Page 1 of 2

Crushed Coral Substrate Okay for FW?

Posted: Thu Dec 31, 2009 7:35 pm
by L!$A
The title pretty much says it all.. my bf has a connection for some free crushed coral substrate, and I was just curious if it is safe for my puffer!
I know that it will raise pH.. but other than that is there any other effects that may change a FW tank??

Re: Crushed Coral Substrate Okay for FW?

Posted: Thu Dec 31, 2009 8:40 pm
by marksrush
Lake Tanganyika is a high alkalinity body of water, so your Mbu would probably like it, and your Texas cichlid can tolerate a wide range of pHs, so go for it if you want. If it's an already established tank, I'd change it out slowly though - if you remove all your gravel at once and replace it with crushed coral, not only are you going to remove tons of good bacteria, but you're going to raise the pH a little quicker than you should.

Re: Crushed Coral Substrate Okay for FW?

Posted: Thu Dec 31, 2009 8:47 pm
by rengnath
marksrush wrote:Lake Tanganyika is a high alkalinity body of water, so your Mbu would probably like it, and your Texas cichlid can tolerate a wide range of pHs, so go for it if you want. If it's an already established tank, I'd change it out slowly though - if you remove all your gravel at once and replace it with crushed coral, not only are you going to remove tons of good bacteria, but you're going to raise the pH a little quicker than you should.
I had white gravel in my tank before I used crushed coral so I just mixed mine in a handful at a time. I rinsed it alot, but when I added even a small amount of crushed coral it still clouded the water. I just left it though, and within about 48 hours the dust settles. Dont even bother doing water changes, as it just stirs up any dust up more. The coral works as a great buffer though, and its is supposed to provide a great bed for benifical bacterial.

Re: Crushed Coral Substrate Okay for FW?

Posted: Thu Dec 31, 2009 8:58 pm
by J-P
free is never bad unless it is used ;)

Re: Crushed Coral Substrate Okay for FW?

Posted: Thu Dec 31, 2009 9:10 pm
by L!$A
lol not too sure if he had used it or not.. but either way I will be washing it throughly!!
Thanks for the advice everyone!! :D

Re: Crushed Coral Substrate Okay for FW?

Posted: Thu Dec 31, 2009 10:17 pm
by rengnath
J-P wrote:free is never bad unless it is used ;)
Agreed! Nothing is worse that someone elses mess!

Re: Crushed Coral Substrate Okay for FW?

Posted: Thu Dec 31, 2009 10:31 pm
by Pufferpunk
It will raise your pH to around 8. That's much higher than neutral, 7.2.

Re: Crushed Coral Substrate Okay for FW?

Posted: Thu Dec 31, 2009 10:32 pm
by L!$A
That is my main concern.. Kaleeko is used to about 7-7.5 at the highest ..
Will this affect him? If so I'm not even going to bother!

Re: Crushed Coral Substrate Okay for FW?

Posted: Thu Dec 31, 2009 10:33 pm
by J-P
I am re-cycling my old pool filter sand ... yes it is a mess...

peanuts .. bird poop .. all sorts of stuff in there.. and I have a lot of it. It would be easier to buy it.. but being as stubborn as I am ... it is at least 2~4 weeks away from being usable at my current schedule.

Re: Crushed Coral Substrate Okay for FW?

Posted: Thu Dec 31, 2009 10:40 pm
by Pufferpunk
I don't think i'd use it, Lisa.

Re: Crushed Coral Substrate Okay for FW?

Posted: Thu Dec 31, 2009 10:42 pm
by L!$A
Fair enough!

Now.. what about this pool filtered sand I hear? Can you get it at pretty much any pet store or more like a special pool store? lol
I would like to try a somewhat sandy substrate to see if Kaleeko likes to burrow or not.. or at least something soft for his tummy to rest on!

Re: Crushed Coral Substrate Okay for FW?

Posted: Thu Dec 31, 2009 10:42 pm
by rengnath
Good things take time J-P. I believe the saying "patience is a virtue" come in to play here. Unfortunatly, thats a virtue we dont always have.

I have crushed coral in my tank and my PH is lingering around 8.4 ... I also have salt so that most likely made it go up to that 8.4 range instead of 8.

I just saw it posted here though, that most fish can adapt to the wrong PH. If it was done slowly, could a Mbu adapt to a PH of 8?

Re: Crushed Coral Substrate Okay for FW?

Posted: Thu Dec 31, 2009 10:43 pm
by L!$A
I'm not sure.. but I'm not really willing to try.. I would be DEVASTATED if i lost Kaleeko...

Re: Crushed Coral Substrate Okay for FW?

Posted: Thu Dec 31, 2009 10:48 pm
by rengnath
L!$A wrote:I'm not sure.. but I'm not really willing to try.. I would be DEVASTATED if i lost Kaleeko...
Kaleeko is way to awesome to risk it. I would probably lean towards the ph up/down buffers even though it would be much easier just to have a natural buffer that does it for you.

How big is he?

Re: Crushed Coral Substrate Okay for FW?

Posted: Thu Dec 31, 2009 10:52 pm
by L!$A
Thank you!! hehe .. & For sure, we buffer the water every time we do a water change.. and test it about 2-4 times a week, really depending on how busy we are!
We also add a bit of stress coat just because none of our fishies really like water changes.. I don't blame them! lol

I remember the first time I cleaned one of our tanks and I forgot to put a pH buffer in there.. and the pH was far too low (thank god it wasn't Kaleeko's tank)
The fish didn't die, but still. It was a pretty big mistake on my part!
But I know people who never add buffers.. and I don't know maybe fish can adapt to a lower or higher pH??

He's about 6-7 inches roughly?
Round as heck!
I'll go take a pic right now actually....