Page 1 of 2

Fishless Cycling and Oxygen?

Posted: Mon Nov 16, 2009 11:31 pm
by MachMe
During my fishless cycling do I need to change out the water? I am in day 2 of the cycle and I have no fish just live plants. I'm trying to do everything right before I go out and buy some puffers.

Also, my inherited tank came with a cheap aquatech 10-20 filter. It's getting the job done for my 20 gallon but do I need to upgrade the filtration or add something like a bubbler wand to provide more oxygen? Is a filter a sufficient source of oxygen? I dont want to spend the money on a bubbler or powerhead if I dont have to.

The guys at my LFS told me this was sufficient and that a bubbler would piss off my puffer more than anything.

Thanks!

Re: Fishless Cycling and Oxygen?

Posted: Mon Nov 16, 2009 11:38 pm
by busybones
The guys at the LFS were wrong...The bubbler should help out alot. You may want to look into getting an upgrade for your filter soon. I'm a fan of the Penguins but to each their own. Just be careful not to make the current too strong for them. And remember that puffers require extra filtration so keep that in mind while shopping around!

What type of Puffers are you getting?

Re: Fishless Cycling and Oxygen?

Posted: Mon Nov 16, 2009 11:41 pm
by Jivenjune
I don't use a bubbler in my 60 gallon. My filter and protein skimmer seem to produce enough oxygen. I've actually put away all the air pumps I have in storage since I don't see the value of them unless I were to be doing some kinda medicated treatment where the additional oxygen would probably help a lot more. Most air pumps just make too much noise--can't sleep with em on.

Re: Fishless Cycling and Oxygen?

Posted: Mon Nov 16, 2009 11:46 pm
by busybones
'' Most air pumps just make too much noise--can't sleep with em on.''

I agree, that's why I puchased some more expensive ones..aaaahhhh silence~

Re: Fishless Cycling and Oxygen?

Posted: Mon Nov 16, 2009 11:48 pm
by MachMe
busybones wrote:The guys at the LFS were wrong...The bubbler should help out alot. You may want to look into getting an upgrade for your filter soon. I'm a fan of the Penguins but to each their own. Just be careful not to make the current too strong for them. And remember that puffers require extra filtration so keep that in mind while shopping around!

What type of Puffers are you getting?
I plan on upgrading my filter to a aquaclear or marineland that cycles 200gph once I get my puffers as I know overfiltration is best. Do you guys think this will provide suffiecient oxygen to my tank? I dont want to do bubblers if its not necessary.

Just one F8 and maybe a couple bumblebee gobies.

Re: Fishless Cycling and Oxygen?

Posted: Mon Nov 16, 2009 11:53 pm
by LilGreenPuffer
I think a bubble is only necessary when you're using a low-flow filter or when the temp is high.

Re: Fishless Cycling and Oxygen?

Posted: Mon Nov 16, 2009 11:56 pm
by Jivenjune
Yep, an AquaClear should be more than sufficient. I got an AquaClear 70 in a community cichlid tank; I have never seen fish ever gasp for air or indicate that there was some type of issue with the oxygen level in the water. Bubblers are pretty. and the strong ones do create some water movement while increasing oxygen, I just prefer to spend my money on other stuff... like marine salt... sigh. Salt really does end up costing me a lot of money... I really need a second job to support this hobby :/

Re: Fishless Cycling and Oxygen?

Posted: Mon Nov 16, 2009 11:57 pm
by busybones
I can't tell you for sure if they are considered necessary or if you'll have enough oxygen in the tank with the filtration system. I've always used them and thought the pros out weighted the cons...

F8's are really cool!

Re: Fishless Cycling and Oxygen?

Posted: Tue Nov 17, 2009 12:05 am
by Eager Newbie
Do puffers enjoy air stones? Will they "play" in them? Would be fun to watch XD

Re: Fishless Cycling and Oxygen?

Posted: Tue Nov 17, 2009 12:10 am
by Jivenjune
Eager Newbie wrote:Do puffers enjoy air stones? Will they "play" in them? Would be fun to watch XD
I have a strong bubbler in my saltwater tank that I periodically turn on to create a little more water flow. Sometimes, I'll see my fat GSPs stomach just covered in bubbles. Makes me laugh. I've also seen him swim within them while trying to push against the current it creates. He seems to be having fun?

Re: Fishless Cycling and Oxygen?

Posted: Tue Nov 17, 2009 12:13 am
by Eager Newbie
I think it would be cool to pull a finding nemo and have a volcano with bubbles pouring out of it! XD

Re: Fishless Cycling and Oxygen?

Posted: Tue Nov 17, 2009 12:19 am
by MachMe
Ha ha! That would be cool. Ok now what about the water changes. In the article it doesnt mention to do any til the end. Should I be or just wait til its fully cycled?

Also, if I do buy a new filter will it hurt my bacteria colonies since it wont be an established filter. Im thinking it will just get build up and bacteria in it immediately.

Re: Fishless Cycling and Oxygen?

Posted: Tue Nov 17, 2009 12:21 am
by robert_hollis
I see my SAPs swim in the bubbles from my bubbler fairly often.

-Rob

Re: Fishless Cycling and Oxygen?

Posted: Tue Nov 17, 2009 12:36 am
by Eager Newbie
Bacteria builds up in your substrate, filter, and on any decor or plants you might have. If you buy a new filter just throw the old filter sponge into your new filter for awhile.
Water changes during cycling probably won't inhibit the bacteria, as it isn't located in the water itself.
If you have no fish, there is no reason to change the water. If, for instance, you do have fish and the tank isn't fully cycled, water should be changed everyday.

Re: Fishless Cycling and Oxygen?

Posted: Tue Nov 17, 2009 2:09 am
by LilGreenPuffer
It's kind of pointless to change the water during a cycle. It will actually slow it down. You'd be removing the ammonia and nitrite, the bacteria's food, from the water, which prevents their growth.