard weekly water change of 50%, but I would think this should increase to remove the sterazin (do you have carbon in your filter). I am not familiar with sterazin, but there are very few products that can be used safely with puffers - even those that say a lower dose for 'sensitive' fish. If you spoke to or e-mailed the company I would imagine they would say that they cannot guarantee that it wouldn't harm a puffer. A product commonly used is Jungle Fizz Tabs - but I haven't been able to find them over here - most people get them online, but I wonder if there might be someone on the forum in the UK, that could let you have some? Don't assume though, that it must be parasites. Get that water in tip top condition whilst you are waiting for the parasite control & go from there. All puffers spend time 'snoozing' at the bottom of the tank, this is normal, especially if he is soon swimming about again when you turn the lights on.
Re: Ill Figure 8 Puffer
Posted: Wed Jan 20, 2010 12:58 pm
by Myaj
Hmm, well that's a tough one. As was said, 40 nitrates is pretty high for a puffer, they often do best if they are 20 or lower, but if that's how it comes out of your tap you're in a tough spot. I would probably try to do a few water changes using store bought water. RO if you can find it, but you'll want to buffer it with a product such as RO Right, I'm not sure that little bit of marine salt will buffer it enough, but it might.
I know its a pain in the rear buying the water and lugging it home, but it might help you at least get the nitrates down and see if that helps. If it does, then you know that's a big part of the problem and can figure out what to do at that point.
The other thing is it very well might be internal parasites. I'm not familiar with what you guys can get over in the UK, but in general, if you can get the fish to eat food treated with the dewormer, you'll have faster, better results. I wouldn't do that though until you can get medication that we consider safer for puffers.
If he does have IP's, often as long as the fish is healthy they do okay and you never know it, but once their immune system starts to drop (which the 40 nitrates could contribute to), that's when the parasites go into overdrive and the fish can't fight them off anymore.
Re: Ill Figure 8 Puffer
Posted: Wed Jan 20, 2010 12:59 pm
by Pufferpunk
I don't think 1 snail/day is nearly enough food. Try some of the varied diets offered in our Library under : Feeding. Also, you'll need to soak his foods in the med, to treat internal parasites. I'd do a large water change & add fresh carbon to the filter to take the meds out of the water & only use them internally. It may be harming your fish. What are the ingredients?
Re: Ill Figure 8 Puffer
Posted: Wed Jan 20, 2010 2:18 pm
by Jacob
Thanks all for the advice!
Yep, 40 nitrates is high. Unfortunately, I can't get to a shop until at least the weekend to get RO water. I may order some nitrate-removing treatment or filter media; I will get that before I can get to a shop, but it'll be a day or two. I had previously steered clear of such products, as they tend also to remove nitrites. Whilst that sounds like a good thing, it will probably weaken the bacteria in the filter.
Pufferpunk wrote:I don't think 1 snail/day is nearly enough food.
Do you mean in terms of variation or quantity? For a while he got overfed a bit because the snails were too big, but he has grown and the snail colony has taken off, so for some time his meal sizes have been more consistent. I admit that it doesn't seem like much food, but pretty much every site out there warns against overfeeding, and until recently I saw no adverse effects.
bigfatfish wrote:do you have carbon in your filter
I did, but removed it for the medication. Unfortunately, I have run out of new pads and it'll be a day or two before I can get more.
Pufferpunk wrote:What are the ingredients?
You don't even want to know!
Malachite Green 0.08%
Piperazine Citrate 0.34%
Formaldehyde 0.2%
Acriflavine Hydrochloride 0.055%
Pretty nasty stuff. The dosage is about 4ml for my tank on days 1,3,6,8 & 10, but I used half of that and only for the first three doses.
The label warns about usage with a variety of species, but puffers are not among them. I didn't contact the manufacturer to ask for more details.
----
He seems worse now I'm back home, but is still moving around a little (in between sitting on the bottom). I will do another water change and order the pads & nitrate stuff, and see what happens.
Re: Ill Figure 8 Puffer
Posted: Wed Jan 20, 2010 2:23 pm
by LilGreenPuffer
Those are extremely risky for puffers, and they are used for external parasites. I don't think they're used to treat internally at all. I'd do another water change, 90% or more. Also, remove whatever carbon is left. It fills up with chemicals in just a few days, and then after that it'll leech stuff back into the water. If it took in any meds, it'll be spitting them back out into your water.
Re: Ill Figure 8 Puffer
Posted: Wed Jan 20, 2010 2:28 pm
by Jacob
Right-o. The bottle (and some other typically-unreliable internet source) states that it treats internal worms. The proper medications require a prescription from a vet in the UK, and this seemed like the best bet. Very frustrating! Out of interest, what do other UK puffer owners use for de-worming?
I'll do a massive water change. Thanks!
Re: Ill Figure 8 Puffer
Posted: Wed Jan 20, 2010 2:35 pm
by LilGreenPuffer
I think most people in the UK use Wormer Plus, which is available on Eba
I could be wrong about it treating internal worms - it very well might - but you'd need to get him to eat it.
Re: Ill Figure 8 Puffer
Posted: Wed Jan 20, 2010 3:31 pm
by Myaj
Oh yikes, bad meds to use with a puffer.
Even getting a nitrate removing product may not help, you have to remember that nitrate specifically is not the only bad thing in the water, its just something we can test for easily and therefore, have a guildine as to how high various organic substances are building up in the water. So even if you remove the nitrates chemically, that may not remove other things (hormones, etc) that are reducing the water quality.
Re: Ill Figure 8 Puffer
Posted: Wed Jan 20, 2010 3:52 pm
by Jacob
Myaj wrote:So even if you remove the nitrates chemically, that may not remove other things (hormones, etc) that are reducing the water quality.
Right, but hopefully they shouldn't be present in my tap water! If they are, half of the UK is screwed as far as keeping fish is concerned as several regions have similar water. (It's also really hard and quite alkaline; one of the reasons I went with a brackish fish is that they tolerate such conditions far better than the traditional tetras and barbs.)
The only way to get rid of the stuff I can't see is to use RO water (or something similar), but that's not an option in the immediate future.
----
I've changed as much of the water as I could, leaving only a small amount in the bottom for the fish to sit in whilst I refilled it. Combined with the 25% and then the 50% that I did yesterday, there should be barely any medication left in there.
The fish is currently sitting on the sand. He drags himself about a bit but only swims when really necessary (such as when I'm taking water out of the tank), and only uses his pectoral and anal fins. He even ignored the snail I gave him, which is quite uncharacteristic. I'm hoping that he'll perk up. In the meantime, I don't think there's not much else I can do; I'll order some nitrate remover for good measure.
Thanks everyone for the help!
Re: Ill Figure 8 Puffer
Posted: Wed Jan 20, 2010 6:21 pm
by pufferpuggirl
Well I've just read through all of this and I'd like to say that because my water tests at 40ppm coming out of the tap, I don't think that's the issue here. My puffers are fine and I really don't think the nitrates being high in a naturally occuring setting is causing any problems in this particular situation. If the nitrate reading was that high due to a dirty tank, well then maybe there would be an issue, but I've been dealing with high nitrates myself and I think my fish are acclimated to it.
Stop using the Sterazin ... I hate to say it, but other than using the Waterlife Vitazin, most of what Waterlife produces is harmful to puffers. I used to use the Cuprazin for whitespot, but now that I know more about puffers, I've stopped.
However, I'm with PufferPunk in that I don't believe you are feeding this puffer nearly enough food. I would not give snails as the only food. When I feed my puffers snails, it's as a treat, or a snack, not their main food. You need to start giving that puffer more food daily until it gains weight and is back to normal. My F8's seem to enjoy prawn (shrimp) and bloodworms. It would be a good idea to get some Waterlife Vitazin to soak the bloodworm in, otherwise the puffers don't get alot of nutrition out of the bloodworm.
I think the most important thing you can do for this puffer, at this time, is to start feeding it more food. The poor thing is probably very malnourished. After you get it eating more food, then you can treat for IP's, but I personally would not treat it until it's eating regularly and seems to have more energy. Once it's good to go, then I would order the Jungle Parasite Clear off eBay for the parasite problem, it's good stuff.
But for now, PLEASE give your puffer more food!!! You might want to read the articles on feeding puffers which is in the library.
Best of luck, but I believe your puffer will be fine if you start giving him some good food. Don't worry about nitrate remover .... seriously, that's not your main problem right now.
Re: Ill Figure 8 Puffer
Posted: Wed Jan 20, 2010 6:44 pm
by LilGreenPuffer
When working with a sick fish, it's essential to give it the best possible water quality, and certainly not such high nitrates that most people wouldn't consider keeping even a perfectly healthy fish in it.
You can add vitamin C crystals to reduce nitrates. There's a thread on it in the marine section.
Re: Ill Figure 8 Puffer
Posted: Wed Jan 20, 2010 6:58 pm
by pufferpuggirl
Yes, but all I'm saying is, this high nitrates from the tap is an on-going problem here in the UK, and in my opinion, the main issue in this case is that I don't believe his F8 is getting enough nutrition. All I'm saying is that he should sort that out first, and then maybe worry about those nitrates, but I think it's just one of those things unfortunately. If he can get the nitrates down without causing too much trouble to his tank, then good for him .... but I think it's easier said than done. My fish seem to have become accustomed to the high nitrates from the tap, and surely I can't be the only person in the UK, and just the fact that he's having high nitrate readings tells me that I'm not the only person.
I just think that puffer needs some good food more than anything else right now.
Re: Ill Figure 8 Puffer
Posted: Thu Jan 21, 2010 4:03 am
by Jacob
Alas, I think he died this morning. He was dragging himself along the floor for a bit, and then stopped in a position where I can't see if he's breathing or not, but his eyes aren't moving to look at me any more. I gave him some food beforehand, and I think he ate some, though he was struggling swim to it (and could not lift himself off the floor).
It seems that I should have checked here before medicating, rather than believing what I read elsewhere! Incidentally, your library was extremely useful when I was setting everything up.
It's likely that I'll get another Figure-8 puffer; the tank is already set up for one, they are lovely fish and whilst I made a pretty serious mistake this time, I should have learned from the experience.
For the record, how much should I feed? I'm guessing that "size of an eye" is too small; it seemed too small at the time, but even the unreliable sources warn about how easy it is to over-feed. Maybe I just missed it, but whilst the feeding article talks at length about types of food, it doesn't seem to mention quantities.
Re: Ill Figure 8 Puffer
Posted: Thu Jan 21, 2010 6:50 am
by pufferpuggirl
I'm very sorry for the loss of your puffer, it's a sad thing to see them go. But I hope that you will learn from your experiences with that F8, and all you can do is go forward and try to do better for the next puffer.
In regards to food, when I'm feeding my puffers, I try to mentally think about how much it will take to fill up their little tummies. The rule of thumb about feeding snails (the size of their eye, is so they don't choke on one too big for their mouths), but it's nothing to do with how much to feed them as far as giving a nutritional meal -- at least not to my understanding. When feeding pieces of shrimp for example, I would not go any bigger than the size of my fingernail on my pinky finger, and with small puffers I feed every day. Try to keep their feeding time at the same time of day, it gets them into a routine. If you were to come to my house near to 5pm, you would see all of my puffers up and about swimming, looking for their meal. It's funny because they all come out of the woodwork, so to speak, when they are hungry, otherwise you wouldn't know there were puffers in some of my tanks.
