Page 1 of 5

plain tap water tested positive for ammonia???

Posted: Fri Jan 15, 2010 6:49 pm
by kilofey
so i tested my tap water for ammonia, out of pure curiousoty and boredom.... and it actually came up a positive result??? :shock: i tested right, i read the test under a bright light, and there does in fact seem to be a green tinge to the water.... im reading about .25... which is the reading im getting from my tank water as well.... whats happening? does some tap water actually contain measureable ammounts of ammonia? or am i just stuipd and seeing something thats not really there? color blind? lol

Re: plain tap water tested positive for ammonia???

Posted: Fri Jan 15, 2010 7:11 pm
by busybones
A lot of tap water will contain ammonia (in the US, I'm not sure about elsewhere) What type of dechlorinator are you using? Prime helps to remove ammonia as well as chlorine and chloramine.

Re: plain tap water tested positive for ammonia???

Posted: Fri Jan 15, 2010 7:33 pm
by kilofey
i am in fact using prime... but i heard it will give a false reading. is that true? and how to i get an accurate reading?.... speak simply please heh heh

just to make sure im using it right... its just one capful for every 50 gal right? that sounds like nothing at all.... it doesnt seem like it could work with just that much

Re: plain tap water tested positive for ammonia???

Posted: Fri Jan 15, 2010 8:02 pm
by RTR
Yes, all water with chloramines added will test positive for ammonia, because in the USA, chloramines are the standard disinfectant added to public water supplies. Not all utilities have switched over to chloramines as yet, but eventually they all will comply with federal law and do so. As your water tests positive for ammonia, you can say that your water has chloramines added. You are using the right agent to take care of them.

Prime does not, repeat DOES NOT give a false positive for ammonia. Your test kit gives a false positive for ammonia because it reads TAN, total ammonia nitrogen. The kit cannot distinguish between free ammonia dissolved gas (NH3) and ammonium ion (NH4+) - the former is poison to our tanks, the latter is harmless. Hobby test kits are still back in the last century. Someday they will catch up. Sechem's ammonia test kit does read correctly. If you are still using old-fashioned test kits, you have to trust that you used the proper dosage of Prime and go from there, or get a modern test kit.

IMHO & IME, Prime is the best disinfectant neutralization agent available today. I would not consider using anything else. There are still too many "conditioners" on the market that do not and cannot do all three jobs required, Prime can and does. I wish I owned a chunk of the company.

Re: plain tap water tested positive for ammonia???

Posted: Fri Jan 15, 2010 9:02 pm
by busybones
kilofey wrote: just to make sure im using it right... its just one capful for every 50 gal right? that sounds like nothing at all.... it doesnt seem like it could work with just that much
Prime is the second most concentrated dechlorinator on the market. So yes a little goes a long way when using prime and as long as you are going by the instructions on the back you should be fine.

Re: plain tap water tested positive for ammonia???

Posted: Fri Jan 15, 2010 9:23 pm
by LilGreenPuffer
I have 1ppm in my tap. I feel your pain. Prime works wonders, though.

Re: plain tap water tested positive for ammonia???

Posted: Fri Jan 15, 2010 9:37 pm
by kilofey
:shock: so what i understand from what you are saying is (and pls tell me if i understood it incorrectly): when i use prime for the first time, i obviously should dose it for the full 55gal of tank water (which i already did). my fish is now safe from ammonia poisoning, regardless of what my api liquid ammonia test kit says. when i do a WC of about 25% in a few days, i will only dose the tank with prime for the ammount of new water i added (roughly 14 gal, or 13.75 gal to be exact). or does the tank need to be dosed for the whole 55 gal every WC? and should i buy the seachem test? or just be diligent with my WCs and know that the prime is doing its job?

and i have this ammonia detector by seachem http://www.google.com/products/catalog? ... B8Q8gIwBQ# just as a rough heads up.... does this test the same way the ammonia test you are reccomending does? will it give a more accurate reading than my liquid test kit? (i know these arent prescise either, i just want to know for a ballpark since my liquid test kit is now useless... just need to know for until i can get the proper test kit)

and is this the correct ammonia test kit i would need? http://www.premiumaquatics.com/Merchant ... re_Code=PA

sorry for all the questions... ive just never used any of these products so im hoping someone can confirm my correct/incorrect useage of them. thank you guys!

Re: plain tap water tested positive for ammonia???

Posted: Fri Jan 15, 2010 9:53 pm
by busybones
or just be diligent with my WCs and know that the prime is doing its job?
Absolutely not, the prime will be helping rid the new water from ammonia but please don't depend on it to be a fix all. You need to continue regular water changes in order to keep your fish healthy.

Re: plain tap water tested positive for ammonia???

Posted: Fri Jan 15, 2010 10:14 pm
by kilofey
busybones wrote:
or just be diligent with my WCs and know that the prime is doing its job?
Absolutely not, the prime will be helping rid the new water from ammonia but please don't depend on it to be a fix all. You need to continue regular water changes in order to keep your fish healthy.
thats what i said..... be diligent with water changes.... that means to keep doing them without fail on schedule every time..... im just trying to figure out what everyone on TPF that uses prime does... do you guys still do the ammonia tests but use seachem tests? or do you just make sure you arent skipping any WCs so that you KNOW the ammonia levels are down? theres a lot of people that reccomend prime, i just want to hear what you guys do to monitor your ammonia

Re: plain tap water tested positive for ammonia???

Posted: Fri Jan 15, 2010 10:27 pm
by J-P
I have a digital monitor... lab grade. But I don't have a typical tank either.

Seachem is good so is Tetra but ad RTR pointed out before (in another post) they only give you a range.. personally I want solid numbers :)

Re: plain tap water tested positive for ammonia???

Posted: Fri Jan 15, 2010 10:28 pm
by LilGreenPuffer
Once your tank is established, the excess ammonia from the tap will disappear in 24hrs or less - the bacteria will process it. :)

Re: plain tap water tested positive for ammonia???

Posted: Fri Jan 15, 2010 10:35 pm
by busybones
When doing water changes you need to use the declorinator before adding the water to the tank. If you are using a 5 gallon bucket (like I do) you should add enough prime for that amount of water and the same for the next bucket. Try to keep your new water temperatures close to the ones of the tank.

Re: plain tap water tested positive for ammonia???

Posted: Fri Jan 15, 2010 11:16 pm
by LilGreenPuffer
Geeeeez, you use a 5g bucket for all those tanks? If I were you, I'd have gotten some really big trash cans or something by now. How long do water changes take you?

Re: plain tap water tested positive for ammonia???

Posted: Fri Jan 15, 2010 11:42 pm
by busybones
LilGreenPuffer wrote:Geeeeez, you use a 5g bucket for all those tanks? If I were you, I'd have gotten some really big trash cans or something by now. How long do water changes take you?
It isn't that bad (my hubby helps ;) ) On a 55 gallon tank it usually takes about 15-20 minutes. But I try to do them on separate days. I would use big trash cans but don't want them setting around the house. The extra work doesn't really bother me :)

Re: plain tap water tested positive for ammonia???

Posted: Fri Jan 15, 2010 11:44 pm
by LilGreenPuffer
I need a husband. Those sound really useful...