Page 1 of 2

Gettin' Started!

Posted: Wed Nov 04, 2009 7:19 pm
by kafkabeetle
So, I went out and bought a cheap Aqueon 10 gal. kit today. I plan for it to become my shrimp/snail breeding tank for a figure 8 puffer in a few months. But I have a few questions.

At our LFS I asked if they could give me an old filter sponge and/or some aquarium water, but they told me the only way to cycle a tank was to add fish. I knew this wasn't totally true, but since they obviously weren't going to help me out, I bought 3 minnows instead. I know from experience that they're incredibly hardy and would live through the cycling process. But my question is, will 3 minnows even be enough to cycle my tank? If not, how do you suggest I do so (cheaply if possible)? I plan to plant the tank, if that matters at all.

I was also curious also if I would be able to use the established snail/shrimp tank water/filter media to cycle the 30ish gallon for the puffer. Would it be as simple as pouring some of the cycled water into the new water in the 30 gal. and using its old filter media for a while? Would it be helpful the transfer the minnows to the 30 gal. during this process? I've done a lot of research of cycling, so I understand the process, but am looking for a more step-by-step advice on physically what to do.

Thanks, folks!

Re: Gettin' Started!

Posted: Wed Nov 04, 2009 7:31 pm
by LilGreenPuffer
Three minnows will not be enough.

Try to get Tetra SafeStart. It's an instant cycling product. Dr. Tim's is good, too. Don't let them talk you into any other brand.

And if they don't have either of those, then ask if you can buy a filter piece anyway. It's no skin off their nose, and they're making money.

The step-by-step instructions are in the Library, under the water/filtration category.

Re: Gettin' Started!

Posted: Wed Nov 04, 2009 7:35 pm
by Jivenjune
If you're going to cycle with those minnows, here are a few tips.

Keep a bottle of prime with you and a box of aquarium salt.

When setting up your tank, increase the salt level to a tolerable level (there is a formula that I can't remember). When your ammonia begins to spike, do a dose of prime to change the ammonia to ammonium. The bacteria will continue to use ammonium as a food source and create additional bacteria. The ammonium is non-toxic to your fish (to a certain extent). Once your nitrites begin to spike up, the aquarium salt will decrease the toxicity of the nitrites. I believe this has something to do with the nitrites competing with the chloride, thus, making the effects of nitrites less toxic to the minnows. The nitrites, however, will still cause problems. At this point, you will have to start doing significant water changes fairly frequently.

As for whether they will cycle your tank, I'm almost 100 percent positive it will. It will just take significantly longer than if you had a larger source of ammonia to feed the bacteria.

Of course, you could forgo all this by returning all the minnows and just tossing a piece of raw shrimp into the filter until the tank cycles appropriately.

Re: Gettin' Started!

Posted: Wed Nov 04, 2009 7:43 pm
by LilGreenPuffer
Sure, they'll cycle the tank, but they won't prepare it for a F8. The bioload isn't comparable.

Re: Gettin' Started!

Posted: Wed Nov 04, 2009 8:15 pm
by Jivenjune
LilGreenPuffer wrote:Sure, they'll cycle the tank, but they won't prepare it for a F8. The bioload isn't comparable.
I thought it was a snail / shrimp breeder tank for an F8?

Re: Gettin' Started!

Posted: Wed Nov 04, 2009 8:18 pm
by LilGreenPuffer
Oh. Yes. Yes, it is.

But actually, since snails are so dirty, it still wouldn't be enough IMO/IME.

Re: Gettin' Started!

Posted: Wed Nov 04, 2009 10:30 pm
by kafkabeetle
Do you think a few snails would live through cycling if I just threw 'em in there and kept an eye on things? I got some Tetra EasyBalance, as it was the only product our LFS sold that seemed remotely similar to the products suggested. If it seems to risky to add snails I'll probably just wait it out.

I was at Wal-Mart to get some gravel earlier and saw a really sad thing. They were selling green spotted puffers as "spotted puffers". There were at least ten of them in a 10 gal. tank and nearly all of them were sort of swimming in place near the bottom. All of them had white crusty spots on them (itch?) and dark gray bellies. Of course they were being sold as fresh water. :-(

Re: Gettin' Started!

Posted: Wed Nov 04, 2009 11:37 pm
by LilGreenPuffer
That's pretty normal for GSPs. Look around a bit more. I guarantee you that 95% of the stores out there mistreat them. And yes, those spots were ich.

Tetra EasyBalance is not an instant cycling product. What does it say on the label?

The snails might live. Why do you want them in there now?

Re: Gettin' Started!

Posted: Thu Nov 05, 2009 1:14 am
by kafkabeetle
Well, I don't want or not want the snails in there now. But unless I've misunderstood it sounds like people are suggesting I don't have a big enough bioload with 3 minnows. I didn't want to buy more since I only had them for cycling anyway. I just thought if I needed to increase the bioload I'd do it with the tank's intended occupants.

But alas, I've decided not to get a puffer in the recent future. This experience has proven that I need to spend some time tending to more forgiving fish. I need to learn simple fishkeeping skills like cycling before moving on to something as delicate as a figure eight. So, woot. I didn't make any drastic decisions!

I know this is a site for puffers, but does anyone have interesting suggestions for what to put in my 10 gal freshwater tank? I'm somewhat inclined to buy a few more feeder minnows and some plants and call it a day. I like how natural brown minnows get mixed into the rosie reds and make a kind of diverse school. Plus it's nice to pamper fishes that were about to be lunch. :-) And maybe I can get some cherry red shrimps anyway, since they're pretty.

Re: Gettin' Started!

Posted: Thu Nov 05, 2009 1:16 am
by kafkabeetle
Oh, and the bottle said it prevented nitrate and ammonia buildup.

Edit: At least it won't hurt anything. :-)

Re: Gettin' Started!

Posted: Thu Nov 05, 2009 1:48 am
by omplmpa3
I think when you decide that you're ready for puffers, you'll be great at keeping them! That fact that you realized they can be a delicate fish BEFORE you bought one pretty much proves it. Good for you!

I think the idea of pampering lunch is lovely. If you do decide on cherry shrimp, wait until your tank is cycled and has been running smoothly for a while. Shrimp are like canaries in a coal mine; the first to go if there's a problem.

Re: Gettin' Started!

Posted: Thu Nov 05, 2009 2:12 am
by LilGreenPuffer
kafkabeetle wrote:Oh, and the bottle said it prevented nitrate and ammonia buildup.
Nitrite or nitrate?

Re: Gettin' Started!

Posted: Fri Nov 06, 2009 1:18 am
by kafkabeetle
Nitrate is what it says...

Re: Gettin' Started!

Posted: Fri Nov 06, 2009 1:28 am
by Jivenjune
Nitrates are what are produced at the end of the cycling process. They are significantly less dangerous than ammonia and nitrite, but they are still harmful in very high doses (20+ ppm).

The cycling process is pretty simple.

Fish produce ammonia. Bacteria begins to grow inside the tank and converts ammonia into another harmful substance called nitrite. Another bacteria begins to grow that converts nitrites into less harmful nitrates.

Your tank is cycled when you have 0 ammonia, 0 nitrite, and traces of nitrates.

If you have a testing kit, you can easily do fishless cycling merely by monitoring when your ammonia, nitrite and nitrates fluctuate.

As for Tetra EasyBalance, I believe this is the stuff with the nitraban.

It has a simple job: it decreases the nitrates in your tank, which would theoretically allow someone more time before they have to change their water. However, nitrates are not the only substance that builds up. There are other hormones / toxins that gradually build up in water, so a water change would be necessary regardless.

Re: Gettin' Started!

Posted: Fri Nov 06, 2009 1:52 am
by LilGreenPuffer
+1. Except that after a fishless cycle, you'll probably have a lot of nitrates, so you'd do a massive water change before adding fish.

EasyBalance does not contain live bacteria. It will not help you cycle your tank. In fact, since it somehow eliminates ammonia, it will actually hurt your cycle.