Page 1 of 1

How many is too many?

Posted: Sat Aug 22, 2009 3:23 pm
by robert_hollis
First off, I wasn't sure if this post belongs in here, under freshwater tanks, or freshwater puffers... So, if I picked the wrong spot, my bad.

Anyhow, I was thinking on the whole issue of people overstocking their tanks and I got to wondering if maybe my tank is overstocked. I've read the estimates on how many gallons per each type of fish, and what not, so I'm not asking for that info. Just looking at the tank, I'd say no. Also, by tracking the water conditions I'd say no. However, I could be wrong. I'd like some opinions...

I have a 50g fully cycle freshwater tank. In that tank are some pond snails and shrimp (ghost and cherry), plus a small assortment of plants (8 aponogetons, a small anubias, several small java ferns, some java moss, and a clump of anacharis). I'm also working on growing some more aponogetons, water sprite, and some other aquatic plant that I dunno what it is (kinda looks like cabomba). My tank has river rocks (about 1/2 - 2/3 golfball size) some driftwood, a large chunk of holey rock with some great hiding holes in it (My pleco hides in one big hole), 4 pvc pipe caves, a busted terra cotta cave, and a plastic pestmart cave. I 'think' this is enough hiding spots, but I dunno. the hardware in the tank is a canister filter, an air pump, a heater, and a koralia powerhead.

My fish residents are:
1 South American Puffer
1 rubber lip pleco
6 neon tetra
5 zebra danios
1 black neon tetra (he thinks he's a zebra danio though)

Does anyone think this is overstocking?

I also have a dozen or so fry that I'm rearing in a different tank. I think they're zebra danios, but I dunno, because they were accidental offspring... I'm hoping to get at least 3 healthy adults out of them to put in my 50g tank.

When my LFS gets some more puffers in, I want to buy 2 more SAPs to go in this tank.

Would all of that make for too crowded a tank?

I don't really have any more plans for that tank except to add more plants, and maybe increase my neon tetra population at some point.

All of my fish seem to be healthy, and my water is nice and clear and when I test it, it's always good.

Anyhow... Opinions are welcome.

Thanks,

-Rob

Re: How many is too many?

Posted: Sat Aug 22, 2009 3:36 pm
by bigfatfish
You should have the SAPs in a group of at least 3 & preferably more. If you do this, then your tank will be overstocked. I love puffers, so can't imagine why you would want anything in with them!! Other opinions from the experts will no doubt follow soon.

Re: How many is too many?

Posted: Sat Aug 22, 2009 3:38 pm
by LilGreenPuffer
That black tetra needs another five tankmates.

Re: How many is too many?

Posted: Sat Aug 22, 2009 4:02 pm
by pufferpuggirl
And your SAP really will be much happier with some mates of it's own, at least 3, but 5 is a good number too!

Re: How many is too many?

Posted: Sat Aug 22, 2009 4:07 pm
by robert_hollis
I only have one puffer, because the store only had one left when I got him. That's why I'm waiting for 2 more.

As to the black tetra... He started off as part of a group of 6, but the other 5 died one by one. I keep thinking about getting more, but I was a bit put off by the deaths of the others. Plus, he really has adopted the zebra danios as his shoal. He schools with them, and swims around with them and sleeps with them and everything.

I have my other 50g, I keep debating fixing the leak in, and setting back up, but... I hate resealing tanks.

Thanks for the input,

-Rob

Re: How many is too many?

Posted: Sat Aug 22, 2009 7:53 pm
by Sponge bob
LilGreenPuffer wrote:That black tetra needs another five tankmates.
Im not to sure about that. I had a lone tetra and he thought he was another kind

Re: How many is too many?

Posted: Mon Aug 24, 2009 10:49 am
by robert_hollis
Really what I was wondering about is the psychological effect of so many fish in so much space. I mean, there has to be some point where the fish have plenty of filtration and swimming room, but still get sick of seeing each other. I haven't seen any aggressive behavior (unless you count the danios mating rituals), and the only time I ever saw the puffer turn on another fish was when he decided he wanted the blood worm one of the danios had in it's mouth. He didn't bite it, but he chased it around the tank for a minute or so before realizing there were several more bloodworms floating in the water.

I also have to say that having a powerhead is great for feeding time, because I can dump the food right in the stream, and watch the fish go nuts as it shoots across the tank, but the fish rarely ever swim in the current it creates. They all seem to like swimming down the cascade of bubbles created by the 4" airstone, though. I almost wonder if I didn't get a powerful enough powerhead, or if my fish are just picky swimmers.

-Rob

Re: How many is too many?

Posted: Mon Aug 24, 2009 10:50 am
by LilGreenPuffer
If you think that they look crowded, then they are, regardless of bioload.

Re: How many is too many?

Posted: Mon Aug 24, 2009 11:08 am
by Pufferpunk
Heavy decor can help them with the psycological effects, as everyone has their own territory. I think it's horrible when I see an empty tank with loads of fish just swimming back & forth with nothing to do!