Page 1 of 2
Feeder Fish and piscivores
Posted: Thu Dec 31, 2009 3:01 pm
by darb
I keep reading that you shouldn't be feeding your fish feeders, yet in the wild the piscivores main diet is probably fish.
This is a bit of a contradiction isn't it?
I have also read that guppies are more nutritious, any comments?
Re: Feeder Fish and piscivores
Posted: Thu Dec 31, 2009 3:04 pm
by bigfatfish
As I understood, most of the comments have been about people who feed fish to normally non-piscivore puffs.
Re: Feeder Fish and piscivores
Posted: Thu Dec 31, 2009 3:23 pm
by L!$A
From what I have heard, goldfish feeders, are terrible.
Guppies are better than goldfish
& White cloud minnows are the best.. as far as I have heard
Don't hold that to me though!
We feed most of our fish White clouds.. they're very expensive. About $25 for 50
But we do not feed our puffer any feeder fish.. just snails, crayfish, tiger prawn, king worms & krill.
He'll get the odd feeder here and there, but it definately is not his staple in his diet
Re: Feeder Fish and piscivores
Posted: Thu Dec 31, 2009 3:30 pm
by eieio
"ollie" gets "home grown" guppies occasionally, but really prefers other foods, like crickets, earthworms, and shrimp
Re: Feeder Fish and piscivores
Posted: Thu Dec 31, 2009 4:00 pm
by riggers
The problem is that many feeder fish carry some sort of disease with them which then gets passed on to your puffer (or other fish). Have a look at the article in the library about them, should clear things up.
library/feeding/feeders/
Re: Feeder Fish and piscivores
Posted: Thu Dec 31, 2009 4:05 pm
by Myaj
Definitely read the article, it sums a lot of it up.
Commercial feeders are full of diseases.. if you do want to feed your piscivores feeders breed your own, and stick to the more healthy types like liverbearers (no goldfish or anything with sharp, spiky fins that can get caught).
For what its worth, most of us find our piscivores do just fine on a diet of raw shrimp and the ocassional "live" treat of earthworms, crickets, live shrimp, etc.
Re: Feeder Fish and piscivores
Posted: Sun Jan 03, 2010 2:57 pm
by Dadof4
I feed home bread mollies for an occasional treat but like MyaJ says, my piscavores get by on shrimp and nightcrawlers. I like to give them the chance to hunt and stimulate that natural instinct. The mollies I feed are very healthy and are fed high quality food to keep them that way.
Re: Feeder Fish and piscivores
Posted: Sun Jan 03, 2010 5:28 pm
by marksrush
Not all feeders are riddled with disease and unfit for your fish. We get ours from a guy who does them locally, we keep them in cold RO/DI, do partial (1/3) water changes every other day, and we have never once had someone come back and tell us our feeders made their fish sick - and since we sell tons of them, we'd hear it if there was a problem and people wouldn't come back time and time again. So maybe if you look around you'll be lucky and find a good source if you absolutely need live feeder fish for your piscivore puffers, because there are good sources out there.
Re: Feeder Fish and piscivores
Posted: Sun Jan 03, 2010 8:56 pm
by Myaj
Good luck though finding a store that doesn't just ship them in by the hundreds.. a lot of our local stores won't even buy from local people, it violates their contract with their main suppliers.
Re: Feeder Fish and piscivores
Posted: Sun Jan 03, 2010 10:56 pm
by Pufferpunk
There is still the Thiamine problem & them being too fatty of a diet.
Re: Feeder Fish and piscivores
Posted: Sun Jan 03, 2010 11:41 pm
by OCgatergal
What are the benefits of feeding feeder fish?
Re: Feeder Fish and piscivores
Posted: Mon Jan 04, 2010 12:34 am
by Dadof4
Pufferpunk wrote:There is still the Thiamine problem & them being too fatty of a diet.
That does become an issue if you feed them regularly but if they are used as an occasional treat it's not that large of a problem. Once every few months isn't a big deal, repeated feeding is. After reading some previous posts I did a little deeper digging in to Thiaminase (the main problem from feeding feeder fish) and it's effects. Thiaminase is an enzyme that breaks thiamine in to usable molecular parts. Build up of thiminase by consuming foods that are high in it, has been shown to cause nervous system disorders by depleting the amount of thiamine in the body (this was found incidentally back in the 1940's and they are still finding more about it). This can happen in mamals as well as in fish by either not consuming enough thiamine or by keeping a diet high in thiaminase. The easy solution is to use vitamin supplements that contain vitamin B1 to give the thiaminase something additional to use. Most of the Selcon vitamins contain B1.
This is no means an advocation to feed "feeder" fish as a staple in the diet. Getting feeders from most LFS is a bad practice (may have to take a trip to see Marksrush) due to disease and what they were fed prior to becoming a snack. I feel that occasionally stimulating the natural instinct to hunt in my obligate piscavores has greatly increased their well being, they're more alert and more active for weeks after and they become more aggressive towards their pre-killed, safer food.
Re: Feeder Fish and piscivores
Posted: Mon Jan 04, 2010 1:22 am
by darb
Dadof4 wrote:
This is no means an advocation to feed "feeder" fish as a staple in the diet. Getting feeders from most LFS is a bad practice (may have to take a trip to see Marksrush) due to disease and what they were fed prior to becoming a snack. I feel that occasionally stimulating the natural instinct to hunt in my obligate piscavores has greatly increased their well being, they're more alert and more active for weeks after and they become more aggressive towards their pre-killed, safer food.
Exactly, I was just looking for supplemental treats for both the fish and myself. I put dozen white clouds in with my dragon puffer before I left for Xmas and that evening I got to see a really interesting aspect of his behaviour that I hadn't seen yet. No longer was he coming to the glass begging, but lurking amongst the plants trying to sneak up on the school without getting noticed, hiding behind a couple of val leaves figuring that he was camouflaged, all part of the reason that I got him! By morning there was only one white cloud left.
It's not exactly natural behaviour to be feeding freeze dried food or pellets, and the occasional feeder helps to provide an overall better environment for the fish IMHO.
Re: Feeder Fish and piscivores
Posted: Mon Jan 04, 2010 1:51 am
by Myaj
You were going to snack on them yourself?? LOL sorry I couldn't resist...
My turgidus still lurks and "hunts".. half the time I'm yelling at him to hurry up and "kill" his shrimp because I'm tired of holding it for him.
I used to keep a few endlers that I'd bred in with him.. they got in there by accident. They lived for months and months.. but occassionally one would go missing, then another, then another.. eventually no more endlers.
Re: Feeder Fish and piscivores
Posted: Mon Jan 04, 2010 3:08 am
by Pufferpunk
What about the problem with what's missing when you feed FW feeders to SW fish?