Page 1 of 1

AC 30 vs Penguin 125

Posted: Wed Oct 07, 2009 3:16 pm
by Tank Girl
I have a small F8 puffer (barely 2" at this time) in a 10-gallon where he is fat and happy. He is a great eater and has lots of rocks and caves and archways, plus some plants that he keeps perforated for me... :lol:

I am not terribly happy with the filtration of the Penguin 125 that is on there - these are messy fish and I have to do a lot of PWCs, which I don't mind, but I would like to bump up the filtration a bit. I will be moving him to a 20 tall in the next few months, but right now I'd like to optimize this little setup.

For anyone who has had both, would an AquaClear 30 be any better, due to the better filter media, or would it be about the same?

TIA

Re: AC 30 vs Penguin 125

Posted: Wed Oct 07, 2009 3:36 pm
by side19
i would go with the aquaclear. i've never had penguins, but the only HOB filters i will use are the aquaclears or the marineland emperors. both great filter, but the aquaclears are better if working on a tighter budget.

Re: AC 30 vs Penguin 125

Posted: Wed Oct 07, 2009 4:25 pm
by Dadof4
The Aquaclear hands down. Some future planning things....if you are going to go to a 20 tall, I would go with an AC 70. You want to aim for 10x your tank volume at minimum and this would be more than adequate for that tank and if you decided to go up to a larger tank it will work also. It seems like over kill but if you go the AC 70 route you can keep going tank to tank without having to buy new filters. Already cycled and awesome filtration. Oh, and DFS has them on sale right now for the cost of the AC 50 and only $20 more than the AC 30.....

Re: AC 30 vs Penguin 125

Posted: Wed Oct 07, 2009 4:28 pm
by Myaj
I would agree, the AC 70 is a good size for around a 30 gallon tank. A bit much, for a 20, but too much is a good thing for puffers, they like current :)

I've never used Penguin filters, but my AC's have never failed me yet :)

Re: AC 30 vs Penguin 125

Posted: Thu Oct 08, 2009 12:25 am
by Pufferpunk
[welcome]
+1 on the AC.

Re: AC 30 vs Penguin 125

Posted: Thu Oct 08, 2009 1:24 am
by emartin
Aquaclear hands down.


BUT A NOTE ON THE AQUACLEARS. This seems to only be a problem with NEW larger units ac70 and 110 from my personal experience but if the new filter does not prime the siphon 100% (no air bubbles trapped and no gurgling noise) then your Aquaclear filter motor is defective. Exchange it for a new one immediately. That's what Hagen Customer support told me to do when I contacted them. I never had this problem with AC50 or below, it seems to just be the larger units that sometimes defective motors are packaged with the filter. You could just mail Hagen the motor and they will replace it but since your new filter is brand new, exchanging it is easier.

Enjoy the new filter! Aside from sump filters and sponge filters, AquaClear is my top choice for filtration!

Re: AC 30 vs Penguin 125

Posted: Thu Oct 08, 2009 10:13 am
by Myaj
emartin, good advice. I have two of the largest AC filters (what used to be the 500's) and they make a ton of noise and sometimes let out this horrible squealing.. the one hasn't done it in a long time, the other one I don't even use because it does it all the time. It never occurred to me that I should contact Hagen.

Re: AC 30 vs Penguin 125

Posted: Thu Oct 08, 2009 10:56 am
by Dadof4
Huh, I'm glad you said something as I keep recommending the AC70 right now because of the (usual) quality of AquaClear.

One filter I found that works real well is the Aqueon HOB Quiet filters. Offers chem, mech, biologic, and some wet/dry filtration for a relatively small price. Had to buy one when my Marineland Emperor went down and it keeps the water perfect and crystal clear. Hardly tell it's running too.

Re: AC 30 vs Penguin 125

Posted: Thu Oct 08, 2009 6:43 pm
by Lil' Swimz$
I also agree on the AC. I'm a fan of any HOB really.

My AC30 makes alot of bubbles. Not in the filter, but when the stream hits the water it makes a foam, along with a ton of bubbles.

Re: AC 30 vs Penguin 125

Posted: Thu Oct 08, 2009 7:02 pm
by Jivenjune
Tank Girl wrote:I have a small F8 puffer (barely 2" at this time) in a 10-gallon where he is fat and happy. He is a great eater and has lots of rocks and caves and archways, plus some plants that he keeps perforated for me... :lol:

I am not terribly happy with the filtration of the Penguin 125 that is on there - these are messy fish and I have to do a lot of PWCs, which I don't mind, but I would like to bump up the filtration a bit. I will be moving him to a 20 tall in the next few months, but right now I'd like to optimize this little setup.

For anyone who has had both, would an AquaClear 30 be any better, due to the better filter media, or would it be about the same?

TIA
Aesthetically, I love how aqua clear looks. Not all rounded off and opaque black. It's a nice shade of clearish gray and boxed off to feel more like it's an extension of your aquarium. I might just be talking out my arse, though.