Page 1 of 1

Some Cycling Qs for my 20gal

Posted: Fri Nov 13, 2009 2:43 am
by MachMe
Hey guys and gals!

I have a new tank that I am cycling. Currently in the tank is:
1) 1 Calcium Rock.
2) Fine Black substrate.
3) 4 live plants that look like large grass blades (not sure the correct name).
4) All necessary operating equipment.

I tried cycling for 2 days with bio-spira and added 5 tablespoons of marine salt total. Marine salt was added to the last bucket and dissolved well. I had my LFS test the water and nitrites were to high. I was told to do 25% WC every other day adding cycle for a week and it should be ready to go.

Now I am cycling by dechlorinating my water and adding cycle. Both products are made by nutrafin. I have access to filter media from a stable tank that houses ottos, angel fish, and tetras. I saw the tank and all the fish look healthy and so does the tank. The tank is a friend of mines and he said I can come pick up a used filter from him to help the cycling process of my tank. My questions are as follows:

Is it okay to use this filter from his tank to help cycle my tank. Also how do I transport the filter? In water, no water, treated water etc.

Do I just place the filter in my tank for a bit? Dip it in once?

Since my tank could be housing F8's I know I need a S.G. of 1.005-1.008. Do I mix this in when I am doing the water changes or when I bring the F8's home? Will it kill my bacteria if I use my friends existing filter media?

Sorry for the abundance of questions but I am cautious and want to make sure my puffers are well treated and happy in their new home. Still havent decided on DPs or F8. I know DPs are freshwater.

Thanks in advance for the help!

Re: Some Cycling Qs for my 20gal

Posted: Fri Nov 13, 2009 3:17 am
by LilGreenPuffer
Bio-Spira doesn't work unless the SG is at least 1.010. Cycle doesn't work. Tetra SafeStart works, though.

Your friend's filter bacteria will die in this water, and in any water with a SG greater than 1.002. My suggestion: You should start with fresh water, add a used filter cartridge from your friend's tank to your filter, and cycle it like that. Then you can get the fish - they're usually in FW at the store anyway, and a couple more weeks won't hurt it. Now begin raising the SG by .002 per week until you're at the right level.

Re: Some Cycling Qs for my 20gal

Posted: Fri Nov 13, 2009 3:21 pm
by MachMe
Ok I took my tank down to about 10% water as that was the lowest I could get it. I dechlorinated the water and filled my tank back up.

Im going to try the fishless cycling method I read in the library. So I will use the filter media from my friends tank and buy a bottle of pure ammonia.
Is there anything else? If I throw a piece of shrimp in there while doing this, will it help or act as a contra to what I'm doing?

Re: Some Cycling Qs for my 20gal

Posted: Fri Nov 13, 2009 4:35 pm
by LilGreenPuffer
A piece of shrimp will provide ammonia. But if you have access to pure ammonia (NO additives, scent, etc.), then don't use the shrimp, because you won't be able to measure how much ammonia it will add. Plus, it's messy!

Re: Some Cycling Qs for my 20gal

Posted: Fri Nov 13, 2009 5:15 pm
by pufferpuggirl
If you can get 'Prime' by Seachem it's much better than 'Cycle'. I don't know about the Tetra SafeStart that you get in the US, but I don't believe it works very well over here, I wasn't at all impressed with it. But maybe they aren't exactly the same product.

Re: Some Cycling Qs for my 20gal

Posted: Fri Nov 13, 2009 8:11 pm
by LilGreenPuffer
Prime isn't a cycling product. It's a water conditioner that detoxifies ammonia.

My friend has been having trouble with SafeStart. She's used two whole bottles on a 10g, and it's still not working. The bottles were unsealed - isn't this a problem?

Re: Some Cycling Qs for my 20gal

Posted: Fri Nov 13, 2009 8:45 pm
by MachMe
I got some ammonia and shook the bottle. There was no foam at all but it does say 10%Ammonium Hydroxide. This may be a dumb question but is that ok?

Re: Some Cycling Qs for my 20gal

Posted: Fri Nov 13, 2009 8:46 pm
by LilGreenPuffer
The rest is probably water. Call the company to double-check.

Re: Some Cycling Qs for my 20gal

Posted: Fri Nov 13, 2009 9:54 pm
by MachMe
Ok, I got some verification from doing homework that this is the right stuff. Im going to start the cycle tomorrow. By the way if anyone needs to find ammonia for future fishless cycles, I got mine at ACE hardware store.


Wish me luck! 8)

Re: Some Cycling Qs for my 20gal

Posted: Fri Nov 13, 2009 10:49 pm
by LilGreenPuffer
I think that some other folks got theirs at ACE too. Good luck!

Re: Some Cycling Qs for my 20gal

Posted: Sat Nov 14, 2009 6:41 am
by pufferpuggirl
LilGreenPuffer wrote:Prime isn't a cycling product. It's a water conditioner that detoxifies ammonia.

My friend has been having trouble with SafeStart. She's used two whole bottles on a 10g, and it's still not working. The bottles were unsealed - isn't this a problem?

I know that 'Prime' isn't a "cycling" product ..... but as far as I'm concerned, neither is 'Cycle' by Hagen, but MachMe was saying he was dechlorinating the water, and that's why I brought up 'Prime', as I think it's far better than the products by Hagen.
And as for SafeStart, it may have started off by being a good "bacteria" product, but I didn't see where it was worth the money they were asking for it. The best thing we had here in the UK was Bactinettes, which aren't available anymore from what I understand, although there is a new product out that's taking it's place, but not sure about that either.