Page 1 of 2

can "prime" dechlor and tank cycler work together?

Posted: Thu Jan 14, 2010 7:37 pm
by kilofey
i bought "prime" dechlorinator and i also bought the best tank cycler that my LFS sells. i asked the lady to show me the best one, she handed me super bac. she said that is the only one they sell that ACTUALLY works (which i hope is true cause it wasnt cheap). has anyone used this product? i dont really have a choice of weather or not to buy Dr. Tims since i kinda need it now and i can only get dr tims online... so this one will have to do...

anyway, onto my question... if i dose my tank with prime, should i dose it with the super bac tank cycler at the same time? will the prime kill anything i need that is coming from the tank cycler or can i use them together? ive never used either of these products. and should i put some of the tank cycler into my filter so that it gets directly on the debris catcher and the inside of the filter walls?

thanks guys :)

Re: can "prime" dechlor and tank cycler work together?

Posted: Thu Jan 14, 2010 9:22 pm
by LilGreenPuffer
I've never heard of Super Bac working. Look, why would they carry the others if they didn't work? To make money. Why did they sell you that? Probably the same reason. :(

Get Dr. Tim's shipped express - you'll get it the next day.

Prime detoxifies ammonia, leaving it for the nitrifying bacteria to consume. That's why we all like it so much. :)

Re: can "prime" dechlor and tank cycler work together?

Posted: Fri Jan 15, 2010 3:33 am
by Pufferpunk
You really should ask the manufacturer about that Prime question.

Re: can "prime" dechlor and tank cycler work together?

Posted: Fri Jan 15, 2010 5:13 am
by LilGreenPuffer
Dad said it converts ammonia into ammonium. Someone (RTR?) gave a really scientific explanation the other day.

Edit - I found it!
RTR wrote:What liquid test kit are you using, and what disinfectant neutralize? I ask because many to most hobby kits commonly give false positives after Prime use. Only a couple of kits can distinguish between ammonium ion and dissolved gas ammonia. Most kits measure both, so-called TAN (total ammonia nitrogen). If your kit says it measures TAN, and you have used the correct dose of Prime, you may have a false positive - they are common and not valid. Someday all kits will read the difference, most today cannot. Seachem makes one which can and does read ammonia dissolved gas (aka free ammonia), the bad stuff. Complexed ammonia is locked into the ammonium ion form and harmless. But the Seachem kit is not user-friendly.

HTH
About that SuperBac... I saw your other post on it and looked up this link, the one you posted. http://www.fishlore.com/fishforum/gener ... -work.html Next time I start a new tank, I'll get some and experiment with it. I've thought about running tests with different ones before, monitoring and using all the popular brands and getting several bottles from different batches of each, stored in different conditions... Of course, that would be ridiculously expensive, but it would be nice to have something a little definitive!

Re: can "prime" dechlor and tank cycler work together?

Posted: Fri Jan 15, 2010 9:45 am
by RTR
Well, thanks to LilGreenPuffer, I don't have to repeat myself - thank you ma'am!

On the bacterial "starters", for background information, there are thousands of nitrification bacteria in the world - bacteria which do the conversion/oxidation of ammonium ion to nitrite ion to get energy, and equal numbers of others which do the similar conversion of nitrite ion to nitrate ion, also for energy. Nitrate is desirable to us in that it is far, far, less toxic to out aquarium critters (at least 100-fold, about two orders of magnitude) than free ammonia or nitrite ion), But the trick we need in cycling a tank is to get bacteria which establish and maintain on-going colonies in our tanks. Most nitrification bacteria will do the two jobs we need done (ammonium to nitrite ion, and nitrite ion to nitrate ion), but most will not establish permanently in our filters or even filterless tanks. What we want and need and are willing to pay for is a set of bacteria which will do the jobs AND establish self-perpetuating colonies in our tanks. To me it is senseless to buy bacteria which you need to replace weekly, every other week, or monthly. Get the point? We want the job done once and for all. If we have to replenish the bugs constantly, they really are not what we need. That is the big question. We know that Dr.Tim's selections work. We do not know about the others. They may work initially if there really are live bacteria present (commonly there are not), but if they are not self-perpetuating, they cost way too much. Do the job once and never again - at least so long a you do kill them off unintentionally. That is the main point. We want three things really 1) live nitrification bacteria, 2) bacteria to oxidize ammonium ion AND bacteria to oxidize nitrite ion, and 3) that both sets will establish self-perpetuating colonies in our tanks. If any of those three things are missing, we are throwing money away and endangering our fish.

HTH

Re: can "prime" dechlor and tank cycler work together?

Posted: Fri Jan 15, 2010 5:02 pm
by kilofey
:shock: woah.

Re: can "prime" dechlor and tank cycler work together?

Posted: Fri Jan 15, 2010 7:38 pm
by LilGreenPuffer
Yeah... um... I want to have a brain left at the end of the day, so I'm not even going to try to remember what ions have to do with anything. Atoms with a charge... Or something... Charges... Okay, I'm bowing out now...

Re: can "prime" dechlor and tank cycler work together?

Posted: Fri Jan 15, 2010 8:32 pm
by RTR
Atoms don't usually change - unless they are radioactive or are put into a nuclear reactor.

But life of any kind that we know of cannot deal in atoms. Life is water-based on this planet at least. Life here deals in ions, it does not know about atoms.

Re: can "prime" dechlor and tank cycler work together?

Posted: Fri Jan 15, 2010 9:50 pm
by kilofey
times like this make me wish i went to college :mcfly:

Re: can "prime" dechlor and tank cycler work together?

Posted: Fri Jan 15, 2010 11:30 pm
by LilGreenPuffer
I'm in college and I did pretty darned good in BIO111 last semester. Doesn't help much right now.

Re: can "prime" dechlor and tank cycler work together?

Posted: Sat Jan 16, 2010 11:27 am
by RTR
We will not discuss year of schooling - I would have loved to be a professional student.

Then there is my younger sister -who nearly flunked introductory biology. We obviously are on different wavelengths. She did go through to get a master's degree though. Not in the hard sciences, of course. ;)

Re: can "prime" dechlor and tank cycler work together?

Posted: Sat Jan 16, 2010 12:49 pm
by LilGreenPuffer
I'm majoring in theatre (focus on educational theatre) and thinking towards a master's in elementary education. I don't want to have to think about ions ever again.

Re: can "prime" dechlor and tank cycler work together?

Posted: Sat Jan 16, 2010 7:26 pm
by riggers
But they're so interesting :D. I love science! Wow I bet that sounds nerdy :lol:

Re: can "prime" dechlor and tank cycler work together?

Posted: Sat Jan 16, 2010 7:48 pm
by Flutter
Hehe. 4th year Zoo major here. About as hard core science as you can get. Actually, at least 95% of my courses are full hard core science. The behaviour courses, conservation biology, and apiculture are probably the only ones that I've taken that aren't. And those aren't easy courses to begin with ;)

Re: can "prime" dechlor and tank cycler work together?

Posted: Sat Jan 16, 2010 9:21 pm
by RTR
LOL again! My sister was an education major undergrad, masters is in guidance- what she does now for some time. She left the classroom long ago - after a horrible experience - took a year off, then went back to school after for the master's and never went back to the classroom to teach again.