Page 1 of 1

gravel from hardware store safe for fish?

Posted: Tue Jan 19, 2010 4:54 am
by kilofey
i know the sand like for sand boxes is fine when washed thourghly and sterelized..... but does this work with the gravel as well? i was thinking of getting a light colored gravel for my tank to make kukahs bright color come back, he only turned dark after i put the black gravel in.... and i like the look of this certain color at the hardware store.... and since i just bought enough black gravel for a 55gal, id like to keep it as cheap as possible since i JUST put the black in and now HATE it... i wont be doing it for a few weeks though, i want my tank to be FULLY cycled before i do it...

i plan on cutting down this crappy store bought tank divider i have to about 3 or 4 inches tall. i want to remove like 5 or 10lbs at a time of old gravel and replace with new gravel for a span of like 2 weeks.... just so i know for shure i dont screw up the cycle.... since its been such a pain getting the water good lol theres NO WAY im gonna mess it up!

also, when buying gravel from a hardware store, is there anything i should look out for when looking at the gravel discription? like porous or unsterelized or a sertain type of rock that wont work in a tank?

thanks

Re: gravel from hardware store safe for fish?

Posted: Tue Jan 19, 2010 10:05 am
by Flutter
Someone else can talk about the rest but I want to mention sharp edges. Perhaps your fish would like to bury in pool filter sand?

Re: gravel from hardware store safe for fish?

Posted: Tue Jan 19, 2010 11:13 am
by RTR
Do you have any idea of the average grain size of the gravel? Too large is an upkeep issue and chronic problem for the fishkeeper. Flutter's comments on sharp edges also do apply.

Also,is your puffer one that buries itself? If that is the case, a much finer substrate is appropriate.

Darker shades tend to brighten a fish's colors, but full black may well take that too far. Very light-colored substrates do tend to make colors paler -it may well wash out some of the color. Much pool filter sand can do that if not shaded by plants and decor.

All the above is why I use a mixed "natural" gravel, relatively small-grained. If a bit light, I can control that with decor or plants to make it look darker. If too dark, a bit more light has the opposite effect.

But in the end the substrate color is the keeper's choice. The fish will adapt to the color. The grain size and lack of sharpness should always be considered for the fish though.

HTH

Re: gravel from hardware store safe for fish?

Posted: Tue Jan 19, 2010 2:51 pm
by autophotos
i used some from my local building suppliers in the last month or so -

they had labels on them - fish safe and non fish safe - so that made things alot easier -

so bought what i wanted and took it home to throughly wash - took ages but hell of a lot cheaper than the lfs -

lfs would have worked out about 60 pounds for what i wanted - where as the builders merchants - 15 pounds and some effort to prepare the stuff

Re: gravel from hardware store safe for fish?

Posted: Tue Jan 19, 2010 4:05 pm
by kilofey
thanks! i didnt know it was listed as fish safe.... i was thinking of some gravel that did look like it had smooth edges and it is smaller than the aquarium gravel.... it is all different natural colors.... i decided on this one because my puff does like to burry himself... so this is lighter than what he is in now. and i know, it really does take a lot to clean this stuff.... but its SSOOOO much cheaper and looks just as good! thanks guys :)

Re: gravel from hardware store safe for fish?

Posted: Tue Jan 19, 2010 4:44 pm
by autophotos
in the uk - here they will label them fish safe or not so you can use them to decorate ponds and water features