Page 1 of 1
seachem ammonia alert question
Posted: Mon Jan 18, 2010 5:14 am
by kilofey
heres the products site:
http://www.seachem.com/Products/product ... Alert.html
i know ive been posting a lot guys... sorry heh heh... but, since i heard from multiple posts that the seachem liquid ammonia test is NOT user friendly at all.... i hate to order it, then immediately throw it away cause i cant figure the darn thing out.
i had this ammonia alert before i even knew it tested free ammonia (since i will get a false positive when using prime with my current test kit).... i know its probably not as accurate as the test kit would be... but i fear i will either not be able to figure it out, or i will think im doing it right when im not, then it will be as inaccurate as my other liquid test is.... would you say i could get away with putting a couple of these in different places of my tank? like one by the filter, and one at the opposite side of the tank.... and just change the water regularly, and whenever i see the color change in the slightest bit in addition to the regular WCs?
Re: seachem ammonia alert question
Posted: Mon Jan 18, 2010 5:58 am
by LilGreenPuffer
Those things are poo. I've never used them, but everyone I know who has used them really dislikes them. One major red flag: They're supposed to last "over a year," but you won't know exactly when it stops working.
It measures total ammonia, same as an API kit, so it's no different.
Re: seachem ammonia alert question
Posted: Mon Jan 18, 2010 4:47 pm
by kilofey
it does read total ammonia? i could swear i read it will read free amonia in the link.... ill take a look at it again.... but i do plan on replacing it every 6 months or so... and with the WCs being done regularly, and an additional WC with the first slight color change it seems like it would be okay
Re: seachem ammonia alert question
Posted: Mon Jan 18, 2010 7:32 pm
by LilGreenPuffer
Hmmm, maybe you're right. It's sort of a confusing description. Where's RTR?
Re: seachem ammonia alert question
Posted: Mon Jan 18, 2010 7:53 pm
by kilofey
calling RTR!!!! come in, RTR! lol.... hey, if you read this, could you tell me if it would be good enough to have this ammonia alert monitor by seachem which reads free amonia.... i will replace it every 6 months (though it is good for a year) and do regular WCs while using prime.... i know they arent the most accurate things on the planet, but with regular WCs and prime it should be a good enough for a ballpark range right? i just dont want to get the other seachem liquid test and not be able to figure it out lol.... this one i CAN figure out

Re: seachem ammonia alert question
Posted: Mon Jan 18, 2010 7:54 pm
by RTR
I thought that I had already said that the Ammonia Alert tests free ammonia. It is based on parallel technology to the ammonia test kit. Seachemis not perfect, but they are head abd shoulders above any of the other houses dealing in similar products.
For more info, see:
http://www.seachem.com/Products/product ... Alert.html
All that aid, I have never tested the product myself I mean,i do have and have used many times, the ammonia test kit. I'm supposed to a couple of dozen of the Ammonia Alerts every year? I think not.
I can neither praise nor heap scorn on the particular product here, since I have not teated it and I would never do either without personal experience. But I can say that its related product, the test kit, works well - if a PITA to use.
HTH
Re: seachem ammonia alert question
Posted: Mon Jan 18, 2010 8:04 pm
by kilofey
thanks RTR

ill keep usin the alert in my tank and see how it goes.... since the WCs are regular, a ball park reading should be good i think.... just figured id ask you since you seemed to know alot about the seachem products

Re: seachem ammonia alert question
Posted: Mon Jan 18, 2010 8:07 pm
by LilGreenPuffer
Let us know if it works well. Everyone I know who's used it haaaated it and said it was inaccurate and hard to read, but maybe with the understanding of free/ionized ammonia, you'll do better.
Re: seachem ammonia alert question
Posted: Mon Jan 18, 2010 8:48 pm
by kilofey
the only thing im looking for on it is a good strong yellow color on the dot (which means 0)..... even a slight green tinge, time for a WC..... i figure as long as i keep it at yellow.... bright yellow at that, i cant go wrong

now that my water is starting to stabalize a bit, i want to keep it that way.... i wanna do this tank right lol.... not like my past tanks that only got water changes when the water "looked" ugly and got a filter change once a monthish

Re: seachem ammonia alert question
Posted: Mon Jan 18, 2010 9:09 pm
by autophotos
i saw some of these the other day in lfs - and then saw them on ebay cheaper - and thought they look good - only a year - but thats not a huge price for a year -
would be great oif they did one for nitrite and nitrate as well - woohoo
Re: seachem ammonia alert question
Posted: Mon Jan 18, 2010 9:11 pm
by PolishPuff
I think they make one for PH
Re: seachem ammonia alert question
Posted: Tue Jan 19, 2010 12:29 pm
by RTR
About a generation ago, I used Dupla products for planted tanks, and a good bit of their filtration media. Their US rep shut down that business (he was local to me,and an acquaintance). Seachem was just starting up. I switched to their plant supplements and ferts. They have expanded tremendously, but are still one of the most advanced and reliable sources for a variety of things. I still use only their plant products, they are the best and most flexible for me. Their conditioner, Prime, is the industry's best IMHO. I have played with some of their other products, but really don't need many of them. Most of what I have tried does the job for which it is sold, but i certainly have not played with the whole line by any means.
The industry, including Seachem needs to modernize their test kit lines. The 20th century chemistries are no longer suited to modern American public water supplies, and the few tests available which are suitable (including Seachem's) really are not user-friendly.That hopefully will come along.