Page 1 of 2

Have you ever had to settle?

Posted: Sun Aug 30, 2009 3:09 am
by ittybittyfishy
So I've been looking for places to buy fish online - though the idea terrifies me. I'm looking specifically for the red-eyed puffer/C. irrubesco. Can't find it anywhere!! Sigh.

Decided to go down to my LFS and talk to Theresa, the wonderful woman with whom my dad places all of his salt water fish orders. The store carries only a basic selection but has ordered specific fish for us before. Said fish were always kept in good conditions and she's made sure they look healthy and that we like them before taking them home! So, worth a shot, right? Had a chat with her but she didn't seem to know the kind of puffer I was talking about.

She did tell me they could get F8s and a 'leopard puffer' - which I later realized was a green spotted puffer, as well as dwarf puffers. She said she had never seen a "red-eyed" or "red-tailed" puffer on her list of available fish (from whatever supplier they have). Not only that, she said she doesn't get puffers in unless someone asks for them (me!!) so I would have to want one of those three for her to order for me - preferrably with a specific fish in mind.

Maintenance wise, I think dwarves would be the easiest, though they are less appealing to me. Perhaps it wouldn't hurt to forget about my 29g and just use my 10g for one or two, to introduce myself to the hobby?

Since F8s and GSPs are brackish (the latter BW to SW!) I'm hesitant, though confident that I could handle that. I would only want one for my 29g, though I'm concerned that the GSP would eventually outgrow the 29g and need a tank of about 40g/50g. Six inches is a whole lotta fish to me!

IN SHORT: Have you ever been in this predictament? Not getting the fish you originally wanted? How did it turn out?

What did you want, what did you get, and are you happy with the decision?

Did you settle for ordering the fish online, because you couldn't find it anywhere else?


ADVICE PLEASE!! :)

Re: Have you ever had to settle?

Posted: Sun Aug 30, 2009 3:14 am
by pufferfreak
Never get a fish you dont really want. Always wait cause it will be worth it. You may have to resort to buying online. thatpetplace.com i believe carries them. You might check there.

Re: Have you ever had to settle?

Posted: Sun Aug 30, 2009 3:29 am
by Bluntokian
In the same situation currently, Accept im not getting any GSP, because im a little nervous about SW for my first tank with anything outside Cichlids and goldfish

Re: Have you ever had to settle?

Posted: Sun Aug 30, 2009 3:50 am
by pufferfreak
SW FO are easy. Nothing to worry about really.

Re: Have you ever had to settle?

Posted: Sun Aug 30, 2009 4:02 am
by pufferfreak

Re: Have you ever had to settle?

Posted: Sun Aug 30, 2009 4:02 am
by Bluntokian
Its ok though, For me anyway as its not my money im spending. However if i was in your situation i would break down the tank as much as possible, Hide it from myself so im not tempted, Then when i see the fish i want set it up. If possible put it on hold at the store.

Re: Have you ever had to settle?

Posted: Sun Aug 30, 2009 12:39 pm
by LilGreenPuffer
I "settled" for dwarf puffers when I wanted a GSP, and I'm really happy with them. But I made this decision because I couldn't house a GSP for years. But if you can house the puffer you really want, then don't settle.

Re: Have you ever had to settle?

Posted: Sun Aug 30, 2009 2:26 pm
by pufferpuggirl
I've never had to "settle" yet because I work very hard to find the puffer I want, and even if I've had to wait, I usually end up with the puffer I'm after. :)

Keep in mind that we've traveled more than 150 miles in one day to get the puffer I'm after. You can ask my husband how diligent I am in finding puffers. If there's a puffer in England, and I want it, I will find it and eventually I will get it! :D

Re: Have you ever had to settle?

Posted: Mon Aug 31, 2009 11:18 am
by Pufferpunk
I live in a big city (Chicago), so it's pretty easy to shop around for what I want here. I'd just be patient & don't settle, unless you reallly fall in love.

Re: Have you ever had to settle?

Posted: Mon Aug 31, 2009 11:44 am
by bigfatfish
Been today to the lfs that had the GSPs that I saw last week (the first ones I have seen in years). Not to buy one, cos the tank isn't cycled yet, just to look. There are 7 in the tank - all have nipped fins, 2 are almost black & hiding at the back, 4 have grey/black tummies but are extremely active, although thin, & only one is lovely & round with a white tummy (still has nipped fins tho). Probably going to be another 2-3 weeks before I am ready to get one, so am I going to have to "settle" for one of these & hope that by getting it into a bigger tank & generally more suitable conditions, that it will come good? Or should I wait for more to come along? Even if I place an order, whose to say that one won't be in equally poor condition? Just worrying now, cos I haven't seen them for sale in so long, that I won't be able to get one. (why don't you live nearer schismy007?!!)

Re: Have you ever had to settle?

Posted: Mon Aug 31, 2009 11:53 am
by pufferpuggirl
Told you, bigfatfish, make a day-trip and come see all my puffers, I may have others you will want. :D

Re: Have you ever had to settle?

Posted: Mon Aug 31, 2009 12:32 pm
by Dadof4
One thing you can do is ask around at other LFS also and see if their suppliers can get them for you. Some places have more than one supplier so they have more of an availability to order from. Itsybitsy, where about are you from? If you're close to me I'll keep an eye out for them.

I myself would not settle but in truth, GSP are fantastic fish and will need a tank upgrade eventually, but that is a long time in coming as they are fairly slow growers IMHO.

Re: Have you ever had to settle?

Posted: Tue Sep 01, 2009 2:51 am
by ittybittyfishy
Dadof4: New Jersey, so unfortunately not near Wisconsin but thanks so much! :)

Asked around as I'm preparing my tank. The father unit and I have been unable to piece together any of the old filters! It's like a filter graveyard down stairs...

So he ordered me a new one by surprise! I told him I wanted one that could filter more than just the 29g, preferrably a higher/bigger one because of their waste/etc. He surprised me by getting one good enough for 50g so I'm excited! It's nice to share hobbies with the family. I love my dad lol

AND I found a red-eyed (irrubesco) puffer for sale on aquabid!! I almost screamed - but it's nearly 3AM here (what the hell am I doing looking for puffers at 3AM? lol) Sooo happy but they labeled the puffer as a "red-bellied puffer." I clicked it because I was sure I had never heard of one before and surprise! JACKPOT!! Hopefully the filter arrives soon so I can cycle. Though that will probably take a week or so.

I was thinking about adding some of the water we have from the 150g FW tank we have into my 29g tank. Would that help cycle?

Re: Have you ever had to settle?

Posted: Tue Sep 01, 2009 2:57 am
by pufferpuggirl
I think you looking at puffers at 3am just shows how much of a puffer-addict you are ittybittyfishy :D

Re: Have you ever had to settle?

Posted: Tue Sep 01, 2009 3:05 am
by Bluntokian
schismy007 wrote:I think you looking at puffers at 3am just shows how much of a puffer-addict you are ittybittyfishy :D
I agree, It is 3 AM here, Havent got any sleep and im still looking