Page 1 of 1

Lost 1 from a pair

Posted: Wed Oct 14, 2009 1:46 pm
by hammerkate20
We had a pair of GSPs that we've had for about 1 year and 1/2. They were the same size when we purchased them, but around the time we switched them to brackish one of them started getting bigger.. and the other didn't. Our Bigger one is about 3 to 4 inches and chubby and unfortunatly the smaller one passed away suddenly about 4 days ago.
We don't know whether to add another puffer or other fish to the tank. ( DO they get lonely?.). He has always had a tank mate. But we havn't heard good things about introducing a new tank mate.
We'd rather not. But we don't know what would make him a happier fish.
(I don't know the numbers on the tank off the top of my head.. but the water is clean, and brackish, and he is healthy).
Please let me know what you think.
thank You!
-Kate

Re: Lost 1 from a pair

Posted: Wed Oct 14, 2009 2:52 pm
by mrgreen
I just lost one of my two F8s this morning. I did a HUGE water change after testing my water. Turns out not only were my numbers very high in Ammonia, Nitrite and Nitrate, but there was a LOT of old food in the gravel. I am usually religious about my water changes, but...

If i were you, I'd get the numbers on your water levels and go from there.

Re: Lost 1 from a pair

Posted: Wed Oct 14, 2009 2:58 pm
by Myaj
Well, the easy answer to that question is another question.. is your tank big enough for another GSP? Adult GSP's are messy, large and territorial, so you need 30 gallon each as a good guideline. So unless your tank is 60 gallons or more, I would say no, do not get a new puffer "buddy".

There actually is an article in our library titled Alone but not Lonely.. talks about how puffers often make better "pets" when they are a singleton.. no worries about fighting, aggression and food battles, they seem to pay more attention to the people around them.

Re: Lost 1 from a pair

Posted: Wed Oct 14, 2009 3:16 pm
by pufferpuggirl
I know the general consensus is that puffers should be kept as singletons, but I have always thought that surely everything must want a companion at some point in time, of course I also know there is always an exception to the rule too .....

When I had my MBU in our community tank, there were a couple of Figure 8's in there too (yes, I have kept them in freshwater, not brackish), and they all liked to hang around together. When I moved BeeBoo, my MBU, to his own tank, I didn't move the F8's right away, and I do believe that BeeBoo was missing them, so we finally moved them over too and they all hang together now, never far from one another. We wondered if maybe BeeBoo thought the F8's were like him since the pattern on their body is similar to his?

But who knows what lurks in those little puffer brains! :?

**And by the way, welcome to the forum Kate! Nice to have you and your puffers along with us! :D

Re: Lost 1 from a pair

Posted: Wed Oct 14, 2009 5:05 pm
by hammerkate20
Thank you very much for the help. (I feel like a bad mommy for not using their names.. The original pair was "Wingus" and "Dingus" ). We were very sad to loose Dingus. Wingus seems to be doing VERY well.. He's a happy chubby puffer. and he's very playful. (Sometimes a little too playful at night when we're trying to sleep).. the tank is in our bedroom.. We think he's doing well on his own... But it was hard to think of him being lonely. We were thinking of his reaction in terms of how our dogs would behave if seperated. (We have two brothers from the same litter, and they're NEVER apart).

Re: Lost 1 from a pair

Posted: Wed Oct 14, 2009 5:20 pm
by Pufferpunk
[welcome]
How large is his tank? There is a great article in our Library about this: library/puffer-care/alone-but-not-lonel ... fers-solo/

Re: Lost 1 from a pair

Posted: Thu Oct 15, 2009 10:25 am
by hammerkate20
He's in a 50 gal right now.. by himself..
and so far the only behavorial difference I'm noticing is that he seems ALOT more interested in stuff going on outside the tank.
Byt the way, thank you for pointing me in the direction of the articles in the library.
They helped me feel alot better about him being on his own.
:D