Page 1 of 1

Many fish keepers are unaware of cycling

Posted: Fri Dec 11, 2009 3:42 am
by shagy382
Hey guys, i recently took up the hobby of rearing fish and i been reading this forum extensively, learning all the cycling stuff and brackish water. Yet i realise that i have a few friends who have been keeping fish for ages and they dont even know wats water cycling all about..i told him that i had to change the water 90% a day because my fish were in an uncycled tank and he said that i should not do that as it will destabilise the chlorine in the water...he doesnt even know wats ammonia and nitrate.

Another one claims that i should put in some medication and put the tank under sunlight and the tank will be cycled in like 4-5 days. Another one claims that the ammonia will naturally react with the water to form a salt which is harmless to fish. Any he says that the ammonia is toxic to the fish because it changes the pH of the water which kills the fish...THen when you try to explain the cycling stuff to them, they just try to dis it off and confirm that their theory is right

Any of these theories make sense?

What im guessing is that many people 'naturally' cycle their tanks without realising it and just take the death of a a fish as due to dirty water or infection..the thought of high ammonias n nitrate never occur to them. Then as more and more fish die and the days go by, the water slowly gets cycled by itself and the fish start doing well..

Do you guys have any friends like that? :?

Re: Many fish keepers are unaware of cycling

Posted: Fri Dec 11, 2009 3:45 am
by Pufferpunk
Those are the most ridiculous theories I've ever heard in my 30+ years of fishkeeping & I've heard it all!

Re: Many fish keepers are unaware of cycling

Posted: Fri Dec 11, 2009 3:59 am
by shagy382
Pufferpunk wrote:Those are the most ridiculous theories I've ever heard in my 30+ years of fishkeeping & I've heard it all!
Yup i decided to just stop trying to advice them and just do my own thing :D anyway puffer punk i really like that puffer of yours..its a congo puffer right? too bad i cant get these kinda fish in my area :(

down here, its only GSPs and Fig 8s

Re: Many fish keepers are unaware of cycling

Posted: Fri Dec 11, 2009 5:29 am
by LilGreenPuffer
You know what really amuses/saddens me? When people think that you should clean a tank to get rid of algae, because algae makes them sick. The dangerous dirt is invisible...

Re: Many fish keepers are unaware of cycling

Posted: Fri Dec 11, 2009 6:06 am
by trekenk
LilGreenPuffer wrote:You know what really amuses/saddens me? When people think that you should clean a tank to get rid of algae, because algae makes them sick. .
This reminds me of something that happened to me. The boyfriend and I own an aquarium maintenance company. One of the tanks we look after is a 125gl salt water aquarium in a bingo hall. You have to realize that no one looks after this tank except us and we go in once a week. Everything is on timers, food feeder and lights. Because it is on an automatic fish feeder we like that there is a bit of algae in the tank for the fish to graze on. One of the patrons from the bingo hall phone the human society because there was algae in the tank and they were under the impression the tank was dirty and we were being cruel to the fish.

Re: Many fish keepers are unaware of cycling

Posted: Fri Dec 11, 2009 7:04 am
by pufferpuggirl
Well I have to say that years ago, when I kept a tropical tank in Florida, I had no idea about cycling, nitrites and all that. I remember that every week I would "clean" the tank by removing all the decorations and washing them under the tap. No wonder I couldn't keep any fish alive. And I never did water changes. But the funny thing is that no one ever asked me about those things. I used to go to a fish store and buy fish from them all the time. The fish would die and I'd go back and buy more. Now, I know that most shops just want to make money, but you'd think that there'd be one or two people who cared enough to ask about my tank. I wish someone had, as I was clueless back then. And of course that was before the internet was commonly available to everyone. I feel sorry for all the fish I killed stumbling along like I did. :(

In regards to your friends shagy382, I think they just don't want to admit that you know something they don't. People usually "dis" something when they don't know about it and don't want to admit they don't know. But you are doing the right thing, and in the end, they will see that what you are saying is the truth because your tank is going to prove it. So keep on doing the right thing. :D

Re: Many fish keepers are unaware of cycling

Posted: Fri Dec 11, 2009 7:22 am
by soggydrysuit
Well, I've 'kept' fish since I was six or rather my dad did for me.

Trouble was his idea of a water change was to strip the two 25g tanks we had down twice a year and wash everything under the tap! His idea of undergravel and later power filters was that any and all waste was 'destroyed by bacterial action'. He just wouldn't listen to anything I said.

I kept a piranha for ten years from about age ten to twenty and one boxing day when it was about five inches long - he had it in a net to clean the tank out and it removed part of his plam... !

Re: Many fish keepers are unaware of cycling

Posted: Fri Dec 11, 2009 7:47 am
by pufferpuggirl
When I started keeping puffers ... I felt like I went through an epiphany. I read as much as I could about cycling and tanks on the internet. I subscribed to a magazine about fishkeeping (PFK), and I just tried to learn as much as I possibly could because I was so motivated by having this one little dwarf puffer (soon after to be about 5 of them!). It just seems odd to me now to think that I didn't ever "get" how tanks work and why my fish kept dying. It's a wonder, looking back, that I was able to keep anything alive in that tank! But I'm glad I'm no longer an ignorant person (at least not totally ignorant), and I know I try to do the best for all my puffers and my other fish too. It's a very rewarding hobby, probably one of the best I've been involved in. I used to be a keen gardener, back in Florida, thing is, over here, there isn't much of a growing season, and not only that, but plants can be expensive, and there's no guarantee that they will stay alive. With fishkeeping, it doesn't matter what the weather is like, I can play with my tanks any time of day, any time of the year! :D

Re: Many fish keepers are unaware of cycling

Posted: Fri Dec 11, 2009 10:02 am
by soggydrysuit
Totally aside, I've a tree fern from NZ. It lives outside during the summer and manages to survive the wind which they hate. This year I'd left it long enough for the fronds to die off, so I cut them off and brought it in. The things re-growing all of it's fronds again which I found amazing because it's in a cold conservatory at maybe 10C.

I don't give it fertiliser, it gets the dirty water from my fw tank filter cleaning. And waste fw tankwater. Amazing what plec and pacu poo can do :lol:

I'll end up with an eight foot wide monster in there again this year :)

Re: Many fish keepers are unaware of cycling

Posted: Fri Dec 11, 2009 11:26 am
by PolishPuff
My first tank set up was done years ago, at the store when purchasing 29 gal kit, I was pushed by the store employee to buy fish right away ( of course I had no idea what cycling was ) With no problem I've pick few fish that were one week guaranteed by the store. Of course fish were dieing and I was exchanging them ones a week total on six fish till the tank cycle slowly. I think cuz of that not experience employee store was losing money. Now with my knowledge and experience if only I could go back in time, that store employee would be in trouble. :badboy:

Re: Many fish keepers are unaware of cycling

Posted: Fri Dec 11, 2009 12:05 pm
by Flutter
Wow, I got my first tank around age 12 (10 years ago, wow). I knew about cycling and I've only ever lost a fish due to a disease, old age, or heater malfunction (or them being really young, lost 3 plecos like that which my mom bought). Never lost a fish during cycling and I knew about cycling before I got my first tank. I didn't have test kits however I made sure to change the water every day and I would gradually slow down the water changes.

Haha, I kind of feel like a geek because I knew it all first...

Re: Many fish keepers are unaware of cycling

Posted: Fri Dec 11, 2009 11:41 pm
by OCgatergal
age=wisdom..thats my excuse.
I have taken over the fish in the house when I was 8 and it was till 6 years later till I heard the words cycling a tank (although I have to say, none of my fish died because of no cycling) , when I first heard it I thought it mean to let it sit for 2 days.
I doubt the general public has heard of cycling a tank and it won't be until the keeper buys some fish books or does hard core research online. Most people get a fish tank kit, read the manual (which has nothing about cycling) and add fish.
Who can blame them though? we all did that at one point