Page 1 of 1

Brown algae :(

Posted: Thu Jan 14, 2010 6:39 pm
by puffypuff
Hey everyone,

Sorry - not strictly puffer specific - but over the last week we've noticed nasty brown algae in our F8's aquarium :(

The aquarium has been running for about a month and a half now, and our fish is doing really, really well, but the algae is uuuuugly. I've read that it's common in a new tank, and will probably go away as suddenly as it appeared, but I'm just wondering when that might be?

We currently have the light on for around 12 hours a day. Would it be advisable to leave it off for a few days, and feed a little less?

We're planning to start converting to brackish in a few months time, when the cycle's had a good long time to get settled - are there any dwarf algae eaters that would live with an F8 and cope in brackish conditions?

Many thanks for any help!

Ps. Do F8s ever eat plants? Most of the planting in the aquarium is artificial, but I've noticed perfect circles cut out of the leaves of the couple of real plants I've got growing in there and was wondering if our fish was having a nibble?

Re: Brown algae :(

Posted: Fri Jan 15, 2010 3:08 am
by mrgreen
I have the same in mine. I use an anti algea after water changes. During, I take every decoration out and give it a nice wipe in old tank water.

F8s are constantly on the hunt. Never seen mine munch on a plastic plant though.

I once put two of my algea eaters in my brackish tank- during a water change of my DPs tank. Bad idea. He immediately had a munch out of his side! (He recovered but I think he was lucky.).

Re: Brown algae :(

Posted: Fri Jan 15, 2010 3:32 am
by Pufferpunk
Is it algae or diatoms?

Re: Brown algae :(

Posted: Fri Jan 15, 2010 10:24 am
by RTR
I'd bet money that it is diatoms, which are highly specialized algae. They absolutely require soluble silicates in the water in which they live. These critters have "shells" called "tests" made up of silicates which they extract from the water. Without a soluble silicate source, they cannot grow and divide.

PS: Diatom powder is mined from strata made up of billions of cast-off tests on diatoms - thus the name - the tests have tiny pores, which filter down to micron levels and below. The intricate tests make beautiful photomicrographs - Goggle them sometimes when you are bored

That was the long slow curve. The fast break is that if your source water is high in silicates, you will have diatom algae. If your source water is moderate in soluble silicates, you may or may not have them. If your water is low in soluble silicates, you might have some very early in the tank's life, but they will starve out soon. Most waters are low to moderate in soluble silicates, but some sources are high (especially those from geologically old sand-based aquifers -silica is not very soluble - it takes centuries to eons to build up - but you knew that already: glass tanks and silica sand do not dissolve very fast, do they?). Ask you water utility and they will give you soluble silicate levels. If it is high, learn to live with it.

It is possible to pre-treat water to get rid of soluble silicates, but is takes equipment, time, and money. My best advice is to deal with it - wipe it off. It wipes off easily, even with a soft sponge. It is the preferred food of Otocinclus catfish, but they cannot take even light BW and should not be with most puffers. If it keeps coming back, still deal with it personally, not by water mods - those cost a heck of a lot more in both time and money.

And yes, puffers do bite holes in plants - it is an incidental side-catch as it were. When they grab a snail on a leaf, they frequently get a nice circle of leaf tissue - fresh veggie directly in their diet. When loaches do the same, they make V or Y-shaped hole cuts. It is easy to tell if a given hole was done by a puffer or a loach. Is that a good enough bit of useless but interesting trivia for you today? ;)

HTH

Re: Brown algae :(

Posted: Fri Jan 15, 2010 10:29 am
by PolishPuff
Brown Algae (diatoms) are more likely to appear in low-light aquarium and new set-ups, with excess silicate acids. Its been known that strong lights make this algae go away, but they might still be seen on lower, shadowed, plant leaves. It can also be found on aquarium glass, gravel and decoration. It can be easily removed manually, since it has a soft/slimy structure. OTOs and Snails can easily keep this algae in low numbers.

Re: Brown algae :(

Posted: Fri Jan 15, 2010 11:33 am
by RTR
PolishPuff the limited appearance of diatoms in bright tanks is only that it is a poor competitor against green algae, so can only get light where the greens are less likely to grow. It actually does best in high light to full sun. It is just slower than the more modern algal forms.

Re: Brown algae :(

Posted: Fri Jan 15, 2010 1:00 pm
by mrgreen
Ok so what can you do about it?

Re: Brown algae :(

Posted: Fri Jan 15, 2010 3:38 pm
by Dadof4
Yeah, I have the same question. I live in an area that the ground water sits in a sand bed and I have a huge diatom problem. Would running a silicate remover in my filter be worth it to at least get some control of the problem?

Re: Brown algae :(

Posted: Fri Jan 15, 2010 5:03 pm
by puffypuff
Pufferpunk wrote:Is it algae or diatoms?
It's brown and slimy and it wipes off easily - so from reading the other posts here, I guess it's diatoms?

We've done a couple of water changes now, but it's only appeared since the last one. At the next change we'll clean all the fake plants and his little cave, and hope that helps keep it down :)

Is that a definite no to an oto or pleccy? I guess I could get some large snails?

Thanks so much for the info guys.

Re: Brown algae :(

Posted: Fri Jan 15, 2010 5:20 pm
by bigfatfish
I had it in my new tank for maybe 2 months. Was starting to regret having a BW set up, as I was taking out the decs every other day to wipe them clean. It always looked brown & dull. Has completely stopped now though. Just get a little algae build up, which needs wiping from the glass ever 10-14 days. I have some ghost shrimp in the tank at the moment, but they don't really eat the algae - they prefer the puffs food!

Re: Brown algae :(

Posted: Fri Jan 15, 2010 8:26 pm
by RTR
Manual removal is best and easiest. Ditom removers are also phosphate removers and are not the best thing to use in a tank. Phosphates are a highly significant part of life - including fish and humans.

Re: Brown algae :(

Posted: Fri Jan 15, 2010 9:54 pm
by Dadof4
Crud. I thought that may be the problem but I was hoping you had a silicates remover that didn't eat phos as well....I wonder if adding a phos and nitrogen supplement would give the green algae a boost and challenge the diatoms and compete each other out...

Re: Brown algae :(

Posted: Sat Jan 16, 2010 11:36 am
by RTR
LOL! Wishful thinking I suspect...

Re: Brown algae :(

Posted: Sat Jan 16, 2010 3:11 pm
by Dadof4
Exactly....*sigh*

Re: Brown algae :(

Posted: Sat Jan 16, 2010 7:22 pm
by mrgreen
Then you'll just get brown algea AND neon green algea. The green is gone now in mine.