Page 1 of 1

Newbie w/ an issue

Posted: Sat Jan 02, 2010 1:35 am
by jamkak
So, I've been poking around this site for a while and decided to register and make a quick post. I used to have a few GSP quite a few years ago in a 45g tank and after a while I just basically got out of having my aquarium up and running. I now have a set of 4yr old twin boys that have been harrassing me in putting fish into the 45g fish tank that currently sits empty. I think they would enjoy watching puffers.

With this, I have always loved puffers but now here is my issue. I'm up in Montana and with the economy we no longer have any local stores except for Walmart and PetSmart. Now we've all see the health of the walmart puffers and currently their tank is looking pretty bad. (Sorta sad...) Anyways, in talking with PetSmart, they told me that puffers are the only fish that they will not order in.

I'm thinking of looking towards the online shops even though the shipping charges are a little scary. In researching, I like the idea of getting a bunch of dwarf puffers and watching them, but thought I would ask what some opinions of types of puffers and quantities that might work?

Is there a more reliable online shop for puffers?

Also, I was wondering if using sand instead of gravel would have any issues with puffers like the caribsea super natural moonlight sand (white)?

Any thoughts or opinions would be greatly appreciated.

Thanks!

-Jeff

Re: Newbie w/ an issue

Posted: Sat Jan 02, 2010 1:52 am
by J-P
welcome to the forum!!

TFDFish.com some members here have had good results .. but I can't speak for them. The $200 buy in .. don't worry about it.. it is the shipping costs.

Re: Newbie w/ an issue

Posted: Sat Jan 02, 2010 1:57 am
by busybones
Welcome to the forum Jamkak! With a 45 gallon tank you have a few options. If you don't mind the extra work of the Brackish water tanks you could go with 1 single GSP or about 3 F8's..as far as more common BW puffers go.

As far as FW...You could have about 1 Dwarf Puffer per 5 gallons...I'd go with 10 in that size of a tank. One male and the rest female to cut down on aggression. You might be able to get away with 3 SAPs in that tank as long as you stayed on top of your water changes ect. I wouldn't recommend less than 3 (eventhough I have only two at this time...plan on getting more) SAPs are a schooling fish and will require a bit more dental work than most Puffs...

To be honest it would be much easier if you could check out the Puffer Pedia (ug.php/v/PufferPedia/) and decide what fish you'd enjoy the most..All of us are diff in our opinions on what puffs to keep. And all puffs have their own qualities that we admire. If you could make a list of 5 or so that you'd be interested in we could give you the pros and cons of each fish. The puffer pedia will give you a min tank size and some info on how they should be kept to help you out a bit.

Re: Newbie w/ an issue

Posted: Sat Jan 02, 2010 2:08 am
by LilGreenPuffer
I think if you had 10 DPs, you could have as many as 3 males. Two females or more per one male.

But I absolutely agree that you should look at the PufferPedia! Do think about whether you want one fish or several small ones, if you'd prefer a lurker or a more active fish, and so on.

Re: Newbie w/ an issue

Posted: Sat Jan 02, 2010 2:49 pm
by Myaj
Welcome to the forum!

I'm not a huge fan of dwarf puffers.. sure, they are cute, but they just aren't as interactive as other puffer species. They might not keep 4yr olds entertained very well either, most young boys I know are not impressed by the dwarf puffers, they like the bigger species.

Now, you know Green Spotteds are brackish and need to go marine eventually right? If you are okay with that, I would try to get a single GSP or, if you can find it, a Ceylon (because Ceylons get a tad bit bigger and their colors tend to stay brighter, IME).

If you don't want the full marine option (marine isn't THAT hard if you don't have corals, just need a skimmer and salt.. but water changes have the extra step of mixing the saltwater, which isn't a huge step, but its not nearly as quick as drain 50% and refill like you can do with freshwater), Figure 8 puffers are low brackish and don't need nearly as much salt. 3 of those and some gobies would be a very interesting tank.

Freshwater species are more limited.. as everyone said, browse the Pufferpedia for ideas. Many species are hard to find no matter what, but if you want something freshwater, you probably would have been looking at mail order anyways!

If you do end up buying from Walmart, my advice there is try to find out what day their shipment comes in and buy the puffer that day, get it out of their "system" as soon as possible. If you can be there before they even get it into a tank, even better! Not that I'd ever suggest supporting Walmart's fish section, but if it is all you can find, sometimes you do have to deal with that.

Are there any bigger cities around that you could do a day trip to? Take the boys to a museum or something and stop at a fish store on the way home?

Re: Newbie w/ an issue

Posted: Sat Jan 02, 2010 8:07 pm
by jamkak
Thanks for all of the information. That is some great feedback in regards to their interaction and 4 yr olds and looking at the pufferpedia.

That's interesting that you mention having to go to full marine. That has actually been my biggest issue with bringing my aquarium back up... I've really wanted to go with a saltwater tank, just fish, and would love to have some type of puffer in a saltwater setup. My biggest problem is that it seems that most saltwater forums make it sound like by the time you include a skimmer, live rock, sand, lighting, filtration and everything your into it for an arm and a leg all at once...

I may have to keep reading a little more on the idea of working towards a full saltwater tank. Now you have me wondering with stating saltwater isn't that bad...

I was thinking of upgrading my whisper 30-60 filter to a marineland emporer 400 which says it does all three of the filtration process (mech, bacterial, chemical... I think that's what it said). Would this get me closer to having the right setup for saltwater and puffers?

The next question would be in regards to the sand and rock. If I wanted to start brackish and work my way towards saltwater, what might be the best path? I've seen some of the aquarium sand has "live" sand and didn't know if this is something I could use or if I still needed the "live rock".

Sorry for the random tangent on my original question, but I really have been thinking of saltwater...

Thanks again for all of the information!

-Jeff

Re: Newbie w/ an issue

Posted: Sat Jan 02, 2010 9:55 pm
by busybones
If you get a GSP you wouldn't have to keep him in full marine until he was a bit older...so you'd have some time to get everything together..As far as expenses go...you can pick alot of used stuff up from craigslist and save tons of money. I purchased my Skimmer for like $35 and I've seen live rock for less than a $1 a pound! With GSPs you shouldn't have to worry too much about special lighting since they aren't really reaf safe fish.

Re: Newbie w/ an issue

Posted: Sat Jan 02, 2010 10:08 pm
by Myaj
Well, that's perfect then!

Yes, there is a lot of initial cost up front when going marine, but you can space that out. GSP's like higher brackish levels and we're finding they do pretty well going full marine at a younger age, but by starting out brackish it will save you some money now.

For substrate, get argonite sand.. don't worry about the "live" stuff. This will be fine for freshwater and later for marine.

So, your big expenses with marine are the skimmer (get a good one) and live rock. The skimmer you don't need until your salinty gets up to full marine, which can be right away if you want or a year or two down the road.

The live rock, same thing, it only lives in full marine. But what you can do now is, design the tank and do your main rockwork with what they call "dead rock". Its just some dry, bare rock that is very porous. Its still not cheap (you buy it by the pound so try to pick out lightweight pieces), but its way less than "live" rock (which has been in an established aquairum and has lots of good bugs, bacteria and other organisms living on it already). By using the dead rock, you are using the right type of very porous rock that bacteria likes to live in.. and then later, when you do go full marine, you just add a few smaller chunks of live rock and the little "bugs" will spread out and inhabit your "dead" rock, along with the bacteria that's already established.. and after a few months, all that "dead" rock is now nicely seeded "live" rock.

The lighting isn't that important in a saltwater tank, if you don't have corals. And puffers like to nip at corals, so you're pretty good there too. I actually had a good lighting system on my 75 and was growing macroalgae (saltwater version of live plants) when my light shorted out. I haven't had the $$ to replace it, and all my algae died off, but the only other negative thing I've seen is all my coraline algae has also disappeared. Hasn't seem to hurt the tank, water quality is still good, its just not as pretty I guess. I'm still keeping a small area lit up with a small light to keep my little bit of mushrooms, etc happy. But overall, ifyou aren't trying to grow corals, you won't need fancy lighting.

So sure, there you go.. that will work just fine and by waiting to go full marine, you can spread out your expenses. If you do want corals, there are some types that puffers tend to leave alone (mushrooms, leathers, etc) but there''s never a guarantee.

Re: Newbie w/ an issue

Posted: Mon Jan 04, 2010 1:12 am
by jamkak
Oh where were some of these sites and forums 9-10 years ago... :) I always wondered how that pleco died when I had a couple of GSP in the tank... :shock:

Anyways, so in looking at the three (Fig 8, GSP and the Ceylon), I do have to say I like the look of the ceylon. Maybe because it seems like a cross between the fig 8 and a GSP, but that might just be me...

In regards to the Ceylon and having to go towards full marine. I don't have a problem with just having one fish in the tank, but was wondering if my 45g might not be big enough. The reason I say that is the specs seems to make the ceylon get up to 8". My tank is 36" long, 24" high and 12" deep. Seems like if I was an 8" fish it wouldn't be that much fun turning around in 12" of space... Would a GSP be a better choice, or am I over thinking this?

I do like the idea of working towards a marine system and starting with some dry rock. Based on some of the reading, I was thinking of trying to find about 40lbs of sand and 40lbs of dry rock. I figure when the time came, I could add another 5 or so pounds of live rock and be at the 1lb per gallon... But with this idea, I read that in having to "seed" the dry rock with live, that I would need to remove the fish during the seeding while the tank cycles? And some sites claimed up to 4 weeks for the cycle. Am I misreading something or what would be the process?

I found a site that seems like a decent deal and thought I would see what everyone's opinion might be:

http://www.marcorocks.com/index.asp?Pag ... &ProdID=62

Shipping was only around $25 so it didn't seem like too bad of a deal for both sand and dry rock...

Thanks again!

-Jeff

Re: Newbie w/ an issue

Posted: Mon Jan 04, 2010 1:40 am
by Myaj
No, those are good points. We usually suggest 40 gallons for a ceylon, but 12" front to back does not give them a lot of turning room at all. Its best to give the fish 1 1/2 times their body length as a minimum, or they can end up with spinal deformities, etc... So for a fish that can get up to 8", you'd want 12".. close, but could be done. Too bad its a tall tank, the wider ones give so much more swimming room.

I'm not sure what to tell you on this one.. personally, I think I would go for it, since puffers are more of a hover and manuver like a helicopter type of fish, not a dart around and swim in the currrent type of fish.. but if you don't feel comfortable with it, the GSP or some Figure 8 puffs are still a good option. Keep in mind though, I really, really like ceylons ;) so I'm a bit biased.

Re: Newbie w/ an issue

Posted: Mon Jan 04, 2010 3:14 am
by Pufferpunk
I think what folks are telling you is you have a few years yet to figure out everything you'll need to get for SW for these guys, if you start with a juvenile.