Page 1 of 1
do ALL puffers come directly from the wild?
Posted: Thu Jan 14, 2010 6:09 am
by kilofey
is there a type of puffer that doesnt necessairaly have to come from the wild to be put in your fish tank? what about my fish? are both fahakas and dwarf puffers usually caught directly from the wild? or are they sometimes bred commercially? and are there any other breeds that are comercially bred more commonly than wild caught? i know you'd probably get a "higher quality" puffer if they were born and caught in the wild as opposed to overcrowding and such in hatcheries.... but i was just thinking about it, and it seems sort of mean to take them from their habitats and put them in a glass box. i still like them and wont get rid of them, cause its not like i can go return kukah and booger to their native habitats in africa and india lol...
Re: do ALL puffers come directly from the wild?
Posted: Thu Jan 14, 2010 10:18 am
by RTR
Most puffers are wild caught,with the exception of the dwarf puffers - most of those are commercially bred.
Hobbyist-bred fish do occur, but so seldom that you cannot count on such. There is a prospect of commercially-bred GSPs, but I don't know how soon we can expect them to be common.
Commercial breeding does not guarantee quality, nor does wild-caught guarantee diseased fish. The commercially bred DPs used to be almost universally carrying intestinal parasites. I dont know the current situation there.
The biggest stress on wild caught fish are from improper handling at capture and during shipment. Much the same applies to commercially bred fish, mishandling (overcrowding, sudden changes in water type, pollution from wastes) and starvation during shipment and through a series of middlemen takes the same toll on both captured and farm-bred fish.
Some wild-caught are rationally harvested and well-handled locally (such as Project Piaba, started for sustainable and non-damaging harvest of Tetras and others of that sort. That effort and later ones at other locations can be well done and sustainable without ecological upset).
Some commercial breeding all but guarantees unhealthy fish - poor food, excessive use of hormones and antibiotics, massive overcrowding, and too-young/small shipment all take a major toll on the "product", but not so quickly that the breeder loses any payment - the fish last until the local distributor, the LFS,or the unsuspecting or unknowing hobbyists.
Re: do ALL puffers come directly from the wild?
Posted: Thu Jan 14, 2010 2:18 pm
by Pufferpunk
PetSmart used to breed DPs at their facility. I don't think they do anymore.
Re: do ALL puffers come directly from the wild?
Posted: Thu Jan 14, 2010 4:50 pm
by Myaj
Dwarf puffers are the only ones reliably breedable by hobbiests. Some of the red eyes can be bred, if the pair doesn't kill each other first, and if you look in our library, Rocker sucessfully bred some lurker species. But by far, they are wild caught for the most part..
Between their natural aggression even towards the opposite sex of the same species, and not being able to tell which is male and which is female in most species.. well, its tough!
Re: do ALL puffers come directly from the wild?
Posted: Thu Jan 14, 2010 4:56 pm
by pufferpuggirl
Suvattii puffers breed fairly easily. I got one from Rocker, one of his off-spring, and I also had one from another fish store that had successfully bred them. I have been told once they pair off that they will lay eggs quite quickly. I didn't want the responsibility of fry, so made sure not to get a known pair.
Re: do ALL puffers come directly from the wild?
Posted: Thu Jan 14, 2010 5:10 pm
by kilofey
[quote="RTR"]Commercial breeding does not guarantee quality, nor does wild-caught guarantee diseased fish. The commercially bred DPs used to be almost universally carrying intestinal parasites. I dont know the current situation there.
quote]
i think you got what i meant backward... i said, you would get a higher quality puffer from the wild and a not so high quality one from a distributor.... i was assuming youd get a better fish from the wild.... i guess its not true in all cases.... just made me think of my guppy tank.... when i had a big guppy tank, i started out with a few since i knew they would be breeding, after a while, they were starting to get overcrowded and started breeding with brothers and sisters and aunts and uncles and so on.... eventually the few i started out with turned into hundreds, and when they were breeding with eachother in a space too small for the quantity, their fins started to come out ugly and not as vibrant.... i also noticed they didnt live quite as long too..... eventually i had to start thinning out my tank, so i just started to use them as feeders for my cichlids

it just made me think about puffers and if they were wild caught, there would be like no way they would be imbred, but in commercial distribution situations, im sure a lot of that goes on in small spaces which would make ther color less vibrant, possibly stunt their growth, and give them a shorter lifespan.... thats just from my personal guppy observations though. puffers may be different..... anyway, i feel kinda bad taking them from the wild, but at least i know my puffer will be a higher quality puffer than if he was bred in a hatchery... i dunno, just my opinion

Re: do ALL puffers come directly from the wild?
Posted: Thu Jan 14, 2010 5:25 pm
by J-P
That is entirely circumstantial. You can have good and bad breeders and you can have healthy and sick wild caught fish. Far too many variables.
In RTR's experience captive fish should live longer and healthier lives than they do in the wild. Again circumstantia because you have many hobbiests that don't treat their fish like a serious pet. Under perfect conditions with the right care your fish should live very long lives.
Your Fahaka is most likely wild caught .. the DP ... it is a coin toss.