Page 1 of 1
Cycling-worse case scenario
Posted: Wed Dec 16, 2009 12:51 pm
by shagy382
HI guys, i just want to clarify one final thing about cycling,
If you are cycling the water with fish inside, and everything is new including the tank, water, filters, the plants, the rocks. Basically i am unable to obtain any filter or stuff from healthy tanks or fish shops. So the question is where do the nitrifying bacteria come from?Are those bacteria present in all water but at low levels?
And in fishelss cycling, is it a MUST to have a source of bacteria introduced externally into the water? or can i just spike up the ammonia content and the bacteria would increase faster.
Last question is whether anyone has used Nitromax marine before.
http://freshnmarine.com.sg/estore/produ ... ts_id=2251

thanks for reading
Re: Cycling-worse case scenario
Posted: Wed Dec 16, 2009 1:28 pm
by Iliveinazoo
shagy382 wrote:HI guys, i just want to clarify one final thing about cycling,
If you are cycling the water with fish inside, and everything is new including the tank, water, filters, the plants, the rocks. Basically i am unable to obtain any filter or stuff from healthy tanks or fish shops. So the question is where do the nitrifying bacteria come from?Are those bacteria present in all water but at low levels?
And in fishelss cycling, is it a MUST to have a source of bacteria introduced externally into the water? or can i just spike up the ammonia content and the bacteria would increase faster.
Last question is whether anyone has used Nitromax marine before.
http://freshnmarine.com.sg/estore/produ ... ts_id=2251

thanks for reading
If you are cycling with fish then I would suggest doing large water changes daily, you will still be unnecessarily hurting, damaging and potentially killing the fish though.
Bacteria will develop without a need to add anything, an ammonia source is required though. Some manufacturers do 'live' bacteria which can seemingly be added at the same time as the fish without cycling however I can't make myself trust it.
Never used Nitromax.
Re: Cycling-worse case scenario
Posted: Wed Dec 16, 2009 1:49 pm
by DarkStorm
http://www.aquarium-supply.biz/ProductD ... e=RMW00033
works like a charm, similar products to this before ya buy "if plan on it" check to see if it needs to be refrigerated / if so is.
Re: Cycling-worse case scenario
Posted: Wed Dec 16, 2009 2:29 pm
by riggers
shagy382 wrote:If you are cycling the water with fish inside, and everything is new including the tank, water, filters, the plants, the rocks. Basically i am unable to obtain any filter or stuff from healthy tanks or fish shops. So the question is where do the nitrifying bacteria come from?Are those bacteria present in all water but at low levels?
You need a source of bacteria to get the process going. If the plants you have are live then they may carry some of the bacteria on them. Is the rock dry dead stuff? But otherwise the bacteria won't be in your tap water seeing as that will have been treated to kill bacteria.
Re: Cycling-worse case scenario
Posted: Wed Dec 16, 2009 3:51 pm
by bigfatfish
Technically, you don't need a source of bacteria. I fishlessed cycled without bacteria - it just took longer - about a month. I would never cycle with fish in, but I understand you can use Tetra Safestart & add fish immediately - although there are varied reports on its efficacy.
Re: Cycling-worse case scenario
Posted: Wed Dec 16, 2009 3:54 pm
by LilGreenPuffer
NItrifying bacteria is present in the air (in small quantities) and in fish poo. Fishless with bacteria source is fastest; with fish is second; finally, it is still possible to cycle a tank with just an ammonia source, but it takes too long to be remotely worth it. The bacteria from the air will be drawn to the ammonia in the tank, but it'll take f-o-r-e-v-e-r to build up a good-sized colony.
If you don't have a bacteria source, you can get it from the fish poo. It'll just take a while. Do daily water changes and keep ammonia and nitrites below .25ppm.
Re: Cycling-worse case scenario
Posted: Wed Dec 16, 2009 4:53 pm
by pufferpuggirl
I would be very wary of trusting Tetra SafeStart .... it may have been a good product at one time, but I don't think it works any more, but that's just my opinion.
You could try a JBL product called Denitrol, or Filterstart, as they both have beneficial bacteria in them and I've used both.
Re: Cycling-worse case scenario
Posted: Wed Dec 16, 2009 7:58 pm
by Pufferpunk
That stuff is garbage:
Bacter Boost provides a
growth medium
Boosts the biological
No live bacteria in there at all.
Re: Cycling-worse case scenario
Posted: Thu Dec 17, 2009 1:23 pm
by Iliveinazoo
LilGreenPuffer wrote:NItrifying bacteria is present in the air (in small quantities) and in fish poo. Fishless with bacteria source is fastest; with fish is second; finally, it is still possible to cycle a tank with just an ammonia source, but it takes too long to be remotely worth it. The bacteria from the air will be drawn to the ammonia in the tank, but it'll take f-o-r-e-v-e-r to build up a good-sized colony.
If you don't have a bacteria source, you can get it from the fish poo. It'll just take a while. Do daily water changes and keep ammonia and nitrites below .25ppm.
As someone stated in another post - it'll take about a month if you only add ammonia and don't add a 'live' bacteria source. Since there aren't many decent or reliable 'live' bacteria sources out there then it is a very good method of cycling a tank. 'Dead' bacteria sources will do nothing but add to the ammonia level.
Patience is a virtue you can take the time to research what fish you would like to keep while your tank cycles.
Re: Cycling-worse case scenario
Posted: Thu Dec 17, 2009 3:46 pm
by LilGreenPuffer
As someone stated in another post
Oops, I didn't see that post.
