Page 1 of 2

Just a Few Fish!

Posted: Thu Aug 27, 2009 4:48 pm
by pufferpuggirl
Whilst perusing some recent classifieds for aquariums, fish, etc., I came across an advert that just made it plain to me that people really don't know what they are doing.

Take a look at this list of fish:
6 Orange Parrot fish
20-30 Blue Acara cichlids
8 Plecostomus (ranging from 4" to 14", all different species)
10 Angelfish
2 Kissing Gouramis
2 Opaline Gouramis
Breeding pair of Swordtails
2 Reed fish
2 Pangasius catfish (11" female & 4" male)
1 Synodontis cat
1 African Spotted cat
1 Snakehead
! Albino Rainbow Shark 3"
1 Elephant nose
7 Buenos Aires Tetras (large)
6 unnamed large Tetras

Can you imagine all of those fish in a 4' x 2' x 2' tank? Yep, for real. That was an advert for that tank for sale, but you had to take the fish with the tank. I cannot imagine why someone would want to stick all those fish in the same tank. Don't people research what they are buying? I really feel sorry for fish. I swear, since getting involved in fish-keeping more seriously, I have a entirely new empathy for fish. What was this guy thinking when he bought all those fish? :(

Is it just me, or does anyone else feel that this tank, besides being way over-stocked, was just full of the wrong fish to be together? :shock:

Re: Just a Few Fish!

Posted: Thu Aug 27, 2009 4:56 pm
by bigfatfish
I'm afraid I don't know much about the individual species, except that synodontis cats are a shoaling (not sure thats spelt right!) fish, so shame to think of them on their own. There looks to be masses of fish for the tank size & as you say, so many different sorts - can't be right.

Re: Just a Few Fish!

Posted: Thu Aug 27, 2009 5:09 pm
by pufferpuggirl
Well I've got a 4-foot tank that's just a little bit smaller than the one I mentioned, and I cannot imagine even having half the amount of fish that's in that tank. Just the plecostomus' alone would be more than enough to fill that tank, not to mention those 20-30 cichlids!! :shock:

Re: Just a Few Fish!

Posted: Thu Aug 27, 2009 5:29 pm
by bigfatfish
I think people must get carried away with all the beautiful fish that are available & how great the aquarium looks, but forget about the needs of the individuals.

Re: Just a Few Fish!

Posted: Fri Aug 28, 2009 1:08 am
by Bluntokian
well i used to keep cichlids and i can tell right now alot of cichlid keepers do controlled over stocking and as long as you do it almost perfect (massive water changes sometimes daily or more in the most extreme cases extra food mass scrubbing ect) it can be done succesfully although i dont find it entirely ok for the individual it really does very little harm to fish if the m/f ratios are kept up towards 1/8 and can alot of times look incredible

Re: Just a Few Fish!

Posted: Fri Aug 28, 2009 1:28 am
by ittybittyfishy
I don't think people are worried about the aggression of the fish towards one another. I think we're definitely upset that it's TOO. MANY. FISH. Period. Doesn't matter who's what gender, that's just too many fish and will no doubt lead to stunting. Or, as with over crowding, jumpers flying out the tank to their untimely death from either their own nerves or being chased. Unnacceptable. :/

Re: Just a Few Fish!

Posted: Fri Aug 28, 2009 1:30 am
by Bluntokian
didnt say i agreed with it now im just sayin that from my experiences i have seen little stress in the fish as long as with puffers for example you stay in certain peramaters

Re: Just a Few Fish!

Posted: Fri Aug 28, 2009 1:38 am
by ittybittyfishy
And I'm just reitterating that about 82 fish in a roughly 120gallon tank is pretty rediculous - no harm done to you.

That's about a gallon and a half per fish. It hurts my brain to even think about.

Re: Just a Few Fish!

Posted: Fri Aug 28, 2009 1:46 am
by Bluntokian
cant argue with that i would done tried to swim into the impeller lol :D

Re: Just a Few Fish!

Posted: Fri Aug 28, 2009 3:49 am
by pufferpuggirl
ittybittyfishy wrote:And I'm just reitterating that about 82 fish in a roughly 120gallon tank is pretty rediculous - no harm done to you.

That's about a gallon and a half per fish. It hurts my brain to even think about.
Yeah, and that's not even considering that Angelfish need a very warm tank. From what I know of snakeheads they are predators and will eat most things smaller than themselves. I have some Buenos Aires Tetras and they can be fairly aggressive fish. And several of the species on that list will grow to be quite large. It's just such a mish-mash of species that I can't imagine what was in that person's mind when they bought them all! :?

Re: Just a Few Fish!

Posted: Fri Aug 28, 2009 11:41 am
by Bluntokian
schismy007 wrote: It's just such a mish-mash of species that I can't imagine what was in that person's mind when they bought them all! :?
answer: OOOH!!! PRETTY COLORS!!! *one guy looks at the other* hey man lets get some acid i bet that would be kool *other guy* lets go!

lol dont do drugs kids...bad things (like that) happen

Re: Just a Few Fish!

Posted: Fri Aug 28, 2009 11:54 am
by groovitudedude
The snakehead is gonna clean out that tank I think, and I doubt the elephant nose will last more than a couple weeks (or days)

:(

Re: Just a Few Fish!

Posted: Fri Aug 28, 2009 12:03 pm
by pufferpuggirl
Yeah it's like someone just didn't give this any thought at all. It just seemed really silly to me, and what's worse, if you want the tank, you MUST take all those fish with it! What a mess that will be. :(

Re: Just a Few Fish!

Posted: Fri Aug 28, 2009 12:22 pm
by diverchic
that's when an arrangement with the lfs to take A LOT of fish comes into play

Re: Just a Few Fish!

Posted: Fri Aug 28, 2009 12:27 pm
by marksrush
I see stuff like this literally every day at the pet store where I work. From my experience, I'd say that less than 15% of the people who come in for fish have done even the slightest research on any aspect of running an aquarium, from initial setup all the way to choosing fish to introduce into their cycled tank. Don't get me wrong: I love explaining it all to them, but it's just something that I find amazing - and frankly, I'd bet that most of what I tell them goes in one ear and out the other. I learned early on that these people, or at least the good ones who care about what they're doing, depend solely on us employees for instructions and information, and that is why it's so critically important that they get accurate information from LFS staffers. (Which as you all know is rare.)

It's actually this way with any animal we have in the store. It kind of scares you when someone points at a chinchilla, asks what it is, then five minutes later wants to buy it.